4 ms·
>We want them to be really really good at following orders and not to think I know this is common trope but tends to be more widely held by those with limited
by bumby 6y ago
>We want them to be really really good at following orders and not to think
I know this is common trope but tends to be more widely held by those with limited military experience.
For example, U.S. Marines are often considered highly disciplined (sometimes conflated with being very good at blindly following orders). From boot camp onward, they are encouraged (sometimes mandated) to read from the Commandant’s reading list. A perennial favorite to assign junior enlisted is A Message to Garcia. However, after nearly 40 years, it was removed from the list explicitly because the message was often misinterpreted as advocating strict obedience and went against the intent to promote independent thought.
Particularly in counter insurgency, the military wants/needs critical thinking, not blind obedience.
- croissants 6y agoDoes the military want critical thinking from its lowest soldiers? As a person with close to no military knowledge, my understanding is that the U.S. Marines are more of an "elite" group and might therefore be more empowered as decision-makers.
- bumby 6y agoIn general, I would say yes. I think there is a realization that a counter insurgency will struggle if low ranking troops are not thinking clearly. A single bad decision from a Lance Corporal can erode months/years of effort or escalate into an international incident. Actually, I believe the Marines have the lowest intellectual bar of entry and the highest physical one for any branch. To your point, they do push small unit leadership to a lower level, which may be why they try to advocate a leadership mindset at low levels.
- scruple 6y agoThe USMC Leadership Principles are public [0]. The Army Leadership Principles are, as well, [1]. They're worth reading. [0]: MCTP 206-10B, Appendix B: https://www.marines.mil/portals/1/Publications/MCTP%206-10B%20(Formerly%20MCRP%206-11B).pdf?ver=2016-06-27-164041-660 https://www.marines.mil/portals/1/Publications/MCTP%206-10B%... [1]: ADRP 6-22: https://www.benning.army.mil/mssp/pdf/adrp6_22_new.pdf https://www.benning.army.mil/mssp/pdf/adrp6_22_new.pdf
- KLexpat 6y agoThe critical thinking that the military does not want is "Why am I here" or "Why is the United States here". Tactical/execution ingenuity is favoured; philosophical or political consideration for whether or not a war should be happening in the first place is more likely to be pathologised as "treason"