4 ms·
Should medical science only promote “get rich quick” surgical procedures and refuse to consider that “work hard first” lifestyle changes are effective for the v
by floatingatoll 6y ago
Should medical science only promote “get rich quick” surgical procedures and refuse to consider that “work hard first” lifestyle changes are effective for the vast majority of patients that work diligently towards health? No: lifestyle changes are a preventative and curative step that can avoid diseases and surgeries in many other fields.
Medicine is absolutely capable of demanding patients work diligently towards lifestyle changes before they receive surgical intervention. For example, if you want an organ transplant and you aren’t working diligently towards health (often with exactly the same list of lifestyle changes as above!) you may be denied your organ transplant.
The problem she fought against was that surgeons didn’t want to consider that the lifestyle changes method could possibly be effective. She was right; they were wrong.
So now it’s left to medicine to decide when and how to take that into account in their treatment recommendations and standards of care. As you describe, this is a Hard Problem, but it’s a familiar one. They already have lots of experience with treatment through lifestyle change, and now as a result of her work, they can apply those learning to this new area too.
Good work.
- soared 6y agoHis/her point is that by the time most people see a doctor about a problem, it is too late for lifestyle changes to have an effect and that surgery is semi-urgently necessary.
- yostrovs 6y agoDoctors know full well that exercise, diet, etc can drastically improve health. Do you really think they are willfully ignorant? They also know their patients that they told a hundred times to start exercising, etc. Now these patients have serious, life threatening conditions. You seem to deny reality and suggest that they finally convince their patients to get their act together when they're 65 years old and set in their ways. How's that working so far?