4 ms·
> The user's interests are frequently poorly represented. The user's interests should be looked after by the browser. A true "user agent" should act on behalf
by ryandrake 6y ago
> The user's interests are frequently poorly represented.
The user's interests should be looked after by the browser. A true "user agent" should act on behalf of the user's preferences, fetching only what the user says they need, and rendering it in a manner that the user wants, not necessarily how the web developer wants. We've gotten far away from this ideal over the years, with browsers ceding more and more control to web developers. Users have lesser and lesser say as to how their browsers render web sites, to the point where we now just have super-blunt instruments like ad blockers and "Disable javascript".
If a web site is too slow, or choked with ads, or doesn't use an accessible color scheme, or uses a font too small, I want my browser to do something about it. I don't want to have to rely on the web developer (or Google) to adopt my own preferences. And if my browser even allows this, the function should be easy to use, not buried deep in Settings.
- Kalium 6y agoI think there's a mismatch here that only becomes apparent when you consider what level each web service and the browser are operating on. Search engines and publishers are considering intent - which is relatively easy because they have a small area over which to infer it. Browsers are operating as smart tools capable of interfacing but not capable of understanding intent because the scope of possibility is so broad. You're right. User agents should be for the user. They should expose options and controls for the user. They should tune and change and transform things for the user. They should understand what the user wants and make life easier for the user. I am just skeptical that browsers are ever going to be true user agents and capable of fully representing the user's interests and intent.