5 ms·
I used to think the same way. But now that I see how pervasive a force racism has been in America's history, I have a different view. Now I think it's worth ask
by wpietri 6y ago
I used to think the same way. But now that I see how pervasive a force racism has been in America's history, I have a different view. Now I think it's worth asking both questions: Is racism really at play? And given America's lasting, endemic racism, is there reason to think something makes it absent in a given case?
A couple of the books that turned me around here: Kendi's "Stamped from the Beginning", a history of racist ideas. And Loewen's "Sundown Towns", a look at the wave of ethnic cleansing during the Nadir that happened across America. I had known about the Tulsa Massacre, but what I didn't know was how common smaller-scale events were for decades.
- BoiledCabbage 6y agoI think you've hit on the true issue. The majority of people have only leared on a superficial level of of the intertwined racism of America's past - often times mostly the light touches they learned in elementary school. And what's taught in elementary school is intentionally simplified to something deemed appropriate for children. Some summary of slavery is bad, MLK, Rosa Parks, sit-ins... Most people don't actually learn anything about American's history and ties with racism at an adult level. So instead people think they know the history of it, and as a result think (based on what they've learned) it's overblown. Anyone I know who has actually taken time as an adult to read about American history and its relationship with racism, comes away with a very different view point. It's so intertwined it's incredible.
- dsohn0 6y agoBlack people want their victimhood to last 1000 years. Let's not pretend American racism is somehow exceptional. Africans have been committing ethnic cleansing as a continental pastime for centuries and no one cries a river about that.
- aksss 6y agoI often think the people who talk loudly and overly-much about the US’s endemic racism have never travelled abroad much to witness what the rest of the world is really like (looking at you, Japan). It’s a product of an education curriculum that is hyper-focused on the misdeeds of the US. While the misdeeds need attention the view completely lacks an honest accounting of how amazing the state of this 325m culturally heterogenous society is compared to.. throw a dart at the world map.
- kelnos 6y agoSerious question (because I don't know the answer, or how to find out): are there many other places in the (first) world where people of a minority race are singled out for harassment by law enforcement, to the point where police are routinely murdering people of that race with little to no consequences? If not, then I think a focus on the US's particular brand of racism is warranted. I do agree with you that it is fairly remarkable that the US is as stable as it is given the large mix of cultural views and values... but that doesn't let us off the hook for the problems we do have.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoBut your claims aren’t back by data either. Your first paragraph is made up. https://samharris.org/can-pull-back-brink/ https://samharris.org/can-pull-back-brink/ (I link Sam Harris because of his bigger point about people echoing talking points completely divorced from the data, as you have done. You can check his data sources.)
- kelnos 6y agoWow, that was a lot of meandering I had to read through before Harris actually got to the point I think you're referencing. But I don't see him present any evidence. He starts by hand-waving away people who believe the opposite of what he believes, and then just basically says "only about 1000 people in total are killed by cops in the US every year, so this is a non-problem". Which... no, sorry, that's not how it works. And the thing he links to literally has a section heading titled "Black Americans are killed at a much higher rate than White Americans". ... and then he goes on for many paragraphs about several police shootings of black men, and how awful and unjustified they are, so... he seems to agree after all that this is a problem? Finally, he tries to muddy the waters by essentially claiming black people seem to "deserve it" more, because apparently black people are involved in more crime than white people? Which, again, doesn't seem to be very well supported by data. So... I don't really get why you're using this link to try to refute what I said, because it does not do that, at least not in a logically consistent, evidence-based manner. > But your claims aren’t back by data either. I believe they are. Let's look at some actual data that we can easily read, rather than attempting to extract something useful from a meandering 15,000 word podcast transcript that rambles on forever. This[0] shows that out of all US police shooting deaths from 2107 through now, 27% were of black people, and 49% were of white people. But black people only make up only 13% of the US population, while white people make up 60%, so that sounds pretty disproportionate against black people to me. But this data is only for shooting deaths; likely someone like George Floyd, for example, wouldn't be counted in that data as he wasn't shot. So let's take a look at this study[1] from last year (reported on here[2]) that suggests blacks are 2.5 times more likely to be killed by police than whites. I could go on, but I'll let you educate yourself further if you're so inclined; "police killings statistics by race" is the search I used. > people echoing talking points completely divorced from the data, as you have done. I don't believe that's what I've done; Harris' own views seem completely divorced even from what little data he presents, if one can be expected to actually find data in that nightmare of a transcript. [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/585152/people-shot-to-death-by-us-police-by-race/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/585152/people-shot-to-de... [1] https://www.pnas.org/content/116/34/16793 https://www.pnas.org/content/116/34/16793 [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-08-06/race-and-police-shootings-what-new-research-says https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-08-06/race-and-...
- wpietri 6y agoThat was certainly my experience. What I learned about racism up through high school was basically, "This stuff happened, but long ago and far away, unconnected to what's going on around you." And it's no coincidence that I learned this in a suburban school with a student body that was 1% black. In a state that was 14% black. And that had a long history of racial exclusion and white flight. I'm shocked now at how one-sided my initial education was on this. Shocked, but not surprised.
- rayiner 6y agoI’m really not sure there is a sound conclusion to be drawn from comparing the Tulsa Massacre to people being skeptical of food from a different culture. The former is something that’s a unique and very ugly aspect of American history. The latter is pretty much universal.[1] You can squint and lump both things under the umbrella of “racism” but they’re so different as to be two completely different kind of things. And I don’t think it’s particularly useful to analyze both through the same lens. Note that when Kendi talks about “racism” he’s talking about anti-Black racism specifically. I think folks try to generalize his ideas in a way that goes beyond what he actually purports to address. [1] My Bangladeshi mom had a tinge of skepticism upon first learning my girlfriend (now wife) was from Oregon, “because they eat snakes.”
- Frondo 6y agoBefore you edited your comment, you said something about Americans being very willing to embrace foods from cultures around the world. For some reason, that remark reminded me of one of the talking points of the 2016 election, the specter of "taco trucks on every corner," and how the Republican campaign that year suggested that that'd be a bad thing.
- rayiner 6y agoTrump throws a lot of stuff at the wall to see what sticks. That one didn’t even register with his own base. I remember having lunch one day in central Illinois—a rural county that went for Trump by 20 points this year. The most popular restaurant in town was a Mexican place. Even Breitbart likes taco trucks: https://www.breitbart.com/health/2020/09/17/video-daughter-helps-save-dads-taco-truck-after-he-earns-just-6-one-day/ https://www.breitbart.com/health/2020/09/17/video-daughter-h...
- chanakya 6y agoI'd go even further and say that just because America has a history of racism and racist ideas does not mean that racism continues to be a major factor today. I've read Kendi, and he offers scant evidence that it is.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- strogonoff 6y agoPerhaps it would help knowing that dislike for MSG flavor enhancer is also a thing in other countries besides the US, and can happen without any exposure to Chinese food whatsoever. It is justified with following reasoning. If: 1. I trust that my body will enjoy the taste of well-prepared food from healthy fresh ingredients, and will inform me when I ate enough. 2. MSG makes anything taste better. It follows that: 3. With MSG added, my body can be fooled into eating unhealthy food and it can be fooled into wanting more food than it needs. 4. All else equal, I will assume that a chef who does not use MSG is more skilful than a chef who does. This logic may well be faulty, superstitious, misinformed, etc., but what it is not is racist. (Addendum: “Chinese restaurant syndrome” is a different thing though, and unlike basic distaste for MSG it does give off an antagonistic vibe. It’s interesting that it happens in the US of all places—I bet many people around the world associate MSG first and foremost with snacks from American brands like Pringles.)