4 ms·
It's obvious in retrospect. Microsoft was about taking over people's hardware (i.e., protecting Windows' installed base), VMware is about helping people utiliz
by marshray 16y ago
It's obvious in retrospect.
Microsoft was about taking over people's hardware (i.e., protecting Windows' installed base), VMware is about helping people utilize their hardware to its full potential. It turns out that one of the fundamental thing we want to do with modern workstation and server hardware is run multiple OS instances on it simultaneously.
This surely sounded subversive, scary, illegal, and weird to MS leadership who expected users to do web, games, mail, and office apps on their hardware. MS required a per-instance license anyway, so how could they lose?
That said, I've heard good things about MS's virtualization technology, aside from the little problem of it requiring Windows for the base OS.
- techsupporter 16y agoUsing Hyper-V no longer requires installing Windows. The hypervisor can be installed on its own (for free, even): https://www.microsoft.com/hyper-v-server/en/us/default.aspx https://www.microsoft.com/hyper-v-server/en/us/default.aspx (Disclaimer: My group supports Hyper-V server.)
- marshray 16y agoLooks interesting, thanks.
- gaius 16y agoWell it is more subtle than that. No sane organization runs multiple OSs for the sake of it. The ideal number is two or three: it hedges your bets against one OS vendor doing something unfortunate and yet keeps your support costs down. So why do you want to run multiple OSs on the same hardware? Because your apps already exist on those OSs. It's all about the apps, always was, OSs are just plumbing. And you are completely wrong about MS: they fully expect people to be running SQL Server, IIS, Exchange and the rest of their back-end on Windows too. The problem always was, it's difficult to run all those together on one Windows instance which is why you would have lots of boxes. A hypervisor running n Windows instances, each of which running one MS server product is an ideal situation for MS.
- marshray 16y agoAny nontrivial organization around for a sufficient period of time will end up with a collection of old servers running various apps. The accounting system. The document management solution purchased 5 years ago. The sprinker system. The program that's needed to recover data from the old backup tapes that everyone hopes will never be needed. And so on. Many of these apps can never be migrated to newer OSes, nor can they be switched off (yet). These are often good candidates for virtualization. A hypervisor running n Windows instances, each of which running one MS server product is an ideal situation for MS. OK. But in the real world we deal with systems other than the ideal situation for MS.
- gaius 16y agoMmm, but my point is: if you run VMware instead of Hyper-V and run Windows on it, it's still revenue for MS.