5 ms·
IMF would use your search history for credit scores
- grawprog 6y ago>Citing soft-data points like “the type of browser and hardware used to access the internet, the history of online searches and purchases” that could be incorporated into evaluating a borrower, the researchers believe that when a lender has a more intimate relationship with the potential client’s history, they might be more willing to cut them some slack. So this https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2014/11/03/if-you-use-a-mac-or-an-android-e-commerce-sites-may-be-charging-you-more/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2014/11/03/... https://www.techlicious.com/blog/price-discrimination-by-operating-system-device/ https://www.techlicious.com/blog/price-discrimination-by-ope... But for your entire credit history? Sounds pretty awful to me.
- thedrbrian 6y agoSounds like social credit.
- grawprog 6y agoI don't think social credit is enough to describe what this and other proposals like this are. It doesn't go far enough. This isn't social credit. It's life credit or maybe existence credit. You're gaining or losing credit from merely the way you exist or live. It's essentially a hidden tax on life itself and everything you do. Every thought, belief, action, piece of information you read, media you consume, basically every single thing you do will have some kind of value placed on it. In my opinion, this goes far beyond social credit.
- bassman9000 6y agoSocial credit is life credit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Credit_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Credit_System
- kaneua 6y ago> researchers believe that when a lender has a more intimate relationship with the potential client’s history, they might be more willing to cut them some slack Is it a comedy writing? Lender can't have "a more intimate relationship" with anything because today it's a computer. Automated sociopath.
- cxf12 6y agoThey said search was free. It could cost you dearly.
- ssivark 6y agoMost people who claim that they don’t care about protecting their data or how it’s used don’t realize that a 0.1% increase in their interest rate on a big expense (say a home loan) probably works out far more expensive than all the nickels and dimes they might save otherwise, including by using “free” services on the web.
- novok 6y agoA %0.1 interest rate increase is like $40/month if you live somewhere expensive. Could you reproduce all of the free services for $40/month or less? I'm not so sure.
- ssivark 6y agoIf you ask people if they would pay $40/mo for the assortment of social media etc web services they use to completely avoid usage tracking, they’d probably typically refuse.
- xiphias2 6y agoGreat. Just one more reason to get off the current financial system.
- wsc981 6y ago> Great. Just one more reason to get off the current financial system. Be careful what you wish for. The replacement might be worse. Seems we're moving towards a system with Central Bank Digital Currencies in which people own accounts at central banks and governments can use policy on an individuals' central bank account to incentive people to do the "right" thing.
- xiphias2 6y agoI’m using Bitcoin for many years now, and while it has its own problems (like sometimes waiting for an hour so that I can do a hotel reservation), I’m quite happy with it so far
- yowlingcat 6y agoThis sounds like one step closer to social credit. It feels like an arms race -- to the bottom.
- Throwaway1771 6y agoWe are the cannon fodder.
- bo1024 6y agoThis could be a good response to the "I have nothing to hide" arguments.
- ballenf 6y agoFor this to work, it would have to become illegal to use VPNs or even do anything on internet logged out. Also probably need to eliminate the address bar from the browser -- you can only get to sites from a search. Actually it wouldn't be illegal to have privacy, it would just become so expensive only the very wealthy could afford it. So the internet would mirror the real world ever more. Maybe I'm overly paranoid, but it really does feel like the powerful are chipping away at every aspect of the internet and its empowering of the common person.
- Throwaway1771 6y ago"I have nothing to hide."
- rolph 6y agoHence the irony of the throwaway.
- Throwaway1771 6y agoI'm paraphrasing the average user - not my statement.
- rolph 6y agoi guessed that, but it is comedic irony from my perspective. no intention to gouge you, just having a saturday. cheers man.
- sneak 6y ago> Maybe I'm overly paranoid, but it really does feel like the powerful are chipping away at every aspect of the internet and its empowering of the common person. It's not just you; that definitely seems to be the trend. Already, privacy is only really available for the wealthy or technical.
