5 ms·
https://www.bellingcat.com/news/uk-and-europe/2020/12/21/if-it-hadnt-been-for-the-prompt-work-of-the-medics-fsb-officer-inadvertently-confesses-murder-plot-to-n
by pydry 6y ago
https://www.bellingcat.com/news/uk-and-europe/2020/12/21/if-it-hadnt-been-for-the-prompt-work-of-the-medics-fsb-officer-inadvertently-confesses-murder-plot-to-navalny/ https://www.bellingcat.com/news/uk-and-europe/2020/12/21/if-...
The Bellingcat story has a weird number of just-so leaps "e.g. this telephone number is one that regularly called these spies" that suggests either that they hired a bunch of actors and put on a show or they received high level intelligence from a nation state actor (e.g. CIA).
- levleontiev 6y agoDo you believe in it or you are funded by Russian government to provide any explanation except the obvious one?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- asats 6y agoThat information is openly sold on the black market in Russia, and for a trivial amount of money. Check out their "How we did it" for the first investigation: https://www.bellingcat.com/resources/2020/12/14/navalny-fsb-methodology/ https://www.bellingcat.com/resources/2020/12/14/navalny-fsb-...
- nzmsv 6y agoI guess anyone who is really curious could try to replicate what they did. The investigators clearly don't know Russian very well because they misspell common names ("Arur", really?). So anyone reading this comment should be able to find and use a Telegram bot just like the authors to get some phone records. Otherwise I call BS.
- asats 6y agoThere is really no question about that data being available for purchase. This sort of stuff was being sold on physical DVD's on actual physical markets since the 2000s. Here's a ~2 year old BBC article talking about all this data being easily available for purchase online in a lot of detail with a reporter ordering their phone location history: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-48348307 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-48348307
- uep 6y agoI knew someone who was retired FBI, who offered his services to me. He had said he could get phone records or bank account information on anyone, anywhere in the world. I don't know if he was blowing smoke, but this was apparently how he made money after retirement. It had sounded like former agents of all different countries have access and relationships with even adversarial countries' agents.
- mikeyouse 6y agoThere are literally Whatsapp accounts where you send them ~$15 and a name/DOB and they'll reply with a full "Dox" of any Russian citizen - it's a free-for-all over there.
- nzmsv 6y agoI hear this quoted all the time, but I think this is just a tired trope. Repeat something often enough and it becomes true. We all know Russians are all corrupt, live in constant fear, bears walk the streets, and the only escape is vodka. In any case, it's easy enough for anyone with a reasonable doubt in what they are reading to check this. Bellingcat claims that anyone capable of Googling can get dox on any random Russian, including someone high up in the FSB. So try it! Pick a random person off the internet and go get those dox. It's a free for all, right? Otherwise what you are reading is a poorly retconned explanation of how a foreign intelligence operation got some data.
- asats 6y agoYou asked if someone tried to do it and already got a link where a BBC journalist bought a phone location data two years ago (that is, this being a thing is absolutely not news). Here's an independent russian newspaper estimating how much it'd cost to get all this data on the black market (note that they don't even question if it's possible to do it as everybody knows that it is possible) https://thebell.io/million-za-vseh-skolko-stoilo-rassledovanie-bellingcat-o-navalnom https://thebell.io/million-za-vseh-skolko-stoilo-rassledovan... They list which databases you'd buy it from and for how much. Their total estimate is about a million rubles, ~$13000 -- Here's another large russian newspaper: https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4616645 https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4616645 "For Navalny's investigation internet and some cash was enough" - "Experts interviewed by "Kommersant" confirm that flight receipts with passport numbers of passengers, their phone numbers and geo-tagged billing of the latter can be found on the black market at a price of 2-40 thousand rubles per request."
- xkr 6y agoThey have a separate article on it: https://www.bellingcat.com/resources/2020/12/14/navalny-fsb-methodology https://www.bellingcat.com/resources/2020/12/14/navalny-fsb-.... There is a huge black market of private data in Russia.
- nyolfen 6y agothis was my impression as well. how did they get passport photos and cell phone records? my suspicion for a while has been that bellingcat is basically a way of laundering US intelligence when it is thought to be beneficial to publicly release information or shape public discourse. that isn't to say that i think what they're publishing is necessarily untrue, or that everything they publish is fed to them.
- tobltobs 6y agoInstead of having suspicions you could read.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SXX 6y agoIn Russia there is a laws that force both internet services and telecoms to provide SMS and phone calls on demand to police. Not just to some spy agencies, but just to normal police. It's heavily used against opposition leaders as well as some entrepreneurs. So there is literally tens of thousands of people who can leak phone billing information to anyone. As for passport data there is tons of points of leakage too since Russia have well-centralised online government services and tons of people have user-access to these databases. E.g people in police, medical services, education, tax departments, local government, etc. And obviously salary of most people with such access is well below $1000 / month after taxes so they are happy to sell any information for few hundred dollars. Imagine it: all spy agency staff profiles don't have "TOP SECRET. PLEASE DON'T LEAK THIS" warning on it,
- patrakov 6y agoAnd it's very unfortunate that Bellingcat had to use this phone/sms data, because this justifies its collection.
