4 ms·
Many of the comments, at the time of posting, aren't really grappling with what the article says. It is about a company called Wistron, not a company called Ap
by roenxi 6y ago
Many of the comments, at the time of posting, aren't really grappling with what the article says.
It is about a company called Wistron, not a company called Apple. I would challenge the idea that Apple is doing something wrong in this given what I now about most of the supply chains producing goods in the advanced economies - everyone down to the consumer buys from the cheapest supplier. Apple is not fundamentally responsible for the labour relations of other companies, and this is a practice that literally everyone I know has engaged in to some degree. "Sweatshop labour" producing clothes isn't very concealing as euphemisms go. It is far more worrying that Apple does business in China period than that Apple has dodgy subcontractor arrangements in India. India is a democracy, they'll sort this stuff out in time.
There is also no need to express outrage on this one. Promising to pay one amount and then not paying it is an unpardonable sin in pretty much every value system anyone cares to name. Comparisons to slavery, however, are missing the point. This is fraud. Assuming an accurate article this is one of the few times that smashing someone else's stuff is justified.
- aarong11 6y agoAre comparisons to slavery missing the point? I understand that companies are always going to go for the lowest bidder, but if the lowest bidder was mistreating it's workers and they know about it then it's socially irresponsible. Companies like Apple have plausible deniability when it comes to things like this. That's one of the major reasons they outsource rather than building their own factory. Apple is built on vertical integration.
- mehrdadn 6y ago> Apple is not fundamentally responsible for the labour relations of other companies It's a funny world where everyday individual customers barely making a living are supposed to unite, educate themselves on the supply chains of everything they see on the market, and vote with their wallets to filter out unethically-produced products, but a single $2 trillion tech corporation ("person"?) who's a customer of another company with all the leverage in the world isn't responsible for caring if it's reaching the $2T market cap ethically.
- tomcam 6y agoApple lectures me on all kinds of things, from climate change to political correctness. Just give me a fucking device and stay out of my politics. They have earned the outrage.
- tmotwu 6y agoFor years, companies like Nike and Samsung have justifiably gone under fire for similar issues with their suppliers. I have never witnessed so many who found it more important to cleanse the name of these companies. It really says a lot about consumer cultism.
- romanovcode 6y ago> Apple is not fundamentally responsible for the labour relations of other companies As soon as Apple steps into politics and takes any kind of political/environmental/socio-political stance - yes, yes it is responsible. Otherwise it is hypocrisy at best.
- TheRealSteel 6y agoIf Apple has any reason to believe they are benefiting from underpaid labour then they are responsible. You don't just get to say "well technically the slaves work for that other company, sure we get the slaves to build our devices that we profit off of, but they're actually hired by someone else". If they know about it and benefit from it it's their responsibility. If they have any reason to believe it might be true and don't do everything in their power to stop it, it's their responsibility. Billionaire Apple shareholders simply chose increasing their wealth at the expense of poor people they took advantage of in developing countries. And this has to stop, and we have to stop saying it's acceptable. Capitalism failed. It failed harder than any other experiment humans ever tried, and it and the wealth equality it creates has to be destroyed.
- 0xbadcafebee 6y agoThe outrage is because we know Apple, and many other corporations, have facilities to be able to become aware of this and do things to stop it. Apple can ask for independent verification of the conditions of the workers in its supply chain. This isn't some crazy new notion, companies do this all the time for quality control purposes. They can therefore do it for human rights purposes too. They can also stop it, by having a contract that requires specific working conditions for all the suppliers, and if they are violated, the contract is voided and immediately goes to a competitor. Apple has no responsibility to anybody but its shareholders. They can use literal slaves for work, they don't care. But we, the consumers and shareholders, can care. And we can express our displeasure by getting outraged, and demanding they not do business with a supply chain that abuses its workers. This even happened back in the 17th century, when people boycotted companies who profited from slavery. People literally purchased items whose design advertised that "no slaves were used in the making of this product". A lot of people thought companies should not be held responsible for using the product of slave labor, but over time, the force of popular opinion was able to get them to change their business models and not use slavery. Today we do the same things, with products advertising not using rBST or antibiotics or engineered crops, or having fair trade or rainforest alliance certifications. We demand products that are produced ethically, and over time that can force companies to do better. This isn't always effective. There's still diamonds being sold that were mined basically using slavery, and most coffee farmers can barely scrape by and can starve from one bad season. We do need to get outraged, or they really will never change.