11 ms·
We in the US do an absolutely horrific job of recognizing and compensating for the externalities of our automotive culture. The criminalization of jaywalking is
by woodruffw 6y ago
We in the US do an absolutely horrific job of recognizing and compensating for the externalities of our automotive culture. The criminalization of jaywalking is one major aspect, but also consider:
1. The construction of highways through poor (read: minority) urban areas, causing mass respiratory disease and premature deaths[1].
2. Allocation of free public space (car parking) to drivers, effectively subsidizing (disproportionately suburban) commuters at the expense of residents.
3. A general culture of entitlement to the road among motorists, resulting in tens of thousands of pedestrian and cyclist injuries a year with virtually no legal (beyond costly civil) recourse.
[1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2006/10/29/nyregion/29asthma.html https://www.nytimes.com/2006/10/29/nyregion/29asthma.html
- AtlasBarfed 6y ago1) I will be curious to see if the BEV revolution happens there will be a huge statistical change in cancer rates in the US. 3) as a cyclist who transitions from commuting by bike in the summer to car in the winter, it is astonishing how my psychology is impacted by driving in the two modes. I am so much more impatient and angry from driving. There is just a nasty psychological feedback cycle of the obvious pure potential of the automobile as a time savings device and the visceral feeling of losing that when encountering any traffic or obstacle. At least I get the cycling part to enlighten my perspective. Most americans are car-encased permanently and oblivious.
- mulmen 6y agoNot sure where you live but I am pretty far north. I'm in a similar situation but in the winter I ride the bus. My psychology changes just based on the lack of light. Driving is definitely super stressful but combine that with short, dark days and less exercise and it just compounds.
- rightbyte 6y agoSadly the tires them self seems to be a big problem. I wonder how big share of air polution they are responsible of.
- labawi 6y agoEstimates seem to be <10%, and I believe even that was by mass, so much less penetrating. It is an issue, and I don't want lots of cars even if electric, but if you are weighing them as having similar air pollution, it's probably fearmongering, or fantasyland where cars don't have deteriorating emission control.
- holoduke 6y agoTires ,but also brake pads. That's why we need to have ceramic brake discs and pads for all cars being mandatory soon.
- eeZah7Ux 6y agoEV solve only a small fraction of the problems.
- nineplay 6y ago> We in the US do an absolutely horrific job of recognizing and compensating for the externalities of our automotive culture. One of the ways we recognize the externalities of our automotive culture is by making jaywalking illegal.
- woodruffw 6y ago> One of the ways we recognize the externalities of our automotive culture is by making jaywalking illegal. You mean the law in one municipality that hasn't taken effect yet, and that took months of LEO-adjacent protests? We're slowly getting better, to be sure. But I don't think anybody should be content with the rate of progress.
- sonotmyname 6y agoI think you mis-read GPs post...
- woodruffw 6y agoI'm the GP of this particular thread, so hopefully not :-)
- tsimionescu 6y agoI think they were referring to nineplay's post, which was the GP of the post that replied to you. It gets pretty confusing, I guess pointers are hard even in natural language. nineplay's post seemed to me to suggest that they believe that jaywalking being illegal is in itself a way to deal with the externalities of the car culture - it seems they are happy with jaywalking being illegal. I would guess that is why they also got the down votes. Your reply seems to be written as if you thought nineplay was praising people making jaywalking not illegal, which I believe is the wrong reading of their post.
- woodruffw 6y agoAh, I can see that reading now. Thanks for the clarification.
- imglorp 6y agoDon't forget.. 4. Auto makers conspired to kill or cripple mass transit. http://www.brooklynrail.net/NationalCityLinesConspiracy.html http://www.brooklynrail.net/NationalCityLinesConspiracy.html
- twblalock 6y agoThere were quite a few other factors that led to the decline of streetcars: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_conspiracy#Other_factors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_consp... One of the biggest is that people actually like living in suburbs, and they could afford to do so after WWII. The promise of the suburbs is a detached house, with some private outdoor space like a back yard, in a quiet area: essentially what the rich had always preferred and been able to afford. That lifestyle became broadly available to the middle classes after WWII. It's hard to blame people for wanting that. People still like living in suburbs. They still like owning cars. They still vote against new transit projects for a lot of reasons, but the biggest reason is that they don't want to pay taxes to support a system they would not use themselves. So I just don't buy the idea that the National City Lines conspiracy caused our current automotive culture. I think we would have ended up with the same car culture anyway, because huge numbers of people wanted to live in the suburbs.
