3 ms·
Journalism is the act of hunting for truth. I don't think any reputable outlet goes into an investigation knowing what the outcome is going to be. Journalists a
by dmschulman 6y ago
Journalism is the act of hunting for truth. I don't think any reputable outlet goes into an investigation knowing what the outcome is going to be. Journalists are good at looking at evidence and identifying possible outcomes and many times their assumptions turn out to be true after rigorous research, but this is different then knowing what an outcome of a story is going to be.
- danso 6y agoYes, that's right. But reporters almost never publish an investigation while having extensive doubt and just leave it up to the reader as an exercise to evaluate the assertions. Here are the Pulitzers for International Reporting, for which "Caliphate" was a finalist in 2019: https://www.pulitzer.org/prize-winners-by-category/210 https://www.pulitzer.org/prize-winners-by-category/210 I challenge you to find another winner or finalist in this category in which the truth value of the published assertions is portrayed as merely optional.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> Yes, that's right. But reporters almost never publish an investigation while having extensive doubt and just leave it up to the reader as an exercise to evaluate the assertions. Well, it's what the original Serial did. That format has inspired a lot of the podcasting world.
- danso 6y agoFor starters, Serial is universally regarded as an exceptional project – i.e. the exception that proves the rule – and a project that has always been under a considerable amount of controversy. In any case, the podcast itself never insinuated that it could make a case for Adnan Syed's innocence. And more relevant with respect to Caliphate, the foundational facts are not in doubt: Adnan Syed was indeed the ex-boyfriend of the victim, and he was indeed convicted of her murder and serving a life sentence.