9 ms·
The only issue that I have, is that so many people (in my industry/nation/orbit) mistake kindness for weakness. I live in New York, which has a basic culture o
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
The only issue that I have, is that so many people (in my industry/nation/orbit) mistake kindness for weakness.
I live in New York, which has a basic culture of "hyper aggressiveness." It isn't "rudeness," as so many people like to think of New Yorkers. They can be aggressively kind and generous. They are just aggressive.
I'm also in the tech industry, which seems to have a very aggressive and competitive culture.
It doesn't stop me from being kind and courteous, but it gets grating.
My experience is that, when someone mistakes courtesy for weakness, they start trying to "game" me. I put up with it for a bit, until they push too far.
Then the till gets slammed on their fingers.
They get very, very upset. Far more upset than if I had just disabused them early on.
I'm learning to enforce my boundaries earlier. It doesn't make me as popular, but it also prevents those "psycho freakouts."
- AndrewUnmuted 6y ago> It isn't "rudeness," as so many people like to think of New Yorkers. I've always suspected the perceived "rudeness" comes not from the residents of New York, but rather the people from neighboring locations that commute into New York for work. New Jersey, I'm lookin' at you.
- ohyes 6y agoAh, yes, the classic “no true New Yorker” fallacy.
- dv35z 6y agoI tend to agree with this (lived in NYC 13 years) - a lot of the rudest people are the folks to treat NYC as a transient place. That said - these people bring out the aggressiveness in the die hard New Yorkers, which creates a feedback loop... When you live in a densely packed place, it’s hard to find your peace. What happens, is that you experience one stress, unleash it somewhere else, which transfers it to more people, etc. The daily subway commute is a toss-up whether you will have a wonderful morning- get a seat, headphones, read a book, smiles from a stranger... or, barely making the train, getting smashed into a train full of angry, rained-on people, 2 strangers screaming at each other, your blood boiling inside. It’s hard to not accidentally “transmit” that stressed, anxious, distrusting feeling to the next people you interact with, further contributing to the perception that “new yorkers are rude”
- iamcreasy 6y ago> they start trying to "game" me. Can you elaborate on it? I don't have much experience interacting with people.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoIt can take many forms. Folks each have their own "schtick," but it's what they are after that matters. 1) Money 2) Property They want me to give them money or goods. 3) Prestige They want me to feed a need for prestige. This can be as simple as agreeing with them in public, an endorsement or referral, or a requirement for some kind of submissive fawning. I started to write up a detailed description of how this can happen, but realized that this is probably not the best venue for that. Suffice it to say that I have spent my entire adult life amongst some very aggressive and manipulative people, and keeping a good relationship with them, while gently enforcing personal boundaries, has always been a challenge. For me, I have a personal ethical code that revolves around rigorous personal and "cash register" Honesty, as well as Integrity.
- ohyes 6y ago> I have spent my entire adult life amongst some very aggressive and manipulative people, and keeping a good relationship with them, while gently enforcing personal boundaries, has always been a challenge. Okay, I’ll bite, why would you keep people like this around you? It sounds unpleasant.
- rhencke 6y agoYou don't always get a choice.
- flowerbeater 6y agoIn my life, this was an aggressive employee we hired who was not performing but also passive-aggressive to everyone, and at the beginning we were obligated to give them the benefit of the doubt (due to their explanations that they're struggling with the pandemic, civil unrest, family emergency, elections). Then even after gathering evidence of their poor performing, they will just keep arguing their case, and would protest to everyone who will listen, and pit people against each other. They will claim they never knew those things were their responsibilities, that they were working hard on it, and that they were just about to address the performance issues, etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bluetomcat 6y ago> I live in New York, which has a basic culture of "hyper aggressiveness" A defining trait of American culture is hyperactivity. Commenting on trivial stuff, moving around restlessly while holding a drink, despise for idle time. The "kindness" thing is a form of hyper-expressivity which is rarely seen in calm cultures.
- awillen 6y agoThis is one of those generalizations that just doesn't work for a country with hundreds of millions of people. You think those in the South and Midwest are hyperactive? Hardly. Those in sleepy beach towns? Nah. If you think that there are defining traits of that many people in a country that varies so greatly in terms of geography, lifestyle, religion and culture, then you just don't know what you're talking about.
- momokoko 6y agoI definitely think Europeans and others from homogeneous or smaller countries struggle to understand the variety and diversity of culture of the United States.
