4 ms·
Arguably, the middle class was the result of economic friction. If there are no barriers to scale, eventually there are a small number of big winners. Historic
by Animats 6y ago
Arguably, the middle class was the result of economic friction. If there are no barriers to scale, eventually there are a small number of big winners.
Historically, distance was a big source of economic friction. This make local retailing and manufacturing a profitable enterprise. As shipping became cheaper and more reliable, local retailing and manufacturing became economically impractical.
Another source of economic friction that generated a middle class was the need for a large number of middle managers and clerical staff to operate a large enterprise. This had two effects. One, it employed large numbers of people. Two, the cost of operating the organization scaled faster than linearly, and this prevented organizations from scaling to planetary scale. Computers have eliminated both those obstacles.
Perhaps the middle class was merely an artifact of the period between the Industrial Revolution and the Computer Revolution, and is now gone forever.
- mjfl 6y ago> If there are no barriers to scale, eventually there are a small number of big winners. There is technically no contradiction between the existence of a middle class and the existence of a small number of big winners. > Perhaps the middle class was merely an artifact of the period between the Industrial Revolution and the Computer Revolution, and is now gone forever. are software engineers the upper class then or are they part of the proletariat? What about doctors and lawyers?
- burlesona 6y agoThe upper class, without a doubt.
- adrianN 6y agoHistorically, the upper class was a class of rentiers who didn't have to "work" as such. Programmers would rather be part of the same class as rich merchants in the past.
- meheleventyone 6y agoVery much the petite bourgeoisie.
- mjfl 6y agoyou are all dancing around the point, which is that the middle class very much still exists.
- fladrif 6y agoPerhaps part of a new breed of middle class. Instead of a distance or management friction, this is a scaling friction. In order to scale, programmers are required. Maybe this correlates with doctors and lawyers, albeit a different friction, one of artificial scarcity (limits to who can attend medical/law school, and whatever certification is required afterwards).
- glouwbug 6y agoI'd argue Canadian software engineers are lower class
- notfromhere 6y agoA middle class is a political choice. The post war rise of the middle class was because of conscious policy choices made by the architects of the new deal and their successors. The policies that supported the middle class have just been slowly undone in the wake of the Reagan “Revolution”
- adrianN 6y agoA progressive tax system is another form of friction that prevents infinite scaling.
- notfromhere 6y agoNot sure why scaling is assumed to be a moral good here.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoWell... I think the modern sense of the term "middle class" is a purely modern invention. As far as I'm aware, the historical "middle class" was never conceived of as being in the "middle" economically. They were the middle class because they were rich like aristocrats, without being nobly born like aristocrats. That put them in the middle of no scales of status; rather, they pegged the high end of economic status, and the low end of blueblood status. They couldn't be treated as well as noblemen, because (1) they weren't noblemen, and (2) everybody hated them. But they couldn't be treated as poorly as peasants, because they were too rich. I don't see what we gain by applying this term to the majority of the United States today; the concepts just don't match up.