3 ms·
I'm not sure if this can ever exist in a world with scarcity. > a recent study of kids ages eight to 12 found that nearly 30% aspire to become YouTubers Peopl
by dehrmann 6y ago
I'm not sure if this can ever exist in a world with scarcity.
> a recent study of kids ages eight to 12 found that nearly 30% aspire to become YouTubers
People will always want to go out there, do their own thing, and get paid a middle-class wage for it. The problem is there's a surplus of these people, most actually aren't talented enough to achieve that, and for those who don't have a natural market fit with what they do, they'll have to compromise their vision.
It reminds me of artists getting priced out of a gentrifying urban center. It takes away the character of the neighborhood, but who is to say their art is good, worth fighting for, and that they're more deserving of their apartment than someone with enough money to afford the apartment.
Basically, I don't want to subsidize someone's hobby/lifestyle. I completely support them doing what they want, I just don't want to hear complaints that there's no money in it.
- afterwalk 6y agoI wonder what percentage of kids age 8-12 want to become a professional athlete. I bet it's at least 100-1000x than the amount of job opening at the "can make a full time income" level. In that case it's mostly the parents that subsidize the lifestyle up until college level.
- dehrmann 6y agoI have a high school classmate who played pro football for a couple of years. I never got the impression his parents did that much for him to subsidize foodball; it's not like rich parents trying to train their kids to be world-class squash players. It still could have been a $500-$5,000 per year subsidy, though.
- harimau777 6y agoI don't know if this is accurate or romanticized, but my perception is that in the past people who wanted to live as artists were able to do so as long as they were willing to give up some material comfort. For example, maybe they could work a day job (stereotypically waiting tables) and still make enough money for a studio in a bad part of town. It doesn't seem like that's the case today. Unless you have a profession or work multiple jobs (both of which prohibit having enough time to seriously pursue art) you are completely priced out of America's cosmopolitan cities.
- dehrmann 6y ago> maybe they could work a day job (stereotypically waiting tables) and still make enough money for a studio in a bad part of town. I respect this; they decided what's important to them, and I think this is a fair situation to be in. > It doesn't seem like that's the case today While I agree, at least in the Bay Area, I'm not super sympathetic to this because, and I'm guessing here, I bet a lot of the people who got priced-out or evicted in the last decade+ voted for supervisors in favor preservation and anti-landlord policies. There weren't artists saying "build new luxury condos so I'm not competing with engineers for a run-down studio."
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Unless you have a profession or work multiple jobs (both of which prohibit having enough time to seriously pursue art) you are completely priced out of America's cosmopolitan cities. The bad parts of cities are still cheap. Within the last ~4yr I did a $1500/mo single bedroom in Boston and a $1300 single bedroom in Waltham (which is a nice but not "surgeons and lawyers buy houses here suburb of Boston). Yes there were mice but I think that is a pretty reasonable trade for the price. Things start getting stupid expensive when you try to live how you think a white collar professional should live.
- charlesu 6y ago$1500 a month for an apartment is a ton. In most places, you’d need to make $60,000 to meet the minimum income requirement. That’s a lot of many for many people.
- dehrmann 6y agoIt'd be rough, but you could make $1500 rent work if you make $20 per hour. You might need a larger security deposit because of your income, but landlords might also not check.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThat's for a single bedroom with parking which are always priced at a premium. You can do better. I just didn't. In the Boston area anyone with a flimsy wisp of a skill (or is able to pass a drug test) is making at least $20/hr and nobody is expecting the poor to be able to follow middle class budgeting rules.
- sershe 6y agoAnother aspect is whether these numbers from what kids want at age 10 are worth considering at all. When I was 8-10 I quite seriously wanted to be a soccer player, even though even to a 9-yo me it was starting to become obvious that the ship has sailed, and I wasn't even talented anyway. A classmate (1992-3 in Russia) told me earnestly they wanted to be a contract killer, it was viewed as a glamorous job ;)