- morlockabove 6y agoIn europe, the surrounding countries are your equivalent to the different states in the us
- momokoko 6y agoThat isn’t really accurate. There is much more diversity in individual states depending on where you are than in most European countries. That statement is kind of what I mean. I don’t think most people outside, and to some extent inside the US, appreciate how much diversity of culture exists in the US.
- dukeyukey 6y ago
- warent 6y agoKindness takes courage. There seem to be a lot of people who live at a level of abstraction where they perceive every interaction as being about dominance and submission. In my humble opinion it is a very limited mindset. I consider myself to be generous person, and also slow to anger. As a result, there are people who think they hit the jackpot and found a submissive pushover who is like a flimsy tree that will bend over at the slightest breath of wind. Of course it's much more like being water; moving around obstacles, yet always forward and unstoppable. What matters is showing people that there can be real kindness and strength in the world. Sometimes it plants a seed for others to also have the courage to be kind. I believe that's how to make the world a better place. It sure makes life worth living.
- taurath 6y agoI think a lot of discussion here is conflating kindness with vulnerability. Kindness can sometimes mean vulnerability, but saying “no” is not inherently unkind. Kindness is also not necessarily self-sacrificing. You can have firm boundaries but be incredibly kind. Working out the differences to me has opened up a new level of relationships.
- the_arun 6y agoThe key is practically selfless. For eg. You are buying food from restaurant - you see a homeless person standing there with a board asking for food. But you have money only to buy one sandwich. What do you do? 1. Say "no", because you too are hungry 2. Share half of the sandwich? 3. Giving whole sandwich & walk away as a saint? (3) is super kindness, but that needs different level of thinking & practice. Kindness we are talking here is (2). Your "no" point comes for the remaining half in (2).
- closeparen 6y agoEncountering people who live on that level can be a trip. I went to lunch with some classmates after lecture. I had been fixated on the content. But the salient facts to one of my classmates were instead: who had spoken, with how much confidence, how often, for how long, how the professor seemed to feel about it. It was eye opening. There was this whole other dimension to the room, which I could barely see, but to her it was front and center. I don’t aspire to be like that primarily or exclusively, but sometimes it’s helpful to notice and pay attention to.
- austincheney 6y agoThat is often not a mistake. It is typically deliberate. On one extreme there are sociopaths that look for any opening to abuse. This is sinister, but tends to be more rare. The other extreme comprises stupid people who view any criticism as a personal assault, the Dunning-Kruger people. The Dunning-Kruger people tend to assume they are super awesome because people aren't willing to invest the energy to mention otherwise. For those wonderful angels I am willing to lie to their face, because the nonsense that comes back is a stressful nonproductive time suck. Those are the people nobody wants to work with because they are a net negative and continue to exist merely as padding for future layoffs. The common uniting theme is underdeveloped self-awareness/empathy. For everybody else kindness is a dose of honesty coupled with empathy and mutual reassurance regardless of excellent or poor performance. When it's sincere it is an investment in relationship building.
- momokoko 6y ago> when someone mistakes courtesy for weakness Can you give a concrete example you specifically encountered? I lived in New York for half of my adult life before moving west. I can’t remember ever having to be too worried about that. Is it possible you just have trouble expressing yourself outwardly?
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago> Is it possible you just have trouble expressing yourself outwardly? Well, there's always passive-aggressive insults. That's considered a low-risk approach. Looks like we've pretty much exhausted this thread. I'll just exit, stage left. Happy Holidays!
- go13 6y agoMaybe that's because you are giving your kindness to the wrong people? And for the kindness to be appreciated and not considered as weakness you need to select who to give it to properly. And for that you need to be judgemental. And bbc and current mainstream median culture will not tell you to be judgemental. Why? Because they they want to be the teller what is right and what is wrong - not you.
- enriquto 6y ago> so many people (in my industry/nation/orbit) mistake kindness for weakness. A complementary but closely related problem is that many people mistake unkindness for aggression.
- harimau777 6y agoIsn't it though? At least if it's intentional.
- xyzelement 6y ago>> Isn't it though? At least if it's intentional. I suspect what the grandparent refers to is people who are offended at hearing "no." Example - someone asks to get in front of you at a line. If you're feeling kind, you say yes. Saying "no" is just neutral, but many people perceive it as a "fuck you."
