4 ms·
The answer is π^2/6: What’s the question?
- lurker19 16y agoTheorem without proof is unsatisfying.
- BrentRitterbeck 16y agoThis includes a brief sketch of Euler's argument as well as a several formal methods of proof: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basel_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basel_problem
- gyom 16y agoYou can find the proof by looking for documentation about the zeta function.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- 2stoned2play 16y agoWhat is how fat my ex is...
- SamParker 16y agoThe author seems to be confused as to how simple fractions work.
- m314 16y agoFor all values of n=pi?
- vog 16y agoThe title says "π" (pi), not "n" (en).
- temphn 16y agoStandard way to do this is with Fourier series on the sawtooth wave. http://math.mit.edu/classes/18.03/spr10/lec_22.txt http://math.mit.edu/classes/18.03/spr10/lec_22.txt
- sigil 16y agoIf you click through to the mathworld page [1], there's a pretty awesome geometric interpretation of the Riemann zeta function: "If a lattice point is selected at random in two dimensions, the probability that it is visible from the origin is 6/π^2. This is also the probability that two integers picked at random are relatively prime. If a lattice point is picked at random in n dimensions, the probability that it is visible from the origin is 1/ζ(n), where ζ(n) is the Riemann zeta function." [1] http://mathworld.wolfram.com/VisiblePoint.html http://mathworld.wolfram.com/VisiblePoint.html
- xyzzyz 16y agoThat's not really the geometric interpretation of the Riemann zeta function, but rather the series \sum_{k=1}^\infty 1/k^n. Riemann zeta function makes sense not only in positive integers greater than 1, but also on the almost whole complex plane, and identifying complex zeros of zeta function is of main interest.
- sigil 16y agoOkay, so it's an interpretation of Riemann zeta on positive real integers. It's still neat. ;)
- Natsu 16y agoFrom the article: "Here’s a simple yet revealing question to ask people at all levels of mathematical attainment: 'The answer is 10. What is the question?'" I know I'd love to hear HN's answers.
- magicseth 16y agoHere's one: How do you express the number of digits that exist in any given base, in that base?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- tkahn6 16y agoA related comic which gives away the answer: http://cowbirdsinlove.com/43 http://cowbirdsinlove.com/43
- NickPollard 16y agoIf you're using Arabic numerals, that is.
- DrJ 16y agowhat is the binary representation of 2?
- psawaya 16y agoI like this a lot, it seems like a classic example of divergent thinking, in a subject (math) that doesn't traditionally involve a lot of it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divergent_thinking http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divergent_thinking
- vog 16y ago> divergent thinking, in a subject (math) that doesn't traditionally involve a lot of it. I strongly disagree with that. Divergent thinking as well as creativity is very important in mathematics and has always been. Solving problems - this is what mathematics is all about. So creativity is vital, and more important in math than in many other professions that call themselves "creative". It is a common misconception that math is about following calculation steps and simple algorithms. This is "math" as taught in school, and it is okay because those are the very basics. However, as soon as you join mathmatical competitions, or even start studying math, things are different: It is no longer about using math but about understanding and maybe even extending math. That means: defintions, theorems and proofs. And, of course, always keeping some examples, visualizations, simplified views, and heuristics in mind. Those help you to stay on top of things, so you don't get lost in this forest. To find proofs, or even just good definitions (which is sometimes as important), you have to be very creative. Learning other proofs means getting lots of ideas about what could work, but as soon as all well-known tricks are exhausted, there are still lots of open questions whose definite answer (i.e. proof or counter-proof) will need yet another genius. Or just another student whose thinking diverges into directions that others haven expoited yet. Or maybe they also thought about that, but didn't take this seriously or didn't try hard enough. Dedication to an concrete problem at hand is in no way a contradiction to divergent thinking. It is more about the combination of convergent and divergent thinking. Sticking to only one of those, and you either won't get far enough, or be lost into totally secluded corners without even noticing. Also don't be fooled by math competitions (which are very different from plain calculation competitions!). Students may get excercises that are fairly well-known to mathematicians. However, in the view of the students those are new, unknown problems they almost certainly haven't heard of up to that point. They might be well-prepared with lots of standard tricks and maybe know about similar-looking issues. But in the end of the day, they have to be creative - very creative - to find their proof. It is not uncommon for the jury to receive a solution from a student the original creators haven't thought of. Usually, such an exceptionally creative solution leads to a special award on the competition. Also, usually the students get multiple tasks, so when they get stuck with one excersice, they can skip to the next one. When they later come back to the first one, it usually makes a lot more sense and have some more ideas to explore.
- tzs 16y agoA little harder: the answer is pi^2/(12 log 2). What's the question?