3 ms·
When someone is condemned to financial ruin because her shop is not allowed to open, this is not a matter of self entitlement, yes I think these are the beginni
by onion2k 6y ago
When someone is condemned to financial ruin because her shop is not allowed to open, this is not a matter of self entitlement, yes I think these are the beginnings of dictatorship.
On the other hand, people are actually dying of Covid. Given the choice I'd take financial ruin over death.
- jschwartzi 6y agoWhy does there have to be a dichotomy here? Another option would be to lock down but also to provide for people who will otherwise be ruined by the lockdown. That seems to be the most humane option. Make it illegal to evict people, provide them with a reasonable base income that allows them to lead a dignified life through the lockdown, and then shut everything down for a little while. Suggesting that the lockdown is synonymous with loss of livelihood is exactly the problem here. Surely the same elected officials that have the power to close everything down also have the power to authorize emergency payments to those impacted by the lockdown.
- sangnoir 6y ago> Another option would be to lock down but also to provide for people who will otherwise be ruined by the lockdown. Well, that's will just establish a beachhead for socialism, and that is reserved for big business.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoFrankly, people are always dying. Deaths don't automatically outweigh everything. This logic quickly breaks down once you apply it consistently. Traffic accidents are a huge cause of deaths, yet we don't ban all vehicles. There are massive costs associated with lockdowns, most of which we can probably only judge accurately once everything is over, and certainly there are second order effects which cost lives also. Such as suicides due to depression amplified by social isolation. Those costs should be factored in. It's not as simple as a blanket "people are dying so everything is justified".
- wonnage 6y agoHow many of those suicides are from people who are broke for pandemic-related reasons, and could've been prevented had we controlled the pandemic early (i.e, with a strict lockdown)?
- scarby2 6y agoDevils advocate: how many of those suicides are caused directly by the restrictions and not the pandemic, how many extra would have lost their sanity due to a stricter lockdown? Truth is we're not taking much time to measure the non-covid, non economic outcomes
- wonnage 6y agoThe whole point of a strict lockdown would've been to nip the problem in the bud via drastic measures. Based on the experiences of other countries, it should've lasted about 3-4 weeks.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoI think this idea is idealistic. It's easy to say now that we should've reacted immediately. But try just getting public support for drastic lockdown measures when the virus was new enough to have about as much impact on people's daily lives as the latest hospital bombing somewhere in Afghanistan.
- winocm 6y agoI lost my sanity during this year's "lockdowns".
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoI wish you the best. Hope you get better.
- onion2k 6y agoYou're talking about death as something abstract. I'm not. I'm saying I would prefer not to die, even if it costs the economy a lot. Perhaps you'd give up your life, or your child or partner or parent, to save a handful of jobs but that's quite weird in my opinion. Economies can be rebuilt. Dead people can't be brought back.