- beagle3 6y ago
- motohagiography 6y agoWhile this idea is obviously an outrage and an abomination, it's the result of another economic factor. Modern creditors take very little actual risk, and that asymmetry of risk creates a power dynamic that is itself a kind of tyranny by a protected class. Creditors can organize, conspire, conduct surveillance, slander, and do pretty much anything a state can do, and that's a set of perverse incentives. Unsecured debt is servitude, and so is debt without an expiry. Some people may be fine with it, but very few who understand it are. Creditors' low risk manifests as low interest rates, which everyone loves until they create bubbles and other forms of hyperinflation, which burst, and the costs are socialized. The IMF was a pernicious organization from its very beginnings, basically using "cheap" subsidized debt from central banks to subordinate developing economies to a neoliberal order and force social policies that enabled globalized businesses (resource extraction and financialization) to in-effect loot them. This used to be a major progressive cause, and one that I supported, but it too seems to have been co-opted by the same interests. Now anti-globalization is abandoned by progressives, who used the activism as a stepping stone into institutional power, where now it's no longer necessary to have the popular support of maker and builder classes. Trade tariffs and economic borders have been banished to the backwater of right-wing populist causes, where people still believe in unfashionable things like nations and the responsibility of government to secure a perimeter for growth. This IMF scheme would seem like a troll, but it's not. The people behind it have an institutional contempt for anyone outside their power games, and to them we're basically livestock. The difference between the 1990's and 2020's is that leftist led populist revolts against this exact kind of IMF driven policy were largely performative, critical, and non-violent because they were carried out by feckless flower children, whereas in the 2020's, I'd predict they will be carried out by men with little left to lose. If that sounds scary, it should. These IMF people just don't get it.
- alexbiet 6y agoGet ready for CBDC wallets linked to your web history. Things like this justify the existence of an alternative financial system based around Bitcoin and related digital assets.
- reaperducer 6y agoThings like this justify me moving increasingly to cash.
- hosteur 6y agoEveryday, using cash is becoming increasingly difficult.
- reaperducer 6y agoIt's still easier than Bitcoin. It will only go away if people stop using it.
- H8crilA 6y agoRemember that when it comes to personal credit scores (or even pricing of corporate debt) the IMF is no more important than, say, the Harvard econ department. They have no authority over such matters. It's just research. Pricing of sovereign debt, particularly of more "problematic" countries, yeah - that's their purpose/business.
- WaitWaitWha 6y ago>They have no authority over such matters. It's just research. You are right. They do not, directly. But, never underestimate bureaucrats hunger for control. This "just research", if it can be used as a cudgel, it will. The IMF dictates many many things through its financial tentacles that impacts individuals to the extreme. Just look talk to some who are from countries where IMF came and helped out.
- vegetablepotpie 6y agoYes, and it gives us a view into the headspace of the people in the finance industry. It’s true, these researchers don’t have direct power, but they do have influence. And that can be dangerous too. This quote from the article is very illustrative: > institutional banking system is facing a serious threat from tech companies like Google, Facebook, and Apple. The researchers identify two key areas in which this is true: Tech companies have greater access to soft-information, and messaging platforms can take the place of the physical locations that banks rely on for meeting with customers This tells me that there are people in the finance industry that think that they are the underdog. They just want the same access to information big tech companies already have so that they could cut the little guy a better deal. If only governments and regulators could see that. Wouldn’t we live in a better world? They don’t think that this could usher in a financial version of 1984 because they’re optimistic in the same way that Mark Zuckerberg was optimistic that making a social networking site to connect people together would be utopian. These researchers are going to impart this idea on students and their colleagues, eventually someone is going to go into government with complete faith that giving financial institutions very fine grained information on citizens is in everyone’s best interests. That is what is dangerous about this.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cblconfederate 6y agoI just need to watch financially responsible porn
- rajandatta 6y agoI work in Banking and have worked in Banks and for them for the last 15 years. This is a terrible idea. It will be deeply exacerbate systemic structural exclusion of those that do not make up the ideal picture of an institution.
- heelix 6y agoWere one combining browser history, visa transactions, GPS location data from your car/phone, and who you interacted with via social networking/phone/email, one could probably create a very powerful personal profile. Be nice to keep the commercial entities from having that much end to end data for as long as we can.
- tus88 6y agoWhen tin-hatters complain about "globalists" this is what they are talking about.
- godmode2019 6y agoWho are the programmers building these control structures, it has it be people like us. Maybe people like us who have lost hope. Programmers will be the first luddites.
- bostik 6y agoNot "will be". "Are". We understand what's likely going on under the hood and want none of it. https://twitter.com/ppathole/status/1116670170980859905 https://twitter.com/ppathole/status/1116670170980859905
- allworknoplay 6y agoAnd yet truly awful organizations have no trouble hiring programmers! Far too many of us are obsessed with puzzles and paychecks and couldn't give a fuck about the ethics of something like this.
- amsvie 6y agoThis may be feasible in Tim Berner-Lee’s vision of Solid and data pods. I’d only do it if I control access to data, and can allow an auditable one-time no-copy access to get 0.X% off my mortgage. But no handing over data to banks between banks / social media companies.