6 ms·
I'm no fan of Facebook or Google, but this is a mega-monopoly deciding to crush a competitor. They're saying no to a company's revenue stream, and they've gotte
by echelon 6y ago
I'm no fan of Facebook or Google, but this is a mega-monopoly deciding to crush a competitor. They're saying no to a company's revenue stream, and they've gotten in the habit of doing this to everyone.
Apple wields too much power.
- VyperCard 6y agoCompetitor in what?
- infinityplus1 6y agoMobile app revenue. Ads where Apple doesn't get a cut vs IAP where Apple gets 30%.
- mcphage 6y agoAds and IAP aren’t the same thing. The money doesn’t even come from the same places.
- Jyaif 6y agoIf ads start bringing in less revenue, more developers will move to IAP (or other stream of revenues).
- chongli 6y agoThe battle is over attention. Users have a finite amount of time to spend looking at their phone per day. The more time they spend scrolling Facebook, the less time they spend on other apps. The less time spent on other apps, the less money they spend on IAPs.
- doctor_eval 6y agoSo you agree with Facebook that their revenue stream is more important than our privacy? If you don’t agree, then how else do you propose Apple enforces said privacy? I mean these third party apps are running on Apple’s platform and using Apple’s APIs to track Apple’s customers. Who else can fix this problem?
- echelon 6y ago> So you agree with Facebook that their revenue stream is more important than our privacy? No. I think our freedom is more important than both. > If you don’t agree, then how else do you propose Apple enforces said privacy? Apple is making decisions that are too big for it. The DOJ needs to break them up. Computing needs to be free. I'm fine if the platform makes these notices apparent, but Apple can't be the arbiter.
- doctor_eval 6y agoI don’t understand your position. There are many types of “freedom”. Is it freedom for Facebook to invade our privacy that you care about? Or do you care about allowing people to be free from privacy invasion? Both freedoms cannot exist simultaneously. So are you saying that Apple should not be allowed to decide which freedom to prioritise? Despite the fact that every other comparable company is effectively on the side of Facebook? Or is there some other kind of freedom you care about? You seem to say that “our freedom” is more important than our privacy, but privacy is a most fundamental type of freedom - literally, the freedom to think our own thoughts. What other freedom could be more important than that?
- Renaud 6y agoI'm not sure I understand your point. How is Apple crushing Facebook as a competitor by allowing users to give proper consent to tracking. I could understand if there was really an overlap somewhere, but I don't really see it. They have different business models, Apple doesn't have any social media property that compete with Facebook or Instagram and if Apple really wanted iMessage to crush WhatsApp they should at least show their interest in dominance by having an Android version of it. Maybe they are competing on resources? but I don't see it either. They don't seem to be going after the same acquisitions. Maybe Apple is doing this because pleasing or pissing off ad-based companies has no effect on their bottom line and they see it as a good marketing campaign to woo the privacy conscious an earn some brownie points for practically zero expense.
- johnnycerberus 6y agoBecause Apple is worse, everything you do on the Apple platform has to be taxed, something like Italian mafia did in the past. Until things got heat in 2020, Apple wasn't even allowing payment competition in their iOS App Store. Think about that. Roman empire did the same with their provinces, wanna get romanised (civilised)? You got to pay the tax. More so, Apple is #3 in the world in game revenue and guess what, Apple doesn’t even make games. I can't buy an Apple device because of the ideology behind their products. Why expect Apple to put other storefronts on their platform? They have all the rights not to but this also implies that their ecosystem is less liberal, which is also fine. They made the OS and the device. If you hate the App Store, don’t use iOS. It's simple. They run 1984 ads but they are the core of 1984. There is basically no reason for not providing an OS interface for others to build their own storefronts on your platform. Android showed that it's possible, there's no excuse. Period.
- holstvoogd 6y agoI'd rather pay the apple tax (money) than the google/facebook tax (my data and privacy).
- johnnycerberus 6y ago
- st1x7 6y ago> They're saying no to a company's revenue stream They're saying no to certain privacy violations on their platform. This being detrimental to Facebook's revenue says a lot more about Facebook's business model than it says about Apple's policies.
- smt88 6y agoApple is far from a monopoly. They lose market share to Android every year, I believe.
- diveanon 6y agoApple and Facebook are not competitors. If anything apple is setting a precedent for it's actual competition that user privacy is something people are willing to pay a premium for.