3 ms·
Is it just me, or does this at the beginning of the article: "For digital signals like HDMI, as long as there is enough data for the receiver to put together a
by bigiain 16y ago
Is it just me, or does this at the beginning of the article:
"For digital signals like HDMI, as long as there is enough data for the receiver to put together a picture, it will form. If there isn't, it will just drop off. While processing artifacts can occur and gaps in the signal can cause blocky effects or screen blanking, generally an HDMI signal will display whenever the signal successfully reaches the receiver. Claims that more expensive cables put forth greater video or audio fidelity are nonsense;"
directly contradict this at the end?
"No one saw any appreciable difference between the $3 cables and the $120 cable, or any of the cables in between. However, we did notice a curious phenomenon: the screen appeared slightly darker and a bit more saturated when connected to the Blu-ray player with the Monster Cable 1200 High Definition Experience Pack cable. The HDTV showed that it was receiving the same 12-bit color depth information through each cable, so the more-expensive Monster cable wasn't pushing through more color detail. Again, the difference was minimal, and could be corrected by calibrating your HDTV."
The contradiction there immediately makes me assume all of their testing methodology is bogus and any other "facts" they introduce in support of whatever argument they're trying to make are probably suspect...
I know they're right, and multi hundred dollar Monster Cables are snake-oil, but I'm also left with the distinct impression that anybody who finds the Monster Cable's transmission of a digital video signal "curiously darker and more saturated" has shown themselves to be incapable of convincing anyone that they know enough about what they're doing to change anybodies opinion. (In fact I _strongly_ suspect Monster's notoriously evil marketing department have had a hand n this "review"... How long till we see articles linking to this saying "Look, even the skeptics who know all the digital domain science can see the improved picture from our Monster Cable 1200 High Definition Experience Pack cable!" Notice how strongly brand and product specific that statement is, it's almost as though it's specifically written for SEO juice...)