15 ms·
Why FSF Endorsing PureOS Matters
- pjmlp 6y agoWell, I ended up reading the post about gaming as well. https://puri.sm/posts/gaming-that-respects-you/ https://puri.sm/posts/gaming-that-respects-you/ > The Librem 5 features high quality, free games that respect you. Play 2D and 3D games without ads, without in-app purchases, and without tracking. Don't expect much uptake from game studios, when the selling point of the platform is not to pay for games.
- Bancakes 6y agoI love how serious they are with Tux Kart. That was the prime example they could cherrypick.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoI've semi-recently gotten into Cataclysm: Dark Days Ahead. I think a lot of roguelikes are opensource. Being opensource and easy to extend gives it an enormous developer base.
- IggleSniggle 6y agoI am always so excited to see this game mentioned outside of its Reddit forum. I haven’t played it since 0.C, but I poured countless hours in and cherish many memories of hapless heroes and their ignoble deaths.
- Bancakes 6y agoLove roguelikes. Ever played IVAN?
- anthk 6y agoSupertuxKart today is hugely improved graphically, on par on WiiU graphics (not bad for a childish racer), and with netplay support. Also, Minetest with the Dreamworld MOD lacks nothing from Minecraft.
- pjmlp 6y agoWiiU graphics is a low bar given its hardware graphical capabilities are on par with DX 10, a 14 year old API.
- DC-3 6y agoI'm a libre software advocate but I see little reason why games should be libre. They're not tools - you don't use them to create things or to do your job. They're more akin to movies - compiled and packaged 'experiences' that are by design read-only. When you buy a DVD, you don't expect hundreds of hours of unedited footage to come along with the film so you can cut together your own version. The same is true of games.
- jcelerier 6y ago> When you buy a DVD, you don't expect hundreds of hours of unedited footage to come along with the film so you can cut together your own version. instead of accepting this as a fact of life, it should definitely be discussed and debated. What are good reasons for not having this right by default ? For instance, Star Wars fans have made the despecialized edition from footage from the various movie - the result is pretty good. People remix music all the time; there have been plenty of initiatives over the years to provide songs as separated tracks to allow for more advanced remixes. etc etc...
- adwn 6y ago> What are good reasons for not having this right by default ? The good reason is that someone or some company paid for creating all those hundreds of hours of footage, so they get the first and final say over who gets to view and/or use it.
- mainstreemm 6y agoFor first release, sure. But forever? Why? If I want to remix Steamboat Willie in 2020 why should Disney still have an exclusive right to that today?
- Brian_K_White 6y agoThat is not a reason or an answer to that question. No one denies that whoever creates something has the right to dispose of it however they wish. Having the legal right to annoy your own customers is not a good reason to annoy your own customers. The question was why couldn't the material be packaged up in any other ways? What's the "good reason" it can't be? Does it kill any babies?
- UweSchmidt 6y agoI like that they have a vision for the ecosystem they are building, which includes gaming. If I understand correctly up-front payments for games should be possible? "Not paying for games" does not seem to be a selling point for PureOS.
- nfoz 6y agoYou have ads in your games? I pay tons of money on games, on many platforms. But ads/tracking/in-app purchases? That sounds like an awful mess.
- kobalsky 6y agoWell, bad news, you are a minority. Phones have changed (destroyed) the landscape. Did you know that King with their Candy Crush and other saga games almost double the operating income of Blizzard with all their legendary lineup? [1]. 1. https://www.investopedia.com/how-activision-blizzard-makes-money-4799286 https://www.investopedia.com/how-activision-blizzard-makes-m...
- duxup 6y ago>without in-app purchases Is that so bad? There are certainly a lot of loot box patterns that are unseemly, but I'm not sure I understand a wholesale prohibition of in-app purchases entirely.
- simonh 6y agoI won't touch pay to win crap like loot boxes and coins, but IAP for additional content like maps and levels and such is absolutely fine.
- addicted 6y agoYou can always sell those as an expansion pack. It reduces nickel and diming and encourages game developers to create high quality content that they can actually sell as a proper expansion, as opposed to little bits that the user has to pay while in the middle of their game, often in order to achieve something that may barely be possible without spending that in app money in addition to what they've already spent.
- DerekL 6y agoBut expansion packs are usually sold inside the game. The term in-app purchase is imprecise.
