9 ms·
America's License Raj
- karzeem 16y ago> "Some occupations clearly need to be licensed. Nobody wants to unleash amateur doctors and dentists on the public." Actually, Milton Friedman famously (and impressively persuasively) did oppose mandatory licensure of doctors. http://www.fff.org/freedom/0194e.asp http://www.fff.org/freedom/0194e.asp A lot of the trouble with licensure is that it tends to ratchet upwards. If I'd been forced to spend $20,000 getting licensed as a barber, I'd be mad if a competitor opened across the street without having spent all that money. Repealing licensure requirements benefits everybody except the people who've already gotten licenses.
- barmstrong 16y agoThis is true. Part of the reason doctors have high salaries (and healthcare costs are high) is that the AMA issues licences and creates scarcity. In this sense, they perform a similar function to a union. It does seem like an outdated way to see if a doctor is good or not. I'd personally find a recommendation from a friend or a bunch of positive reviews on yelp a lot more convincing than the mere fact they have a license to practice. It's pretty likely hospital administrators and others would be able to determine which doctors were good without a licensing practice (just like we find good programmers without licensing), and they have strong incentives to do so.
- dkarl 16y agoI'd personally find a recommendation from a friend You would, but so would a bunch of stupid people with stupid friends. I think licensing doctors falls into the same category as mandatory school attendance, i.e., stopping people from hurting ourselves so they don't drag us down with them. To think we worry about doctors following decades-old traditions instead of evidence-based medicine, or being influenced by drug companies. Those are good worries to have! It could be a lot worse. Everyone knows you're supposed to see a doctor when you need medical care, got to take your kids to the doctor when they're sick, etc. That magic word "doctor" results in people actually getting competent medical care instead of going to a faith healer or an herbalist, which is what they'd do if anyone could call themselves a doctor and people had to discriminate for themselves. Let people screw themselves all they want if it doesn't screw me, but we should take some measures to make sure people get more competent medical care than they would be able to choose for themselves, just like we force them to educate their kids instead of putting them to work full-time when they're eight.
- fleitz 16y agoMandatory schooling has nothing to do with ensuring education and everything to do with ensuring dogma and a uniform and compliant citizenry. You need only look at the flag salute and the various rituals that have nothing to do with education to see it. Education is not mandatory, only schooling. If mandatory schooling was about education then why can't parents take their education dollar to any certified provider?
- dkarl 16y agoIf mandatory schooling was about education then why can't parents take their education dollar to any certified provider? They can, in the U.S. They can send their kids to a private school or even school them at home, provided they meet certain requirements.
- pnathan 16y agoIf you live in a free state in the US, you can take your children wheresoever you so please.
- hugh3 16y agoWait, are there states of the US where private schools don't exist? I didn't know this.
- hugh3 16y agoUhhh-huh. So if that's the case why do they waste so much time teaching you science and mathematics and ancient history and foreign languages and so forth when they could just be having four-hour flag-salutin' sessions? Not everything needs to be a vast conspiracy, y'know. Some things are slightly screwy despite the best of intentions.
- rw 16y agoBut, there is going to be pressure on those that make the judgments. What happens when someone figures out how to game the doctor rating system? I'm just very risk averse when it comes to surgery (and I want my doctors to be vetted by experts in their field, as well as my social circle).
- karzeem 16y agoAnd you're absolutely right to be risk averse. That's why if you needed major surgery, you'd go to a reputable hospital and not to some clinic above a grocery store. The hospital in this case is a middle man, and their role is vouching for the doctors they hire. When you buy a propane tank at Home Depot, the reason it doesn't blow up is that Home Depot's reputation depends on selling non-explodey propane tanks. When you buy meat at Whole Foods, why are you sure it's not rotten? Because the government checked that specific steak, or because you know Whole Foods wouldn't sell you rotten meat? Similarly, the reason people go to reputable hospitals is precisely because they know they can trust those places to hire competent staff.
