3 ms·
> Why would defector accounts be biased? Experience with defectors from other countries, such as the former Soviet Union, shows they sometimes tell the truth,
by the_af 6y ago
> Why would defector accounts be biased?
Experience with defectors from other countries, such as the former Soviet Union, shows they sometimes tell the truth, they sometimes tell false or exaggerated stories, and they sometimes tell half-truths. I don't know why North Korean defectors would be different.
> and their accounts of starvation, extreme poverty, and harsh authoritarianism all support one another.
This specific claim is about people going to die in droves to caves, not just about harsh authoritarianism or extreme poverty. That's why it must be considered skeptically -- because it seems just like the kind of thing we're prone to believing about North Korea given other news, but this is not enough to make it true. And once it gets repeated uncritically, it becomes the "common sense truth".
- mtnGoat 6y agoExcept going into caves is a valid survival strategy because caves are naturally warm. If you had no heat at the surface, going subterranean would make sense to sell warmth. They weren't going into caves to die, quite the contrary, they were going into the caves to survive.