- addicted 6y ago> without ads, without in-app purchases, and without tracking I don't see where they are discouraging paying for games? I do see them discouraging insidious tracking, advertisements masquerading as gameplay, and lottery systems designed to enrich the game developer at the expense of the actual gamer.
- zlsa 6y agoFrom the previous sentence: > The Librem 5 features high quality, free games that respect you.
- fsflover 6y agoFree as in freedom, not price: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_software.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoI think it's the "free games" part. I think they mean free as in freedom, but is it also free as in beer too? "Free" is such an unfortunate word, because in other languages it only means "gratis". "Libre", as in LibreOffice, is better.
- mdoms 6y agoI agree, when you take a few words completely out of their original context then the statement makes no sense.
- quadrifoliate 6y agoI think that since they are discussing the FSF, they just mean that the source of the games will be freely available and redistributable to people who are paying for the software. I don't think this is materially different from models like Humble Bundle, which feature vastly discounted prices for games. Addendum: People looking at "free" and thinking "you don't have to pay for them!" makes me feel both old and pessimistic. Is the "free as in speech, not as in beer" thing just a byline at this point? I remember reading about it and being pretty excited by the concept ~15 years ago, and it seems that it was pretty common in the software industry to understand the distinction; especially in the context of the FSF.
- craftyguy 6y agoThey mean 'free' as in freedom, not 'free' as in beer. There's a (huge) difference.
- Galanwe 6y agoThe article really mixes up "being free" and "having FSF validation". While having FSF validation is indeed some kind of proof of due diligence, in the end what really matters is the trust that users place in the project itself in following their guidelines. I do not have a particularly strong trust for the (modern) FSF, so their validation adds nothing, IMHO, in my trust in Purism.
- holri 6y agoWhy do you have no strong trust in modern FSF?
- Galanwe 6y agoIt's hard to answer this without potentially starting a flame war. I can see that some comments start to explode already. Still, let me try to explain my mistrust constructively. Let me just start by saying that trust is a very personal feeling. We give trust to others based on criteria that are different. I completely understand that my points listed below are not relevant trust indicators for others. That being said, I have 2 main mistrust issues with FSF: 1) Leadership I had various occasions to interact with RSM over the years, in various contexts. I do not have a fond memory of those interactions. - I remember someone which is very difficult to have a real conversation with. Very childish and binary in his view of the world. Prompt to not listen to arguments, talking louder than others, turning arguments into jokes, etc. - I worked and know plenty of people who worked with him in various academic labs where he's been invited to give talks or work on subjects. The same complaints emerged all the time: he would grossly hit on female PhD students (just enough to make them uncomfortable), always tried to be hosted by someone and would not even shower there, very rarely participate in the big picture of why he was invited (e.g. He would lock himself in a room for 2 days straight to fix some esoteric emacs bug on an archaic platform, instead of just organizing seminars on free software and participate in discussions), he would act in very narcissistic ways (e.g. After proposing to go to a restaurant, he would then propose - and insist grossly - to pay the bill with his autograph on a printed copy of emacs source code). He would constantly rant on closed source computers and cell phones, but will gladly borrow anyone's phone to make international calls. I stop here because I just have too much random echos of his not-so-pleasant behavior. Overall most of my personal interactions with RSM, as well as friend's recollections picture him as gross, childish, and narcissistic. Now RSM himself is not the FSF as a whole, but I have a hard time trusting an organization that is so centered around a single individual which embodies traits that I do not appreciate. 2) The organization members I did not have direct relation with other FSF members, but I have been contributor to projects where the FSF intervened (or tried to) in the governance. Most of the time, the FSF members were never contributors to the projects. Yet they were the one trying to dictate the tone and direction, and act like they owned the projects based on their moral high ground. This has led me to associate FSF members as some kind of a self proclaimed elite class of zealots, exempt of technical knowledge and actual contributions, but still willing to be heard. This goes directly against my view of governance of open source projects, in which I believe the actual contributors should be ones to set the tone and direction of the project, because they are the one building it. --- Again, all this is mainly personal feelings, so I don't want to look like I'm trying to influence others into distrusting FSF. I understand that my interactions with RSM were in a certain context and that he maybe could be a very pleasant person in a different situation. And I also understand that my interactions with other FSF members were limited to the projects I contributed to, and there may be thousands of others where they were helping and constructive.