- jacobolus 6y agoThey could afford to move to suburbs because the federal government subsidized the hell out of it at the expense of people living in cities.
- teloli 6y agoOh man, am I glad to be European. Walk to the bar, cycle to work, take the tram if it rains. American cities built for cars are just so sad.
- RandallBrown 6y agoI can do that in my American city too.
- ericmcer 6y agoCar free cities are super obtainable but seem like a total impossibility. We will never trade safety, health and solitude for convenience.
- sonotmyname 6y ago> safety, health and solitude Funny, those are 3 of the main reasons I live way out in the nearly-rural suburbs instead of in downtown San Francisco. It seems like some of us have made that trade, just not in the direction you're hoping for.
- woodruffw 6y ago>Funny, those are 3 of the main reasons I live way out in the nearly-rural suburbs instead of in downtown San Francisco. And this is precisely the problem: automotive culture presently represents a massive subsidy to rural and suburban areas at the expensive of urban dwellers. I can't possibly blame people for making that trade. But the observation is that it's sweetened by externalities that ex-urban areas don't have to bear.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- twblalock 6y agoI don't think car-free cities are easily obtainable. I can't think of one that currently exists. Even cities with world-class mass transit, e.g. Tokyo and London, are full of cars, and taxis are still a better option for some trips -- even though there are also surface trains, subways, and buses to choose from. In those places, step 1 has already been solved: convince the population that mass transit is desirable and should be well funded. London even charges congestion fees for cars. But they still can't achieve car-free cities.
- ScarZy 6y agoThis is an interesting observation but I'd argue there certainly cities where cycling is a norm (Amsterdam, Copenhagen) and cities that are increasingly turning to 2 wheels as a way to solve density (Paris, Berlin, Oslo). I think the UK, like the US, suffers from the idea of cars being a status symbol. I've no idea how this works in Tokyo for example, would be good to know their approach to cycling as an alternative, but pedestrianisation of areas and city centres are what we should certainly strive for.
- dehrmann 6y ago> 2. Allocation of free public space (car parking) to drivers, effectively subsidizing (disproportionately suburban) commuters at the expense of residents. The times I've commuted into a city, I had to pay for parking, usually in a private lot. I suspect it's like this in most big cities, and in smaller cities where people still commute, parking is probably private lots owned by the employer, not street parking. Picture a standard office park. In places with free street parking (or public lots), I suspect the population is sparse enough that the added land cost for parting isn't a big deal, most people have cars, and most people support having parking.
- woodruffw 6y ago> In places with free street parking (or public lots), I suspect the population is sparse enough that the added land cost for parting isn't a big deal, most people have cars, and most people support having parking. This is not true in Manhattan, which (to my knowledge) is the most densely populated borough in the most densely populated city in the US. Almost all street parking in Manhattan is free, with small carve-outs for meters on high-traffic blocks. The city also has a semi-official policy of allowing commercial traffic to ignore parking laws[1]. In practice, that means trucks parked on sidewalks, with pedestrians exposed to car traffic on the streets. [1]: https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2018/08/20/delivery-companies-pressure-city-hall-to-let-them-keep-violating-law-without-penalty/ https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2018/08/20/delivery-companies-pr...
- what2build 6y agoParking structures are: 1) an eyesore 2) poor use of space in dense urban areas Sure let’s reduce urban housing supply cause suburbanites need to drive into town for a little culture. Bringing the noise, smog, and road rage along! Or build culture out there and bike or walk. Omg. It’s insanely toxic, and the epitome of first world entitlement.
- AmpsterMan 6y agoI'd prefer for there to be a more market incentive to build parking garages than a mandate for commercial/offices to have to all have their own parking, or effectively subsidized free street side parking. Think of all the surface area used up by cars parking on the street; pave that over with a sidewalk and allow bars/restaurants to set up shop there. That's what I would like.
- asguy 6y ago> 1. The construction of highways through poor (read: minority) urban areas, causing mass respiratory disease and premature deaths[1]. Isn't this kind of leap? I've lived plenty of expensive places (e.g. downtown San Diego, Boston, Los Angeles) that had free/highways close to expensive property. What is leading you to believe highway construction targets the poor areas, other than those real estate markets are already depressed (which is possibly why poor people live there)?
