4 ms·
> When we speak of free software, we are referring to freedom, not price. Third paragraph of the preamble at https://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-1.0.
by mulmen 6y ago
> When we speak of free software, we are referring to freedom, not price.
Third paragraph of the preamble at https://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-1.0.html https://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-1.0.html. Still unchanged in v3: https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-3.0.html https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-3.0.html
GPL has always been about free-as-in-freedom, not free-as-in-beer.
- pjmlp 6y agoExcept that try to make a living from selling GPL software to desktop users.
- toyg 6y agoThe problem here is Linux users, not GPL desktop software. Linux users are technical and skint; they have no problem compiling something from scratch if it can save them a few dollars. GPL desktop software would probably fare better on Windows, ironically, where compiling and installing things correctly is nontrivial even for power-users. This is actually becoming even more the case, now that security is getting more and more important: having a known-safe installable build from a trusted party is extremely valuable.
- jabl 6y agoI think that's how Krita (a painting app) pays the bills. The code is GPL, and most Linux distros package it for free. But on the windows store, they have a for pay version for some relatively low price (€25 or such). It's not a billion dollar business like Photoshop, but apparently it pays the salary for a few full time employees.
- Torwald 6y agoThis is an interesting challenge. But, up until today, the problem is, except for maybe Firefox, there is no GPL desktop software, that is good enough to get sold, regardless of licence. (No, the GIMP is not good enough to do professional graphic design work. Etc etc pp)
- ognarb 6y agoBlender and Krita come to my mind in term of professional graphic applications. There is also other professional software like Ardour for music production or LibreOffice for word processing.
- Torwald 6y agoKrita is good software, but it is lacking usability. How could I sell ist against Acorn or Pixelmator? The latter is at 20$ and has superior benchmarks due to M1 support. It is available for the Mac and the iPad as well. It has the perfect UI, whereas Krita has a UI that would weird out everyone who learned graphics in the "Adobe" school. LibreOffice, you probably know that Excel is one of the biggest software platforms out there. So, I can see a chance here, when you sell script/macro development, but I wouldn't know why anyone would want LibreOffice. It's just in use because nothing else is available on Linux. Blender is probably very good, but people who need such stuff don't necessarily look too much on price. Performance is more important there. I don't know enough about music production to comment on Ardour.
- aprdm 6y agoYou seem to not know about blender or krita too but commented anyways
- Torwald 6y agoI did not comment on Blender as a software other than indicating that I do not know it well enough. I commented about the market for this category of software. What I said about Krita is true. I think you don't understand that market and it's priorities and thus gained a wrong impression of the meaning of my words.
- smarx007 6y agoI think what people mean when they say GPL-licensed software business does not work is not that GPL denies charging in any legal manner but that it's very hard to deny free of charge use while protecting freedom of use. And if you don't deny free of charge use, you will have hard time doing business. Many enterprises (all?) have a procurement process which requires to look for a cheaper or a free alternative. If you provide Mongo under AGPL, it will be harder to get a company to buy a subscription. Procurement officer will nag you with questions why should we pay if there is a free alternative (that's what you call market cannibalization)? Support is the thing that usually gets a procurement through but that effectively cancels all the "unicorn" growth (if most revenues come from support contracts as opposed to licenses) and essentially puts you outside the "blue ocean" because human support does not scale as software can. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Ocean_Strategy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Ocean_Strategy Edit: someone mentioned AWS Linux and k8s below, I think it's really off in business terms. Those things are open and free in order to "commoditize the complement" https://www.gwern.net/Complement https://www.gwern.net/Complement
- marcinzm 6y ago>Procurement officer will nag you with questions why should we pay if there is a free alternative (that's what you call market cannibalization)? Because their legal department prohibits them from running AGPL code :). That's a side reason for non-standard open source licenses I suspect. The hassle of getting legal to approve them is more than the cost of just paying for a commercial license.
- smarx007 6y agoNo, I was saying that procurement will tell you to use Mongo under AGPL (the free alternative) and not to embed it in the app (if you can). What I meant is that procurement takes OSS-licensed code as a "given" and carefully considers what they get on top of the base product when they pay money (while developers often think that they are charging for the whole thing, but in "enterprise" context). And that is where the blue ocean ends. Independent of that, you are completely right that most serious companies view non-standard free/"free" licenses as commercial and simply consider those as non-OSS products just like they would otherwise.
- kemitchell 6y agoHave you ever paid for GPL-licensed software?