3 ms·
There have been some interesting comments here since I posted this article just before I took my son to his soccer tournament. Now that I'm back, I see some com
by tokenadult 16y ago
There have been some interesting comments here since I posted this article just before I took my son to his soccer tournament. Now that I'm back, I see some commenters have suggested that some of the occupations identified in the submitted article as probably not needing state licenses (as indeed they don't need in many states) do need licenses. Those suggestions by my fellow HN participants are often made on the basis of hypothetical examples or imagined worst cases.
My own sister has formal training in interior design from a baccalaureate program at a state university, and she has pursued that occupation since graduation for more than two decades. I am aware from my sister's work in commercial interior design in a big city with skyscraper office buildings that some interior designers have somewhat of an influence on the safety of public spaces. But it's ludicrous to think that Florida's pattern of regulation of interior designers is in any sense motivated by public safety concerns. If there are such huge public safety concerns from interior designers not being state licensed, why do we not hear news stories from other states with different patterns of regulation about all the people who die from entering buildings that are owned by owners who hired unlicensed interior designers?
The experiment in federalism that has been going on in the United States offers a wonderful comparative laboratory of policies. Unfortunately, for reasons well explored by public choice theory,
http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/PublicChoice.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/PublicChoice.html
state legislatures often ignore the real-world experience of other states in setting policy, preferring instead to listen to rent-seeking
http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentSeeking.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentSeeking.html
lobbyists who divert attention from real-world experience to focus on hypothetical harms that could (maybe) happen if they don't obtain their favorite kind of special treatment. So I would respectfully suggest to my fellow HN participants that if someone wants to make a case that some occupation (e.g., hacking to build web-based SaaS businesses?) should be regulated by state-issued licenses, the persuasive way to make that case is to refer to detailed statistics about actual benefits or harms to the general population, rather than referring to imagination or common fears.
P.S. The one time I had to shop for a surgeon, for my wife, I asked my mom, an operating room nurse who has worked with some world-famous surgeons, to help me find the best doctors in town. That she was readily able to do. People always work the best network they can for the other people they care about most, and life will always be this way, regulation or no regulation. My wife had a completely uneventful and full recovery from her surgery.