- nyolfen 6y agoi don't think i'm so off the mark: https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/12/17/bellingcat-can-say-what-u-s-intelligence-cant/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/12/17/bellingcat-can-say-what... > “I don’t want to be too dramatic, but we love this,” said Marc Polymeropolous, the CIA’s former deputy chief of operations for Europe and Eurasia. > When former Russian spy Sergei Skripal and his daughter were poisoned, it was Bellingcat that was first to publicly identify the two Russian military intelligence operatives that had traveled to the U.K. to spritz the door handle of the Skripals’ home with the Soviet-era nerve agent. > “Whenever we had to talk to our liaison partners about it, instead of trying to have things cleared or worry about classification issues, you could just reference their work,” said Polymeropolous, who retired from the CIA in 2019.
- hedberg10 6y agoKeep in mind this can also be used as hero theatre which happened in the orange revolution if I remember correctly, also an alleged poisoning and still, 15 years later, very murky. Both sides can lie. As per John Le Carré's Moscow rules: 1. Assume nothing.
- SXX 6y agoExcept official state propaganda release such interview with their own spy agency staff to prove their innocence. Waning: too funny, you might die of laugh: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNEWMrdSNfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNEWMrdSNfc
- pavlus 6y agoOrange revolution happened 14 years earlier [1]. One of candidates in presidential campaign was pro-Russian, and other -- wasn't. There was an attempt to poison to death the later one [2] with a toxin that's part for Agent Orange, there is some irony in that, because Yuhscheko's party had orange colors. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orange_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orange_Revolution [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Yushchenko#TCDD_poisoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Yushchenko#TCDD_poisoni...
- xinniethepooh 6y agoRussian disinformation organizations are moving quickly to call this a 'CIA op' or 'fake news', but the evidence laid out in the documentary is very damning and obtained easily by Navalny's team.
- jessaustin 6y agoThis sort of comment is less convincing when created by a greenbean account.
- nzmsv 6y agoHere's the thing. I don't know what to believe myself. I live and work in Silicon Valley. I have Russian heritage of which I am proud, and the ongoing smear campaign is disheartening, even if not entirely unsubstantiated. I am not on payroll of any secret service. But here I am asked to believe a story in which there is an evil dictator that has a chokehold on an entire country, yet is somehow unable to get rid of a blogger/YouTuber. The blogger in question is acting completely independently and is not propped up by any government force. It is though his pure bravery and resourcefulness that he is able to evade the evil dictator's ploys. I can't help but think that there are parallels in this story to... Star Wars. There we also have an invincible freedom fighter improbably taking on a fearsome adversary. Except even in Star Wars we learn that all is not what it seems: the reason the dark lord could not kill the freedom fighter was because he didn't actually want to (him being his son and all, sorry for any spoilers if you still have not seen Star Wars). And here I am asked to believe a story less plausible than the plot of Star Wars. I find this insults my intelligence.
- doovd 6y agoYou are right to be suspicious. This story has so many holes.
- HatchedLake721 6y agoSo many holes that made Putin on live TV confirm that FSB were following Navalny, hence confirming the whole investigation and the story
- newacct583 6y ago> or they received high level intelligence from a nation state actor Much more likely they have a mole in the Russian government, FWIW. Autocrats are, in general, broadly hated by their own bureaucracies. That's why they do purges and murder opponents to begin with. But yes, clearly there was some level of intelligence work needed to make this happen, you can't just look up "state poisoner" in an index of professionals.
- roywiggins 6y agoYou don't need a high level mole when access to these databases is just floating around for sale. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-48348307 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-48348307
- elmo2you 6y agoThe sole purpose of organizations like these, is to generate "information" that can impossible be verified, but does sound like it could be (sort of) plausible. For those too young to remember, here is a wise lesson from "Yes Prime Minister" (Distract the press: expel some diplomats): https://youtu.be/v9meC6TmSig https://youtu.be/v9meC6TmSig If anything is at all remarkable about this operation (because as it currently stands, it is far more likely to be a US intelligence operation, trying to force Germany to back out of North Stream 2), is how eagerly most people in the West just swallow whatever is shoved down their throats. Apparently even without any critical thinking or common sense. Many in the West would be shocked, about what an average (educated) Russians could tell them about Navalny .. but all of that is of course propaganda and lies, because Russian people can't think for themselves. Fun fact: most people who ever made an effort to contact Russians and get at least some first hand stories about events in Russia, pretty much all found out how unreliable US/EU media actually is. But never mind .. if the US or EU end up in ruins one day, and won't receive any sympathy, at least it won't be hard to see/understand why.
- gizmondo 6y ago> Many in the West would be shocked, about what an average (educated) Russians could tell them about Navalny .. As an average educated Russian I wonder, what do you imagine they would tell them?