47 ms·
The same problem (from the commercial distros point of view) exists for RedHat now, and anyone following the plan of this article. If the software you are tryi
by Brian_K_White 6y ago
The same problem (from the commercial distros point of view) exists for RedHat now, and anyone following the plan of this article.
If the software you are trying to sell, is GPL, then anyone can do the same as CentOS at any time.
The article suggests users will arrange into two groups, non-paying users of the develelopment version and paying customers of the production-class version.
But the production version is still GPL and so anyone can get the production version for free any time they want.
Your only option for getting out of that is not to use any GPL software in your super valuable commercial product.
That is the GPL deal, which you don't have take. You can take it OR leave it.
What RedHat seems to have forgotten was 2 things, which I'm sure they knew very well at some point:
- Even non-paying users are more valuable to you as non-paying members of your ecosystem than members of any of your competitors. They are actually what keeps your ecosystem a defacto standard. It is incalculable how valuable it is to be a defacto standard for anything.
- Those non-paying users were never and are never going to be paying customers no matter what else you do. Their use is not "lost revenue" because you were never going to get any revenue from them anyway. If they couldn't use your product for free, they'd just use someone else's product for free. There is no "convert them into paying customers".
And there is also no "convert them into development version users" either because of see above re GPL.
All it is is annoying for everyone, even bystanders, that they keep trying.
- toyg 6y ago> But the production version is still GPL and so anyone can get the production version for free any time they want. That's not correct. Anyone who is already a user can. If you restrict distribution of the binaries, you also restrict the amount of people who can get the sources. You cannot impose NDAs or the likes, but you can introduce some restrictions on their overall privileges going forward (i.e. you republish sources? No more patches or support for you - which is basically what RH does with their paying customers). RH could stop publishing sources entirely, if they really wanted to, and just provide them to paying customers on request. They don't do that because it's a nuclear option that would effectively push them out of the Linux ecosystem they've invested so much into dominating (RH is effectively the one company who can steer massive amounts of the Linux ecosystem on its own - as shown by systemd et al).
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agowow. this exact argument is used against persecution of torrenters among others. i seek stuff like torrents because i cannot afford buying and that is the reality for most of the world. simply counting downloads of a song times $.99 is not true. if i had the money to pay for netflix, i would rather spend 9 bucks than muck around in torrents, hosting sites, ads, malware, etc etc.
- dralley 6y ago>Even non-paying users are more valuable to you as non-paying members of your ecosystem than members of any of your competitors. This is only true if paying customers aren't constantly transitioning to become non-paying members, because CentOS is "official" and "just as good as RHEL" in every respect including the length of support.