6 ms·
Anime is not the dominant form of media in Japan, and is largely targeted at a relatively narrow age band. Outside of the main target demographic, you're not go
by jcranmer 6y ago
Anime is not the dominant form of media in Japan, and is largely targeted at a relatively narrow age band. Outside of the main target demographic, you're not going to get a lot of familiarity with anything but the very largest show.
In the US, how many current animated shows can you name? I can name a decent fraction of cartoons from the late 90s, but am completely unable to name anything since then--at least until I got a nephew and am now getting acquainted with the relevant demographic shows. That's a 20 year gap in shows.
Compare other media. How many classical composers can you name? I doubt many people, even erudite people, could push well beyond the basic frontier of Bach, Beethoven, and Mozart. Recognition of well-known tunes (such as Pachelbel's Canon, whose name my spellchecker doesn't appear to recognize) is going to far exceed their name, let alone the composer's name.
The most recognizable anime to a layperson in Japan is likely to be the big mega-blockbusters of various eras. I'd be more shocked if you said that no one had heard of Mobile Suit Gundam, Dragonball, Naruto, or Attack on Titan [which one they'd pick up on depends on their age] than any of the shows you've mentioned. Hell, the only thing you listed that I'd think people in the US with a passing familiarity with anime might know would be Cowboy Bebop.
- tayo42 6y agoIsn't ghibli a big deal? Atleast that's what one person told me in Tokyo.
- fomine3 6y agoAnime for kids is always mainstream content. Anime for non-kids is not mainstream but not very niche, it getting very popular for around 10-30s age people compared to around 2000. Pachinko and mobile games (both makes $$, publish ads) also contributes for otaku contents' popularity.
- mudita 6y ago> Hell, the only thing you listed that I'd think people in the US with a passing familiarity with anime might know would be Cowboy Bebop. Really? He listed Akira! From Wikipedia: > The film had a production budget of ¥700 million ($5.5 million), making it the most expensive anime film at the time > The film had a significant impact on popular culture worldwide, paving the way for the growth of anime and Japanese popular culture in the Western world As an aside, I was a performer in this performance piece: https://www.artbasel.com/news/messeplatz-alexandra-pirici-glossary https://www.artbasel.com/news/messeplatz-alexandra-pirici-gl... It uses "gestures and sounds which are taken from both natural and popular media sources, Pirici renders disparate forms of heritage and cultural memory, conceiving Aggregate as a time capsule in which fragments of vernacular culture, art history, and everyday life are given new, living embodiments." I was surprised when out of a diverse selection of materials from world culture, the choreographer also chose to include the theme song from Ghost in the shell.
- totetsu 6y agoDonna Harraway's A Cyborg Manifesto is/was a widly read text in media studies. it could be one way many crative types are sure to have heard of Ghost in shell.
- schrijver 6y ago-> Donna <- Harraway
- totetsu 6y agoThanks.
- mudita 6y agoThanks a lot for this reference. I am a professional dancer and phd student in machine learning and starting to combine these fields for an art project, but I wasn’t aware of Donna Harraway, this could actually be really helpful to me.
- BurningCycles 6y ago>Anime is not the dominant form of media in Japan, and is largely targeted at a relatively narrow age band But it seems very popular, out of the top ten highest grossing films in Japan, 5 are anime (Spirited Away, Demon Slayer, Your Name, Princess Mononoke, Howl's Moving Castle), and the top two are Spirited Away and Demon Slayer. In North America's top ten you will only find one animated feature, Incredibles 2, and it is at position ten.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> The most recognizable anime to a layperson in Japan is likely to be the big mega-blockbusters of various eras. I'd be more shocked if you said that no one had heard of Mobile Suit Gundam, Dragonball, Naruto, or Attack on Titan [which one they'd pick up on depends on their age] Sailor Moon?
- Freak_NL 6y agoOr Doraemon.
- m4rtink 6y agoSazae-san ?
- bitwize 6y agoJust think, somewhere in Japan there might've been a "Weird America" article in the late 90s about American male and female college students' fascination with Sailor Moon, which was clearly intended for little girls. Two decades later, a followup might compare the Sailor Moon phenomenon with the fascination among adult American men for the Western series My Little Pony.
- timoth3y 6y ago> Anime is not the dominant form of media in Japan, and is largely targeted at a relatively narrow age band. Outside of the main target demographic, you're not going to get a lot of familiarity with anything but the very largest show. The top two highest grossing films in Japan are both anime; Spirited Away and Demon Slayer. Titanic follows at a distant third. Forth is Frozen, which you could argue is basically anime. I live in Japan, and most anime is not really my thing, but its huge and definitely mainstream here.