- Vivtek 16y agoWhile this isn't your central point, I'm pretty sure the reason Home Depot's propane tanks don't explode is not that Home Depot is concerned for their reputation and therefore takes all necessary measures required to avoid a rather infrequent problem, but that propane tanks and their handling are, in fact, regulated by government, and that those regulations codify best practices for infrequent events. A purely free-market, reputation-based system of behavior works well for frequent events, but fails miserably for infrequent events, and that's why regulations are necessary. In other words, and more snarkily, the assumption that Home Depot hires competent staff is probably not sufficient to protect you from explosion.
- karzeem 16y agoThe government does regulate the safety of things like propane tanks, but major retailers, Home Depot included, usually have merchandise quality standards well above what the government mandates. That's suggestive (though not conclusive, I'll admit) that it's Home Depot, and not government safety standards, that keep you safe when you shop at Home Depot.
- karzeem 16y agoThere are a couple encouraging signs in medicine. First, a lot of doctors advertise that they're board-certified. That's a voluntary, private certification that attests to the doctor's competence and has more rigorous requirements than state licenses do. Without licensure, there's every reason to think that private certifications would take on even more importance. Second, the market is steadily routing around physician's monopoly on the practice of medicine. There's sverything from questionable stuff like acupuncture and chiropractic to nurses and PAs doing things that only doctors used to be allowed to do (e.g. prescriptions, minor procedures), and those trends seem to be accelerating.
- logjam 16y agoYou're completely wrong. "The average physician's net income declined 7 percent from 1995 to 2003, after adjusting for inflation, while incomes of lawyers and other professionals rose by 7 percent during the period." http://www.nytimes.com/2006/06/22/business/22doctors.html http://www.nytimes.com/2006/06/22/business/22doctors.html "...none of this really matters, because doctors' salaries aren't a large enough chunk of health care spending in the United States to make a difference. According to Reinhardt, doctors' net take-home pay (that is, income minus expenses) amounts to only about 10 percent of overall health care spending. So if you cut that by 10 percent in the name of cost savings, you'd only save about $26 billion. That's a drop in the ocean compared with overhead for insurance companies, billing expenses for doctors' offices, and advertising for drug companies. The real savings in health care will come from these expenses." http://www.slate.com/id/2227965/ http://www.slate.com/id/2227965/ The rest of your comment is incorrect as well. The AMA does not license physicians, state governments do. Many physicians don't even belong to the AMA. The AMA lobbies for physicians, but it's not in any way like a union (not that there's anything wrong with unions). Resident physicians in particular would probably lead better lives if in fact there were something like a union to limit hospitals and training programs that have traditionally worked these young physicians upwards of 100 hours a week for what amounts to minimum wage. Resident physician hours and primary care doc hours are still onerous, and most are paying education debut averaging $150,000. Physicians can practice without any involvement with a hospital, and many do. In any event, the idea of using hospital CEOs or CFOs to determine "good" doctors is about as misguided as asking British Petroleum to determine "safe" drilling engineers. There is a reason for (some) licensing. We tried the adolescent libertarian fantasy of letting the "free market" drive things like medical training and licensure back in the early days of the 20th century. You could characterize the vast majority of medical education in that era as training in quackery, before people like Abraham Flexner got involved: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=93666259 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=9366625...
- kiba 16y agoYou're completely wrong. "The average physician's net income declined 7 percent from 1995 to 2003, after adjusting for inflation, while incomes of lawyers and other professionals rose by 7 percent during the period." http://www.nytimes.com/2006/06/22/business/22doctors.html http://www.nytimes.com/2006/06/22/business/22doctors.html "...none of this really matters, because doctors' salaries aren't a large enough chunk of health care spending in the United States to make a difference. According to Reinhardt, doctors' net take-home pay (that is, income minus expenses) amounts to only about 10 percent of overall health care spending. So if you cut that by 10 percent in the name of cost savings, you'd only save about $26 billion. That's a drop in the ocean compared with overhead for insurance companies, billing expenses for doctors' offices, and advertising for drug companies. The real savings in health care will come from these expenses." http://www.slate.com/id/2227965/ http://www.slate.com/id/2227965/ Interesting data, but the question is if licensing scarcity increase salaries than without. The salary decrease in 1995 to 2003 doesn't tell us anything other than.....net income decrease. The rest of your comment is incorrect as well. The AMA does not license physicians, state governments do. Many physicians don't even belong to the AMA. The AMA lobbies for physicians, but it's not in any way like a union (not that there's anything wrong with unions). Would it be possible that AMA effectively limits licensing rate through their lobbying? There is a reason for (some) licensing. We tried the adolescent libertarian fantasy of letting the "free market" drive things like medical training and licensure back in the early days of the 20th century. You could characterize the vast majority of medical education in that era as training in quackery, before people like Abraham Flexner got involved: Interesting data, but not enough details to support your statement. We need more details on what kind of reforms were made, privately or governmental.
