6 ms·
Australia?
by pjc50 6y ago
Australia?
- mhh__ 6y agoAlso New Zealand? Our (UK) response has been a bit of a clusterfuck so far, we're not a good example to judge by.
- pjc50 6y agoIndeed. We could have chosen to be an island, but that would have meant quarantining business travel.
- mhh__ 6y agoThe comedy of errors around the government has probably been worse though. Barnard Castle alone probably killed thousands, the way this government is doing contracts is probably criminal, we fucked up the T&T for months etc. etc. etc. etc.
- ljm 6y agoA comedy of errors assumes some level of ignorance or carelessness, but we have 10 years (and counting) of empirical evidence that this government is acting out of nothing but self-preservation and malice. Voting Mr Bean into office would constitute a comedy of errors; but what we have now (when you also throw Brexit into the mix) is far from funny.
- makomk 6y agoIt'd also have meant severing food supply chains (and probably also medical supply chains and a bunch of others). The UK relies on trucks coming across from the continent and continuing on to destinations throughout the country with their original drivers. Ending that would make Brexit look like a walk in the park by comparison. Also, you've got to remember that the time period during which the UK would've had to do this for it to be effective was one where the WHO and all the right-thinking people were insisting that border restrictions were counterproductive, xenophobic and made things worse, something Trump would do, and when Italy still incorrectly believed they had zero cases.
- pjc50 6y agoOnly if you assume the worst implementation without thinking of the necessary exemptions. Obviously don't cut off the food supply chain. > time period during which the UK would've had to do this for it to be effective .. lies roughly from Feburary to the present day. No reason to allow travel from countries with significant prevalence. > all the right-thinking people were insisting that border restrictions were counterproductive, xenophobic and made things worse [citation needed]
- mafribe 6y ago[citation needed] How about this: https://www.containcovid-pan.eu/ https://www.containcovid-pan.eu/? Choice quote: Given open borders within Europe, a single country alone cannot keep the number of COVID-19 cases low Let's reverse the burden of evidence, and request [citation needed] for your implicit claim that the open borders lobby is not relevant here?
- nicoburns 6y agoIt wouldn't have been that hard to implement quarantine for truck drivers (cleaning cabs and switching drivers at the crossing, etc). Not trivial. But not that hard either. There would be no need to shut down the supply chains. > the WHO and all the right-thinking people were insisting that border restrictions were counterproductive, I'd argue that these were very much the wrong-thinking people. And that the WHO advice has been pretty terrible throughout. It seems obvious to me that closing borders is appropriate in a pandemic. The UK still hasn't done this. Lots of people were going abroad on holiday between lockdowns.
- toast0 6y ago> The UK relies on trucks coming across from the continent and continuing on to destinations throughout the country with their original drivers. I'm not familiar with freight in Europe, so please excuse the diversion. They drive freight vehicles onto the Eurotunnel Shuttle or on ferries? I'm guessing this isn't containerized freight, which would seem to make sense to transfer to freight rail (at least to cross the channel).
- lend000 6y agoAnd islands. Australia may be a continent, but its low population density and lack of roads connecting it to more populous regions is certainly a contributing factor. All of the countries doing best are either authoritarian or effectively political islands (Australia, New Zealand, South Korea, Taiwan, China).
- mprovost 6y agoGreat Britain is an island...
- Symbiote 6y agoIt is probably the most connected not-tiny island. (One of the world's biggest airports, several of Europe's busiest, frequent direct rail connection to the continent, frequent ferries on many routes, fully integrated free trade + work zone.) "According to Getlink, the company which operates the Channel Tunnel, 1.64 million trucks traveled between the UK and the EU using the crossing last year. More than 2.5 million cars made the crossing, as did 51,229 buses and 2,012 freight trains. Added to the even greater volumes of truck crossings made on ferries — the Port of Dover handled a record 2.6 million trucks in 2017, according to its own figures — it accounts for a massive annual volume."
- lend000 6y agoNot to mention it has double the population of Australia and 80x the population density.
- JimTheMan 6y agoThe UK could have closed all these borders down. They just chose not too.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoThe UK could not close those borders down, we would starve.