3 ms·
The real criticism, as it were, is in the final paragraphs where the author points to the usual study of psychotherapies which found small advantages for CBT. (
by gwern 16y ago
The real criticism, as it were, is in the final paragraphs where the author points to the usual study of psychotherapies which found small advantages for CBT. (I couldn't help but sarcastically think, 'and is 8% more effectiveness not worthwhile?')
- gnosis 16y agoRead that again. It didn't find an 8% advantage for CBT. Here's the sentence that mentions 8%: "Dr. Wampold found that the methods and techniques unique to a given therapy account for only a modest portion (roughly 8 percent) of the overall treatment effects." Note that he's talking about "a given therapy", not CBT in particular. Also, it's not clear from the summary whether 8% was within the margin of error or not. And what kind of "effectiveness" are they measuring? Has the "effectiveness" been shown over the long-term or just the short-term? How large were the studies? Etc...