5 ms·
I mostly agreed with you until: > Nobody needs a somewhat smarter version of AskJeeves. That's exactly what I need. It's not right for everything, but asking
by freedomben 6y ago
I mostly agreed with you until:
> Nobody needs a somewhat smarter version of AskJeeves.
That's exactly what I need. It's not right for everything, but asking questions is the natural form of information seeking for a human. Being able to do that well is a huge value add.
- uniqueid 6y agoYes. I didn't want to be nuanced there, though, because the nuanced version is: nobody wants the kind of 'smarter AskJeeves' that technology is currently capable of producing. Had I written that, the next thing you know, someone would be calling me an idiot and informing me about the wonders of GPT3 and Tesla autopilot :)
- freedomben 6y agoHeh, good point :-) Yeah the current state of the tech is (in my opinion) just a voice command line. You have to know the right keywords to say, and in the right order, to get it to do what you want. It's largely an exercise in guess, test, and revise.
- derefr 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aardvark_(search_engine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aardvark_(search_engine) was a “better AskJeeves” — it routed around the natural-language problem by feeding your question to real people. Interestingly, it didn’t just boil down to a Quora/StackOverflow model; it wasn’t a “wisdom of crowds” thing. Instead, your question really was used as a search query — but instead of searching a pool of documents, it would search a pool of experts, matching you with an expert who knows about similar things†, then facilitating contact with them (and forwarding them your initial query/question to start off the conversation, like a Helpdesk system.) † Not sure how they did this part — for academic experts, they could “just” fulltext-index their corpus of published journal papers, to build up a “knowledge fingerprint” of the expert. Not sure what they would do for people in industry without a stream of publications, though. Sadly, Google bought them, shut down the Aardvark product, and probably just put the engineers on regular SRE code-slinging tasks. It almost seems like Google felt threatened. And — hint hint — nothing’s stopping anyone from building something like this again :)