- almost 16y ago> I'd personally find a recommendation from a friend Plenty of people already use that method. And a lot of them go to see homeopaths and chiropractors based on that. Can you image what would happen to those people if they had to use recommendations from friends when they had actual medical problems that require actual doctors?
- dpatru 16y agoJust last month one of my friends with a debilitating back condition that forced her to spend many days in bed was told by medical doctors that she needed surgery to get rid of the pain. On the advice of friends, she went to a chiropractor and got immediate relief. The chiropractor solved her problem without surgery. Medical doctors have their place, but so do other healers.
- hugh3 16y agoAre you really gonna rely on a bunch of reviews on yelp to tell you which doctors are competent? I don't even trust yelp reviews to tell me which restaurant to go to. Everything seems to have 3.8 stars...
- msie 16y agoActually, Milton Friedman famously (and impressively persuasively) did oppose mandatory licensure of doctors. Can you summarize what his argument is? Can't we count on some upfront testing that will weed out the people who clearly cannot call themselves doctors? Is testing the same as licensure?
- karzeem 16y agoHe argues that private certification organizations (think Consumer Reports, but for doctors) are a more reliable and versatile way to see how competent a doctor is, and also that hospitals and clinics have an incentive to only hire competent people. The rebuttal would be "Fine, but certainly state licensure can't hurt. It's just a backup." He says that it does in fact hurt, by allowing the AMA to control the supply of people who get to practice medicine. This limits patients' options w/r/t how, from whom, and for what price they can get medical care. E.g. suppose I find a competent, well-trained nurse to remove a mole for me. The nurse and I agree to go ahead for $100. Friedman says that it's a) morally wrong and b) inefficient for the government to barge in and say, "No, for your own safety, you're not allowed to make this voluntary agreement. You have to have a doctor do this. Oh, and it'll cost $300." That's the effect of a law that says only licensed physicians are allowed to remove moles.
- pyre 16y agoMy rebuttal: private certification organizations that, over time, reduce the effectiveness (strictness) of their testing because they are (e.g.) afraid of getting sued (libel, slander, discrimination, etc) by people that have been denied.
- Symmetry 16y agoOn the other hand, there seems to be a big shortfall in the supply of doctors, in the US at least, so less strict testing than we have now might be a good thing. http://theincidentaleconomist.com/wordpress/why-cant-we-have-more-doctors/ http://theincidentaleconomist.com/wordpress/why-cant-we-have...
- fleitz 16y agoIt's interesting that you mention Friedman, in his series Free to Choose he outlines the AMA position against paramedics. It seems quite funny now but if you think about it it really outlines a larger issue with the AMA and the Hippocratic Oath. If you read most of the oath it's really about dividing up healthcare into monopolies.
- forensic 16y agoPeople who gained power and money in America's free market closing the door behind them. It's really sad.
- lukifer 16y agoThis is a frequent pattern in many contexts. A wave of immigrants gets demonized, they integrate over the course of a few generations, and then they turn around and demonize the next wave of immigrants. A school of art or literature survives the scoffing of the old guard, only to become the old guard themselves, et cetera.
- karamazov 16y agoDescendents of immigrants are not immigrants.
- alexqgb 16y agoIt's known as "pulling up the ladder behind you".
