2 ms·
Calls to "lock up the bastards" might give some short-lived emotional satisfaction but rarely translate into anything resembling victory (see the war on drugs).
by pseudolus 6y ago
Calls to "lock up the bastards" might give some short-lived emotional satisfaction but rarely translate into anything resembling victory (see the war on drugs). The burden of proof in criminal matters is "beyond a reasonable doubt". I'm somewhat doubtful that prosecutors, faced with an onslaught of defense counsel and sympathetic jurors, will meet that burden in white collar crimes. The answer isn't jail but rather developing the will to overcome regulatory capture and to enforce existing legislation which is more than sufficient to counter monopolies.
- alisonkisk 6y agoAnd taxation, to make evil geniuses less interested in the activity in the first place, creating room for less evil geniuses.
- lmeyerov 6y agoBigcorps are veto-driven as no one wants to be the one to kill the cash cow, and VPs will do unethical things as long as they are legal and benefit the company + their immediate team, justifying it as 'good business leadership.' So jailtime and meaningful fines shifts burden from 'a fee smaller than your bonus / company profit' to 'oh shit.' Truly bug and evil stuff happens, but most normal VP politics has email + file trails due to design docs, legal agreements, etc. Harder part seems like knowing what to subpeona and in time :)
- zarkov99 6y agoDo you feel the same way about the malfeasance that brought on the financial crisis?
- pseudolus 6y agoThe malfeasance that brought on the financial crisis is illustrative. It ultimately led to one criminal prosecution that involved a small single digit number of branches Chinese-American community bank (Abacus Bank). The prosecution was ultimately unsuccessful. If the government couldn't pull off a successful prosecution of such a small fish then why believe they'll be successful with the likes of FAANG? Best to devote the limited resources the government has to proactively utilizing its powers and enforcing anti-monopoly legislation. If it was readily capable of doing so in the past, why not now? In passing, the debacle that was the prosecution of Abacus Bank was the subject of a great documentary 'Small Enough to Jail' [0][1]. It's demonstrative of whom the government will ultimately always chose to prosecute. In the case of Abacus Bank, an institution that had a significantly lower default rate than most large banks. [0] https://www.pbs.org/video/abacus-small-enough-to-jail-suqmxe/ https://www.pbs.org/video/abacus-small-enough-to-jail-suqmxe... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abacus:_Small_Enough_to_Jail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abacus:_Small_Enough_to_Jail
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoTo me this reads like a generic argument to de-criminalise white collar crime and fraud. Untill we have prosecution for executives, events like 2008 and boeing will keep coming.
- ashtonkem 6y agoWhite collar crimes often include a special requirement that other crimes don’t have; a requirement that the accused were aware of the illegality of their actions. This is an extremely hard bar to clear for prosecutors, which is why they often don’t pursue criminal charges that seem obvious from the outside.