- enriquto 6y ago> Isn't it though? At least if it's intentional. No, it isn't. You can be unkind and peaceful. Civilization is based on the possibility that people who hate each other can still work together for the common good. Intentional kindness is often disgustingly hypocritical, at least in my (non-U.S.) culture.
- bitexploder 6y agoI tend to be very direct day to day. I think kindness doesn’t have to be in personal interactions, especially in a business context. I’m perfectly polite, but also very honest. I still use empathy to understand where people are coming from. You have to learn to give unconditionally without becoming a doormat. It’s tricky. I think you have to be purposeful with how you give to others. I also help people out and do my best to be kind in my private life (charity, supporting local food banks, etc). I think you can generalize this kindness is healthy thing way to far. For me the reward is helping people and making their lives better. In a business context I think your examples are very different from the more intrinsically rewarding giving and kindness.
- chefandy 6y ago>I think kindness doesn’t have to be in personal interactions, especially in a business context. I’m perfectly polite, but also very honest. To be frank, I find the ratio of people who actually do that to people who think they do that but are really using it as an excuse for not exercising their interpersonal skills is 1:1000. I've known many people that called themselves brutally honest, but with the exception of one particular manager I can recall, it always ended up being an excuse to feel powerful by shocking people with a brazen lack of tact while the truth of the statement, even if occasionally beneficial, was incidental. Who knows... maybe you're the 1 out of the 1000. The tone of what you wrote sounds more reasonable than what many others have expressed in that vein, so I'm inclined to think so, but it'a hard to tell without having universally accepted bounds to words like kindness, politeness, and honesty. That said, doing good deeds and not directly insulting people we deal with doesn't absolve us from a the basic social necessity to treat other people with compassion and humanity. For that reason, whenever I encounter anyone that touts their honesty at the expense of kindness, I generally consider it a tacit admission that they have some serious work to do on their interpersonal skills and don't realize it.
- bitexploder 6y agoI have been managing people for many years now. It’s a hard balance, but I always start from a place of empathy. I find it easy to be empathetic first and then lay out then business/situational needs. We don’t do brutal honesty, just gentle honesty. When people are brutally honest they just use it as cover for being an asshole. I am probably not being clear about what I think about kindness, it’s a subtle point. Even kindness overdone can be patronizing.
- swat535 6y agoYou can be kind and not be a doormat. This takes practice and experience but the gist of it here is that you have establish and understand boundaries. Kindness is giving someone a helping hand when they need it, but not going overboard and letting them take advantage of you over and over again. In my experience, the less you let vampires suck out your energy, the more you'll be able to give to people and the way to that is by saying No and hearing No. I personally start by being kind and then await kindness back. If they reciprocate, great. If not, I politely decline their next request and change my response if they change theirs. Great relationships are formed when there is a mutual exchange of happiness and ideas else it's basically one party taking advantage which is unhealthy.
- galeaspablo 6y agoThis resonates. Executed correctly, kindness is not mutually exclusive from assertiveness. E.g. It is possible to make a complaint at a restaurant in a factual way and with a smile. E.g.2. Giving hard feedback with a smile, and constructively. It comes down to empathy, and the basic rule of treating others as we wish to be treated.
- CPLX 6y agoI’d go a step further. Not only are they not exclusive they are not really on the same axis at all. They’re just different concepts. The primary thing they have in common is they are considered opposites by people that have neither.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gumby 6y agoI have lived in NY, and my partner was born and grew up in NY, and I find New Yorkers pretty friendly, especially when compared to other cities around the world I've lived in (all of which have had their share of friendly folk). I think you have to be friendly to live cheek by jowl with so many. However New Yorkers are brisk. The tech industry has definitely become more aggressive over the last 20 years. I credit it to the people who decided they should join it because there is a lot of money to be made, when before it was mostly people who liked technology. And for that latter point: I consider an aggressive attitude a sign of fear (perhaps a consequence of a kind of imposter syndrome?). Generally I pity the mean people.
- claudeganon 6y agoMy experience in New York and Los Angeles is that the natives are perfectly pleasant, so long as you’re aware of the local mores. The worst people are the people who move to cities and try and fit in by adopting some caricature of these customs, which is often accompanied by engaging in hideous games of one-upsmanship with their fellow new arrivals.