- tzs 16y agoBut, as the Wall Street Journal has doggedly pointed out, America’s Licence Raj has extended its tentacles into occupations that pose no plausible threat to health or safety—occupations, moreover, that are governed by considerations of taste rather than anything that can be objectively measured by licensing authorities. The list of jobs that require licences in some states already sounds like something from Monty Python—florists, handymen, wrestlers, tour guides, frozen-dessert sellers, firework operatives, second-hand booksellers and, of course, interior designers—but it will become sillier still if ambitious cat-groomers and dog-walkers get their way Handymen, frozen-dessert sellers, and firework operatives all plausibly involve health or safety concerns. Where in the US do second-hand booksellers need a license? I suspect that they may be counting for some of these requirements to have a business license, rather than any license tied specifically to the occupation. They may also be mixing up requirements to be licensed with requirements to be bonded.
- solutionyogi 16y agoDo you know that you need a license to be a barber? Or that in Texas, you need a license to be a florist? [ http://www.agr.state.tx.us/agr/program_render/0,1987,1848_5649_0_0,00.html?channelId=5649 http://www.agr.state.tx.us/agr/program_render/0,1987,1848_56... ] I can learn programming on my own (through books or Internet) and get a employment as a programmer working on business critical systems and I do not need to get any license from anyone. But hey, if I want to cut someone's hair, I need to pay my dues to the state? I think for non medical businesses, the licensing requirements should be removed. We save tax payer's money and there could be more competition in the market place which will benefit the consumer. [And don't worry about protecting the consumer, once you get a bad hair cut from a salon, you will announce it to the world (thanks to the Internet) that the hair salon is bad and you will never visit that place again. Market forces will take care of the crappy businesses.]
- _delirium 16y agoBarbers are actually one of the traditional license-requiring occupations going back centuries, because one of their main jobs used to be shaving men with straight razors, which carried a risk of injury or disease if the barber was poorly trained, or if the equipment was poorly disinfected. It might admittedly be a bit obsolete now.
- jasonjei 16y agoWhat the British author of the article should point out is that the US states determine how and what professions are licensed. Some US federal laws and regulations require licensure in a profession in federal domain, but those requirements are determined by the state (e.g, Arizona CPA licensure has greater school credit requirements than a Georgian CPA).
- mef 16y agoAs a counterpoint, here's the pro-licensing argument for interior designers from a friend's mother who is an interior designer in Florida: interior designers are distinct from interior decorators in that they often propose structural changes to buildings that, if done improperly, could compromise the integrity of the structure. Licensing interior designers is another layer of safety akin to a building permit for someone renovating their home.
- lukesandberg 16y agobut presumably you would still need to actually hire carpenters/architects and get a building permit to implement the structural changes. I don't think you should need to be licensed to make a recommendation.
- pyre 16y agoI think that the implication is that the designer is acting as the architect, and just directly hiring the carpenters/etc. I don't know if this is true or not though.
- flogic 16y agoIsn't approving structural changes why we have PEs?
- jrwoodruff 16y agoI'm not sure why wrestlers, tour guides and handymen need to be licensed, but many of the professions the author highlights genuinely should be licensed. The main profession the article picks on - interior designers - seems to be misunderstood by the author. He incorrectly insinuates interior designers only choose fabrics and colors. In fact, interior designers are professionals who have completed training in space management, ergonomics and architecture. They are able to recommend structural changes that could, if designed incorrectly, cause structural damage. Interior Decorators, who in fact are NOT licensed, are limited to choosing fabrics and colors (so to speak). More info: http://www.schools-of-interior-design.com/Interior-Design-vs.-Interior-Decorating.htm http://www.schools-of-interior-design.com/Interior-Design-vs... Some of his other examples: Frozen desert sellers - I hate to bring out the '...but think of the children argument,' but seriously, do you know if the grungy dude in the van selling ice-cream to your kids knows how to handle food safely? Has a criminal record? Has 12 DUIs? Firework Operators - their job is to set off large explosions close to large crowds, occasionally indoors. I, for one, don't have a problem making sure they know what they're doing. So the author may have a valid point, but his poor choice of examples does not support his case well in my opinion.