- 7e 6y agoWhich one of the FSF’s dozen employees made this endorsement?
- fsflover 6y agohttps://www.gnu.org/distros/free-distros.en.html https://www.gnu.org/distros/free-distros.en.html
- moocowtruck 6y agothese people are crooks why would FSF endorse them?
- SiebenHeaven 6y agoWhy do you say that? (genuine question)
- vinceguidry 6y agoI have a Purism Librem 13. It's sitting on a shelf somewhere because the battery won't charge anymore, the barrel connector is too loose. Purism tech support was no help at all. Another minor issue, the screws weren't held in by any kind of loctite and they just fall out after awhile if I don't remember to periodically tighten them. Like 4 of those screws are missing. And the rubber feet just had the worst adhesive on them, so they're gone. Until the thing just plain stopped working on me all of a sudden, it was great.
- LMYahooTFY 6y agoI wouldn't say that it doesn't matter. I think that propagating the values of free software is important, so I'm certainly supportive to a large degree. But I think HN is the place to discuss nuances such as these: Firstly, it's very unclear to me how Purism and the FSF reconcile the FSF criteria regarding 'Nonfree Firmware' with the blobs on the device. It's also unclear to me what the distinction is between this part of the criteria and the RYF certification. https://ryf.fsf.org/about/criteria https://ryf.fsf.org/about/criteria Furthermore, the FSF's criteria regarding non-free firmware seems problematic, and it directly affects the Librem. Purism has been working with the FSF in pursuit of the RYF certification, and all of the responses I've found seem to be somewhat evasive of the fact that it may be the Librem will not get firmware updates, and that this is in accordance with RYF criteria. https://forums.puri.sm/t/does-respects-your-freedom-certification-allow-updating-of-proprietary-firmware/9484/14 https://forums.puri.sm/t/does-respects-your-freedom-certific... The response from the CSO almost confirms this. I find a lack of firmware updates to be possibly more of a concern than whether or not only my application CPU is running only free software. What the FSF and company define as 'software' also still seems to be problematic.
- fsflover 6y ago> I find a lack of firmware updates to be possibly more of a concern Why are you suggesting that one can't change the firmware? In your link, Purism CSO explicitly said you would be able to do it: > I would expect that we would document the process in our Librem 5 developer docs at some point, when it’s relevant (such as when there’s an update to apply).
- LMYahooTFY 6y agoThe CSO explicitly said they "expect" you can, and "at some point" it will be documented. They have yet to explicitly state in any way that they will ensure firmware receives security updates.
- fsflover 6y agoThis is true, but it doesn’t mean it’s impossible.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoThe FSF is too dogmatic. I love this page: https://www.gnu.org/distros/common-distros.en.html https://www.gnu.org/distros/common-distros.en.html "Debian's Social Contract states the goal of making Debian entirely free software, and Debian conscientiously keeps nonfree software out of the official Debian system. However, Debian also maintains a repository of nonfree software." So shipping free software isn't even enough for admission to the FSFs special club. Right. I've stopped listening to anything Stallman says.
- tomcam 6y agoOnly Stallman can define freedom, prole. No wonder you’re not in the club.
- jabl 6y ago> The FSF is too dogmatic. In other news, water is wet. More seriously, yeah there's a place for ideological organizations that broadcast their philosophy and won't budge when moneyed interests try to push them around. But such organizations also tend to be difficult to work with if you just want to get stuff done.
- blitblitblit 6y agoAnd in still other ways this endorsement is hypocritical to their own dogma: https://web.archive.org/web/20161010040458/https://blogs.coreboot.org/blog/2015/02/23/the-truth-about-purism-why-librem-is-not-the-same-as-libre/ https://web.archive.org/web/20161010040458/https://blogs.cor...
- rando832 6y agoJust no. Your link is about coreboot. The FSF endorsement is of PureOS (does not contain coreboot).
- cogburnd02 6y ago> The FSF is too dogmatic. I disagree. They have a moral value system, and they adhere to it. Just like (say) Roman Catholicism. The FSF's point of view is that by providing repositories (which make installing a program a single command-line or a few GUI-clicks away) that's not functionally different from that being a part of the operating system. So providing repositories of nonfree software is functionally equivalent to including that software in the OS itself. And to have software freedom, then all the software on a machine must respect the user's freedom; i.e. be free software.