- Freak_NL 6y agoStudio Ghibli (maker of Spirited Away) is in a league of its own though. That specific outlier aside; I get the impression that cartoons in Europe and the US picked up quite a bit of slack in the adult demographic with shows like Archer and Rick & Morty in the past decade, building on what Adult Swim prepared in the US. In Japan this niche was already much more explored, although it is not a pass-time most adults flaunt. While I never got the impression that adult viewers of anime were anything more than a (sizeable) minority, they are certainly a target demographic, and manga (comics) even more so. One example that always stuck out to me was former prime minister Asō Tarō who openly admitted to being quite well-read in manga.
- boraoztunc 6y agoI watched "10 Years with Hayao Miyazaki" [1] recently, besides knowing his stubborn character and artist life, and the work they do at Studio Ghibli is pretty outstanding, as terms of time, effort and dedication. There is also an indie movie, "Never Ending Man" [2] they shot after he suddenly announced his retirement at the age of 72, but later came back with his first CGI project. Years of hand-drawing, an old man through his digital transformation Studio Ghibli also released all their posters and stills [3] from its animations. [1] https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/ondemand/program/video/10yearshayaomiyazaki/?type=tvEpisode& https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/ondemand/program/video/10... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CvslsD9F0bk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CvslsD9F0bk [3] https://www.ghibli.jp/info/013344/ https://www.ghibli.jp/info/013344/
- m4rtink 6y agoI can confirm this - back in 2017 we asked the owner of a guesthouse in Toyama we stayed in about his favorite anime/manga and what he said was Slamdunk, an older manga series about basketball - not even one of the blockbusters such as One Piece. My theory is that most in Japan people get exposed to manga and anime at their school period but not many have time for it afterwards, resulting in them only knowing older series and possibly quite a bit of nostalgia. Actually reminds me a bit of the current resurgence of retro gaming here in the West a bit.
- bitwize 6y agoAnime, yes. Manga, not so much. It's fairly common to see adult Japanese reading manga on the train, for instance. The manga adult readers consume is not like the stuff we enjoy, like One Piece. Adult manga appears to fulfill the same role for Japanese that "airport fiction" does for us, and is broadly similar in genre: spy thrillers, workplace dramas, romance, etc. The art style is also way different, more mature and realistic with less broad caricature and more emphasis on adult rather than young/teenage characters.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago>> How many classical composers can you name? I doubt many people, even erudite people, could push well beyond the basic frontier of Bach, Beethoven, and Mozart. Let me see- without asking the internet, off the top of my head: Tchaikovsy Wagner Verdi Vivaldi Brahms Schubert Musorgsky Skalkotas Soshtakovich (spelling?) Satie (sp?) Rostropovich (sp.?) The guy who wrote Hungarian Dances? The guy who wrote Per Gynt? The guy who wrote the opera Amleto? Well I guess you're right. That's how many names I can conjure off the top of my head after scratching it for five minutes. I would recognise another dozen names or two though, with a bit more scratching. Edit: OK, after looking up stuff, Brahms wrote Hungarian Dances but I was thinking of Béla Bartók; Grieg wrote the _Peer_ Gynt suite (not Per Gynt); and Franco Faccio wrote Amleto. Correct spellings: Shostakovich; Satie is correct; and Rostropovich was a musician, but not a composer X) Oh, crap- I forgot Dvorák. How could I fogret Dvorák? I think the above is more evidence of my memory needing more coffee, than my knowledge of classical composers. ... but I think you'd be surprised how many classical composers people who don't consider themselves particularly erudite will know. I don't think you're right. I have many friends who play classical music instruments and who listen to classical and love it and know the composers' names almost as well as I know the names of obscure black metal bands :)
- dsohn0 6y agoYour parents messed up raising you.
- cafard 6y agoSkipping the ones on your list: Ohkegem, Josquin Des Prez, Byrd, Tallis, Palestrina, Monteverdi, Schutz, Rameau, Haydn, Telemann, Bachs who weren't J.S. or P.D.Q. (C.P.E. for example), Liszt, Chopin, a Johann and Richard Strauss, Mahler. I am no musician, but my parents knew a fair bit about it, my wife does, and friend is into early music.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoAye, I should have remembered Haydn, Lizst, Chopin, the Strausses and Mahler, maybe Byrd, Telemann and Palestrina. I think you're cheating with the multiple Bachs though :P