- impendia 16y agoWhat is "space management"? It seems clear that if someone is going to recommend putting holes through walls, they should be appropriately educated and licensed. But I clicked through to your link, and it appears that the biggest difference is that interior designers are required to be familiar with various building codes and the like. In other words, bureaucracy begets bureaucracy.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Muzza 16y ago> Frozen desert sellers - I hate to bring out the '...but think of the children argument,' but seriously, do you know if the grungy dude in the van selling ice-cream to your kids knows how to handle food safely? Has a criminal record? Has 12 DUIs? I fail to see the relevance of criminal records and DUIs to handling ice cream.
- fleitz 16y agoIt's laughable the professions that require licensing. Up here in Vancouver you need a license just to be a waitress.
- pyre 16y agoIIRC in Ontario (Canada), you need a license to serve alcohol, though I believe it's basically just a series of classes to make sure that people all have a baseline level of competency in things like "determining if someone is too drunk" or stuff like that.
- sskates 16y agoThank goodness any form of licensing or certification never caught on in the tech community. Way too libertarian to let any of that sort of stuff stand. On the flip side the worst that can happen in the vast majority of cases is that programs won't work (or maybe they'll even lose your data or leak it to the world). It's pretty rare that a programming error can kill someone.
- tokenadult 16y agoThere have been some interesting comments here since I posted this article just before I took my son to his soccer tournament. Now that I'm back, I see some commenters have suggested that some of the occupations identified in the submitted article as probably not needing state licenses (as indeed they don't need in many states) do need licenses. Those suggestions by my fellow HN participants are often made on the basis of hypothetical examples or imagined worst cases. My own sister has formal training in interior design from a baccalaureate program at a state university, and she has pursued that occupation since graduation for more than two decades. I am aware from my sister's work in commercial interior design in a big city with skyscraper office buildings that some interior designers have somewhat of an influence on the safety of public spaces. But it's ludicrous to think that Florida's pattern of regulation of interior designers is in any sense motivated by public safety concerns. If there are such huge public safety concerns from interior designers not being state licensed, why do we not hear news stories from other states with different patterns of regulation about all the people who die from entering buildings that are owned by owners who hired unlicensed interior designers? The experiment in federalism that has been going on in the United States offers a wonderful comparative laboratory of policies. Unfortunately, for reasons well explored by public choice theory, http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/PublicChoice.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/PublicChoice.html state legislatures often ignore the real-world experience of other states in setting policy, preferring instead to listen to rent-seeking http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentSeeking.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentSeeking.html lobbyists who divert attention from real-world experience to focus on hypothetical harms that could (maybe) happen if they don't obtain their favorite kind of special treatment. So I would respectfully suggest to my fellow HN participants that if someone wants to make a case that some occupation (e.g., hacking to build web-based SaaS businesses?) should be regulated by state-issued licenses, the persuasive way to make that case is to refer to detailed statistics about actual benefits or harms to the general population, rather than referring to imagination or common fears. P.S. The one time I had to shop for a surgeon, for my wife, I asked my mom, an operating room nurse who has worked with some world-famous surgeons, to help me find the best doctors in town. That she was readily able to do. People always work the best network they can for the other people they care about most, and life will always be this way, regulation or no regulation. My wife had a completely uneventful and full recovery from her surgery.
- xnerdr 16y agoI'd suggest it's partly a matter of time investment required. If I could get a barber license in 4 weeks, or even 12 weeks, I wouldn't mind. But at a year of study, it becomes a more serious venture.
- ianb 16y agoThough not professional licensing, we had an example of the unintended consequences of licensing here (Minneapolis) when there was a proposal to license community gardens. Though the licensing would not be particularly expensive it would also mean gardens would require insurance, because the city would have liability if something happened at a licensed location (but as long as the city simply wasn't involved no one could sue the city). The result of course would simply halt these otherwise entirely non-commercial efforts, as much out of bureaucratic overhead as financial.