- avianlyric 6y agoThe role of highways and red-lining of federal house building loans in segregating and suppressing black communities is well documented. (You can argue about intention, but the effect is pretty apparent) [1] Remember this happened in the 40s and 50s. Plenty has changed since then, including the gentrification of poor areas near highways. But that doesn’t change the history of the US highway system. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/03/role-of-highways-in-american-poverty/474282/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/03/role-of...
- woodruffw 6y ago> Isn't this kind of leap? No. Here are two specific examples: 1. The Cross Bronx Expressway, which basically created the South Bronx[1]. "The Power Broker" by Robert Caro is one of HN's most frequently recommended books, and covers this subject (as well as other racially-motivated planning projects by Robert Moses) extensively. 2. I-65 and I-165 in Mobile, AL cut directly through the historic "Africatown" neighborhood[2]. Residents regularly complain about both automotive and nearby industrial pollution, encouraged by ease of access by the highway[3]. Most of these effects are more visible on the East Coast rather than the West Coast, since the East's older and denser cities had fewer "paths of least resistance" when building the Interstate Highway System during the midcentury. But it wouldn't particularly surprise me if the areas that are now expensive in the cities that you mentioned were originally cleared for highways under "slum clearance" or similar laws. Edit: This is anecdotal, but I figured I'd mention it anyways: I grew up in Manhattan, and virtually everybody I grew up with has (or had) asthma. Some of that is to be expected from other pollution sources (in particular, NYC used to burn very dirty heating oil), but I also went to public schools that were directly alongside major state and interstate highways. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross_Bronx_Expressway#Urban_decay_and_congestion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross_Bronx_Expressway#Urban_d... [2]: https://www.npr.org/2019/06/19/733996699/alabamas-africatown-hopes-for-revival-after-slave-ship-discovery https://www.npr.org/2019/06/19/733996699/alabamas-africatown... [3]: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jan/26/africatown-site-of-last-us-slave-ship-arrival-sues-over-factorys-pollution https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jan/26/africatown-s...
- njharman 6y agoUm, the biggest one POLUTION! Including lead poisoning of a couple generations due to leaded gas. Disastrous foreign Mid East policies to secure oil.
- canofbars 6y agoThere is a credible theory that the use of leaded fuel was responsible for the spike in violent crime that occurred in the same period. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead%E2%80%93crime_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead%E2%80%93crime_hypothesis
- jbnorth 6y agoRegarding your third point, I've nothing but distain for bikers in my community. They put up signs to be treated like cars (since there generally are very poor shoulders in this area) but then will plow through stop signs and will not signal turns or anything. Nearly ran one over in a fire truck because they just ran right through the stop sign.
- AirborneUnicorn 6y agoIt’s been seen [0] that having a slightly different subset of traffic rules for cyclists (while maintaining that they are indeed a vehicle with rights to the public roadways) is safer for all parties. ————————————————- [0] https://sdotblog.seattle.gov/2020/09/30/washington-states-new-bicycle-safety-stop-law-allows-people-biking-to-treat-stops-signs-as-yield-signs-with-some-exceptions/#research https://sdotblog.seattle.gov/2020/09/30/washington-states-ne...
- tristor 6y ago> The construction of highways through poor (read: minority) urban areas, causing mass respiratory disease and premature deaths[1]. This has nearly nothing to do with automotive culture and everything to do with the system of governance in the US. In local politics in the US, your level of representation is roughly equal in proportion to your property tax bill every year. If you're renting, or otherwise in a situation where you don't directly pay (significant) property tax, your voice doesn't matter. The rest is pretty much true, but would be worth noting that the only options for the US are for every city to have extensive sprawling underground metros interlinked by high-speed rail, or to have most people own a car and have highways everywhere. Any middle ground or half measure is untenable in our current society without causing direct, real, dire consequences to the very people you're trying to champion.
- owowow 6y agoThe Democracy Voucher program in Seattle has leveled the field quite a bit by enabling candidates that can connect with voters to field a viable, funded campaign: https://www.seattle.gov/democracyvoucher/program-data https://www.seattle.gov/democracyvoucher/program-data We have a much larger field of candidates running due to this program.