- papito 6y agoI mean, in NYC, don't walk slowly in the middle of a sidewalk, hold doors for people, don't blast TV and music at home, and don't walk on the floor like an elephant with heels first. That's all I got.
- mmsimanga 6y agoNYC is the only ever place I have visited in the US. Perhaps everyone could see I was a tourist. I was impressed with how polite the people where. Was really impressed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gscott 6y agoBeing kind you have to be firm. Giving someone $20 for a particular purpose is kind, but the person is going to come back over and over so the next kind thing to do is decline to give more without their putting in effort to change their situation.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> New York, which has a basic culture of "hyper aggressiveness." We also volunteer in droves [1]. [1] https://gallery.mailchimp.com/e3163e2ee79e21b79cf36982c/files/672fc2b9-f410-4bdc-ae22-ad2c2ad536ef/NYC_Service_Volunteers_Count_2018_compressed.pdf https://gallery.mailchimp.com/e3163e2ee79e21b79cf36982c/file...
- TuringNYC 6y agoAs a native NYer I find this comment odd. In the US we have places around the country with Stand Your Ground laws — and locals wanting to exercise that right for the slightest slight, with devastating consequence. And we’re worried about someone being rude/aggressive on a NY street? We have to put all this in perspective. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand-your-ground_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand-your-ground_law
- xyzelement 6y agoYour last paragraph is key - once you establish boundaries for yourself, you're free to be generous and kind because you are clear with yourself on what's Ok and what's abusive. Once you have that, the other factors (industry, city) don't matter - you are able to act the way you want independently of how people are, because you're confident that you won't let their transgressions cross over into "you." It's been a long process learning this for myself as well.
- vecinu 6y ago> I live in New York, which has a basic culture of "hyper aggressiveness." It isn't "rudeness," as so many people like to think of New Yorkers. They can be aggressively kind and generous. They are just aggressive. This part made me think of this video on the NY subway that exemplifies exactly what you're talking about: https://youtu.be/yVzAC7mLxJw https://youtu.be/yVzAC7mLxJw This guy is doing something extremely kind for this lady that it brings her to tears and yet the way he does it almost seems aggressive and demanding but it's such a nice act!
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoThis argument sounds true, but I like to think of myself as being occasionally kind, or helpful, or benevolent.. whatever. And yet I just can't come up with a single example of something like that. In fact I don't believe I even think of myself in categories such as "weak" or "strong". I know I'm extremely averse to conflict, which, I guess, would be considered "weak". I'll let you have your way (within reason), but then that's the last time you'll see me, which is probably not the outcome someone trying to exploit you is hoping for.
- whiddershins 6y agoAs a native New Yorker I resemble that remark :-) I will say the opposite can also be frustrating. People conflate niceness with kindness or even worse, morality. Being gruff isn’t intrinsically immoral. Being super “nice” isn’t intrinsically moral. This might sound like some sort of rationalization for bad behavior, but I don’t think so. When you optimize you have to have at minimum a hierarchy of optimization goals. At some point, one goal WILL conflict with another. This means that conflating niceness with morality will inevitably lead to misguided and immoral/unethical behavior.
- testxyz 6y agoTesting please ignore
- Taylor_OD 6y agoI don't know. Leave New York. I chose to move to Chicago rather than New York after college because 1. cost of living 2. people. The midwest is nice. New York city folks are not. I've worked at two companies where I managed or worked heavily with our New York office and hated it both times. I realize not every New Yorker is an asshole and not everyone can leave the city on a whim but if its good for your health its worth considering.
- Bakary 6y agoTo be more specific they evaluated your courtesy as a sign of lower status from their perspective (whether consciously or not) and got angry because you did not in fact react as someone of lower status
- mmsimanga 6y ago> They get very, very upset. Far more upset than if I had just disabused them early on. I have experienced this a few times in relationships. Was brought up to always be courteous and kind. In our society those are the most admired qualities of a person. In the big world where people didn't grow up the same way I did I felt this is often misinterpreted for weakness. Trouble always starts when I "suddenly" do not budge from a position I believe in. An example is I do not believe in splashing my life on social media. We were also brought up to be kind to visitors. Go out of your way to make them feel at home. We joke now as adults how the only time we had Coca-cola in the house was when we had visitors. The idea is a visitor shouldn't stay too long so it is best to be kind to them. The problem starts when visitors overstay and continue to expect the same treatment. Or they visit to often.