3 ms·
the law obviously allows Google to not have any measures in place that bar their users from uploading pirated music. Didn't Limewire just lose despite making t
by eli 16y ago
the law obviously allows Google to not have any measures in place that bar their users from uploading pirated music.
Didn't Limewire just lose despite making that argument? I mean, granted that unlike Google Limewire probably was encouraging infringement, but it seems like an awfully fine line.
- nextparadigms 16y agoGoogle Music is effectively a file locker. File lockers are not illegal.
- jbellis 16y agoThen again, the labels shut down mp3.com's music locker 10 years ago.
- ugh 16y agoMy.mp3.com did not at all work like what Google is doing. Looking only at experience the end user is having, the difference is minimal to non-existent but that’s not what the law cares about. (My personal opinion is that what my.mp3.com was doing should be legal just as what Google is doing is clearly legal. The distinction the law is making in that respect doesn’t make any practical sense.)
- ugh 16y agoWhat Google offers is very different from LimeWire. It doesn’t even allow users to make their music public or share it. It’s just storage space with some special music features. It specifically doesn’t encourage or enable users to pirate music.
- hugh3 16y agoWhat Google offers is very different from LimeWire. It doesn’t even allow users to make their music public or share it Is that so, though? What if people start uploading music to accounts and then publishing the login details? Bingo bango, free google-hosted public radio station!
- cleverjake 16y agowhat and what if people start sharing keys to their houses? they'd be able to share music that way too. Why would anyone use such a convoluted way of sharing music when they can just continue to download it the way they have been for 10 years. Anyone that determined to share music will find other ways of doing it.