4 ms·
>There’s nothing “forced” about the software update Facebook is talking about either, which, I think, is going to be iOS 14.4. It’s actually quite interesting t
by coldtea 6y ago
>There’s nothing “forced” about the software update Facebook is talking about either, which, I think, is going to be iOS 14.4. It’s actually quite interesting that Apple does not force software updates, or perform them in a hard-to-disable-or-detect manner
This part is bogus, and Gruber knows it. The update might not be "forced" in its installation, but it's forced in many other ways (Apple stops signing old versions, quickly moves on, new phones can't install it, you can't revert back, etc).
Forced updates are neither good nor bad in themselves, for me. For one, they help move the platform forward faster, bring everyone to the same page, and serve to land new features which is good (as a counter-example, remember how long Windows XP or IE6 took to die, with tons of security and compatibility issues dragging the platform behind?).
On the other hand, they can potentially break features someone depends on, or introduce new bugs.
Same at OS X. Sure, you can stay 2-3 releases behind. But often those releases are not supported on new devices, they stop getting updates fast, and new third party programs assume you have the new version and even require it. It's not like Windows, where you can stick with a 10-15 year old version and still be fine. In MacOS after 2-3 years, you're stretching it!
In any case, the forced updates are a clear tradeoff, coming from two different ideas about how an OS (move fast, be opinionated and ocassionally break things vs always-be-compatible-and-flexible).
Gruber to say iOS updates aren't forced is misingenuous.
- radley 6y ago> The update might not be "forced" in its installation It's forced passive-aggressively. Update notifications are sent daily, sometimes 2-3x in a day. There's no opt-out or blocking the system notification. Users can only defer and the defer options change each time.
- coldtea 6y ago>It's forced passive-aggressively. Update notifications are sent daily, sometimes 2-3x in a day. There's no opt-out or blocking the system notification. You can however set the system to manual update, and you wont see any notification.
- radley 6y agoThat's not true. I've tried every setting (opt-out, manual, automatic) on every device and Apple essentially does it the same way regardless: repeated notifications to manually update. Opt-out works the same as manual. The only difference between manual & auto is that auto will pre-download OS installers, but you still have to manually run the update.
- joshstrange 6y agoThis is the one part of the blog post where I cringed. I like Gruber, read DF, and listen to his podcast but this is in the "technically true" camp at best and he knows better. Yes, you aren't forced to update but you get notifications, auto-updates at night if you haven't disabled them, and you can't rollback. I understand all of the decisions that Apple has made and even agree with them on the whole but to pretend Apple doesn't try and force you at every turn to upgrade in a 1-way process is just disingenuous.