3 ms·
My guess it was some simple rules like older doctors go first No need to guess. "It used an algorithm that assigned each person a crude risk score, taking int
by reaperducer 6y ago
My guess it was some simple rules like older doctors go first
No need to guess.
"It used an algorithm that assigned each person a crude risk score, taking into account factors such as age, job description and the number of coronavirus cases that had been detected in their hospital department. That resulted in personnel like environmental services workers, food service workers and older employees being shuttled to the front of the line.
Residents, who are early in their careers and tend to be young, rotate throughout the hospital to train with various teams of physicians, making them difficult to place in a designated unit."
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/18/world/covid-stanford-health-center-vaccine-protest.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/18/world/covid-stanford-heal...
- bosswipe 6y agoI really don't think you can call that an algorithm, it's a set of human defined rules. You could call it a formula, but an algorithm implies a series of steps which are not present here.
- zimpenfish 6y agoSince algorithm is defined as "a process or set of rules to be followed in calculations or other problem-solving operations", how is it not an algorithm?
- bosswipe 6y agoGoing by that definition, the rules here are not defining the steps to be followed to do the calculation. The rules here are defining the answer that they want, not the steps necessary to figure it out.
- jrochkind1 6y agoI guess they do deserve some credit for prioritizing food service workers and such who are in high-contact situations, not just medical workers! In addition to having a bug for residents without designated units (which again, how did they not test it on a sample set including residents?), it sounds like they maybe weighted age (or department?) too much compared to job description. It doesn't seem like an older physician that is working from home should be weighted higher than nearly anyone working every day in the hospital, regardless of age or if other people in their department working in the hospital got sick already. It seems like amount of contact with patients should have been weighted far higher than anything else (patients for elective procedures are required to get a virus test first, so amount of contact with untested patients like in ER, or covid+ patients like those who need to care for them, even higher). But I'm not a doctor or medical ethicist. If Stanford has a reason for not doing that, they can, well, explain it, if they want to look better. It makes me figure it was just not done very carefully. It seems to me that formula was just not very good. While it's technically an "algorithm", sure, I think most of us in the field would just call that a "formula" not an algorithm. I think they use the phrase "algorithm" precisely because to the layperson it seems more mysterious, more sophisticated, more complicated, harder to question, less obvious that was just something humans did, possibly not very carefully.