3 ms·
> 2. Allocation of free public space (car parking) to drivers, effectively subsidizing (disproportionately suburban) commuters at the expense of residents. The
by dehrmann 6y ago
> 2. Allocation of free public space (car parking) to drivers, effectively subsidizing (disproportionately suburban) commuters at the expense of residents.
The times I've commuted into a city, I had to pay for parking, usually in a private lot. I suspect it's like this in most big cities, and in smaller cities where people still commute, parking is probably private lots owned by the employer, not street parking. Picture a standard office park.
In places with free street parking (or public lots), I suspect the population is sparse enough that the added land cost for parting isn't a big deal, most people have cars, and most people support having parking.
- woodruffw 6y ago> In places with free street parking (or public lots), I suspect the population is sparse enough that the added land cost for parting isn't a big deal, most people have cars, and most people support having parking. This is not true in Manhattan, which (to my knowledge) is the most densely populated borough in the most densely populated city in the US. Almost all street parking in Manhattan is free, with small carve-outs for meters on high-traffic blocks. The city also has a semi-official policy of allowing commercial traffic to ignore parking laws[1]. In practice, that means trucks parked on sidewalks, with pedestrians exposed to car traffic on the streets. [1]: https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2018/08/20/delivery-companies-pressure-city-hall-to-let-them-keep-violating-law-without-penalty/ https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2018/08/20/delivery-companies-pr...
- what2build 6y agoParking structures are: 1) an eyesore 2) poor use of space in dense urban areas Sure let’s reduce urban housing supply cause suburbanites need to drive into town for a little culture. Bringing the noise, smog, and road rage along! Or build culture out there and bike or walk. Omg. It’s insanely toxic, and the epitome of first world entitlement.
- AmpsterMan 6y agoI'd prefer for there to be a more market incentive to build parking garages than a mandate for commercial/offices to have to all have their own parking, or effectively subsidized free street side parking. Think of all the surface area used up by cars parking on the street; pave that over with a sidewalk and allow bars/restaurants to set up shop there. That's what I would like.
- owowow 6y agoBuilding a parking spot in a modern building can cost $20k, which is hard to recoup with parking revenue. If the break even target is 10 years with no interest accrued, we are talking about $5.47 a day in revenue needs to be generated (plus the overhead of managing the lot itself). How many paid parking lots do you see that are full on a regular basis? Are they really generating revenue even half time?
- adrianN 6y agoSo you're arguing parking is way too cheap and we should make it more expensive. I think that's generally a consensus opinion among city planners.
- what2build 6y agoI’d prefer for there to be more market incentive to avoid needing as much car travel. Which is happening organically thanks to the cost of living increases, urbanization putting more people closer to necessity (which we should be expanding into neighborhoods; but austerity for the rubes, bailouts for failed CEOs and boards!), services like Lyft, and teens worried about the planet being sustainable for them in the future thanks to old people deciding it’s ok to just wreck it and die. Since the 80s the number of teenagers getting their license has fallen off a cliff, from 50-60% possessing one in the early 80s to less than 30% last I saw the numbers. The only group where possessing a license went up is 60-70 year olds. Let’s hope we’re on a downward trajectory of forcing the entire species to eat, sleep, and breath toxicity. Though looking at the US’s concern for its neighbors I’m not that hopeful. Full speed ahead towards the end of the world then. Super metal to ride the rocket into the sun.
- throw0101a 6y ago> In places with free street parking (or public lots), I suspect the population is sparse enough that the added land cost for parting isn't a big deal, most people have cars, and most people support having parking. Of course they support it, because it doesn't effect their wallets. But that doesn't mean that there isn't a cost to it: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_High_Cost_of_Free_Parking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_High_Cost_of_Free_Parking
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoManhattan has all day free on-street parking in some places. More opens up after 6PM. Then everything is free on Sundays.
- staybailey 6y ago> parking is probably private lots owned by the employer, not street parking. Picture a standard office park. But this is still subsidized because regulations mandate that buildings have lots of parking. These regulations are typically quite extreme with requirements intended to support the 99.999% demand case (think peak hour of black friday) conditional on a parking price of $0. Most developments build the minimum amount of parking they can by law suggesting this isn't a free market outcome. So if you want to have business you have to provide tons of parking and make up for it with higher prices for your goods and services. This subsidizes vehicle driving over other modes a transport. Especially so because giant parking lots make it harder to reach the store front by foot. Google Donald Shoup for more context.