7 ms·
> where did they think the money would come from? There’s a growing misconception that everything can be paid for by simply taxing the wealthy a tiny bit more.
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
> where did they think the money would come from?
There’s a growing misconception that everything can be paid for by simply taxing the wealthy a tiny bit more. Several prominent activist politicians have built their platforms on the idea that billionaires are an infinite source of consequence-free tax revenue.
These ideas are especially popular among the college students and new college grads I mentor. It usually falls apart when they pull out their calculators and realize that Jeff Bezos entire net worth wouldn’t come close to paying off everyone’s student loan debt or solving climate change.
Meanwhile, completely false Tweets about how Jeff Bezos is about to become a trillionaire or how he could simply solve the entire student loan crisis himself gain 100,000s of likes, some of them from prominent politicians or their campaign managers. People don’t care about the facts right now.
Frankly, many people don’t really care if this solves anything or if second-order consequences result in a net decrease in tax revenue due to people simply moving (as is the case with some wealth taxes in other countries). For many, this is more about punishing their bad guys than generating tax revenue to accomplish something.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThe most important point of taxing the top ~1% is to simply bring their wealth more in line with their contributions, and to reduce their outsized power on the political system. Jeff Bezos isn't "worth" a million times more than his warehouse workers, and he shouldn't have that kind of money either as a matter of principle, or as a matter of democratic power. It's not a matter of punishment, but a matter of ensuring a more just/meritocratic and free society. The fact that the state can also use some of this money to help with the funding of social programs is a secondary benefit.
- emteycz 6y agoHe as a human is worth exactly the same as the workers, of course. But that changes nothing about his right to the wealth he created. The others could create their own wealth, Bezos wasn't in a privileged position when he started. If his money gives him political power, the solution is to fix the political system, not steal his money.
- fattire 6y ago"wealth he created"
- emteycz 6y agoExactly. How else would it get to his bank account? If he didn't create it, why people sent it to him? He stole it?
- Pfhreak 6y agoProfits are just unpaid wages. He bought labor for less than it was worth and pocketed the excess.
- emteycz 6y agoThat means the workers will have absolutely no problem founding their own business and there is no need to tax Bezos.
- jamiltron 6y agoThat's not what that means at all. Founding a business requires a significant investment of capital.
- emteycz 6y agoIt doesn't necessarily require the founder investing large amounts, Bezos began with a small investment - and a lot of ingenuity. My own business began this year with $0 and I'm way past $100k. I had to live in my car for two months, absolutely worth it though, it helped me focus like never before. I created excellent product and then spent a lot of time both online and offline finding customers. And now imagine you do this, and after all the shit you went through people start saying you don't deserve your money, completely ignoring the huge risk you made and the opportunity cost behind you, and that YOU MADE THE THING. What would you think?
- OminousWeapons 6y agoI think it's worth asking why compensation is the way it is. If we assume that people's compensation is based on the value they generate for an organization, then what you are asking is basically "can a million warehouse workers together in a collective be as effective as Jeff Bezos at producing value for Amazon?" Alternatively, you could ask "can a given warehouse worker given one million times his current compensation add as much value to Amazon as Jeff Bezos can?" It's quite possible that the answer to both of those questions is no, and if Jeff Bezos is generating a million times more value than the average warehouse worker for Amazon with his decision making and actions then it is not an issue that he is being paid a million times more than a warehouse worker. I'm not saying that what warehouse workers are being paid now is "fair" or "reasonable", but I do think that trying to establish some fixed ratio between what a warehouse worker makes and what Jeff Bezos makes is sort of a silly exercise. Additionally, if you think that comp shouldn't reflect value added to an organization, then I would be interested in hearing what you think it should be based on.
- rorykoehler 6y agoThis is a false equivalence with the argument GP made. It’s not healthy for society to have Bezos level wealth in one person. It will never be no matter the political system in place.
- whatthesmack 6y agoIt isn't a false equivalence, though. From the original comment: > taxing the top ~1% is to simply bring their wealth more in line with their contributions The comment above yours is just pointing out that Bezos may contribute more, which would be an explanation for Bezos' outsize wealth. Whether it's true or not that Bezos contributes more is subjective, of course. > It’s not healthy for society to have Bezos level wealth in one person. That's an entirely different point unrelated to the "contribution" question/attribute.
- purple_ferret 6y agoJeff Bezos's net worth is almost entirely in Amazon's stock value. He isn't being compensated by some objective analysis of his worth. Amazon, the company, might be, at which point, he's benefiting as the largest shareholder.
- Privacy846 6y agoThe concept of meritocracy was born as satire, is currently a farce, and will likely never be realized as a genuine phenomenom.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoJeff Bezos is worth more than his warehouse workers because he creates jobs for the workers to survive. if the warehouse workers were worth the same, they would have come up with AMZN. that amazon doesnt give out as much dividends and ploughs back all the profits to create new companies and new jobs shows that jeff bezos is more socialist than any self declared socialist. its going to back as wages! and benefits of society are for everyone. if this isnt more than fair, i dont know what is...if the wealth redistribution people ever lived in any other country other than california(i wouldnt include the rest of the usa), they would realise how socially responsible and beneficial ca's billionaires have been to california by contributing to not just california but to the rest of the world. if anyone is 45 or above, they'd know how it was in the 80s and early 90s. if anyone has lived anywhere else and shelled out double digit VAT, they'd know that the europeon mixed economies and social welfare states place a higher tax burden on the middle class for far lesser quality of life materially than in california. i wish i can air drop the proponents of 'eat the rich' into any one of the dozen countries..not even third world countries..for about 3 months. they'd realise how good we have it here in CA. or rather..how good we have had it...all that is going to go. it's ironic that the same people crying for blood and redistribution are the ones fleeing to tax free or low tax states. thanks for nothing.
- tsimionescu 6y agoYou're describing the failed dream of trickle down economics or Ayn Rands objectivism fever dream. Jeff Bezos' money is not working out for anyone else as much as it is for Jeff Bezos. 40-60 years ago, people could support a family off a single factory worker salary. Now, a good 10 or 20 percent of Jeff Bezos's employees can't even support themselves and need food stamps to live. Global warming is making the entire world go to shit faster and faster. And you think people are better off? Not to mention, at the rate people's productivity has gone up, we should probably be working 3 or 4 day weeks at most, or earning almost double our wages. Instead, all of this extra productivity has been pocketed by Jeff Bezos and his ilk. > Jeff Bezos is worth more than his warehouse workers because he creates jobs for the workers to survive. if the warehouse workers were worth the same, they would have come up with AMZN. First of all, I didn't say he wasn't worth more to the company than 1 warehouse worker - of course he is. Is he worth more than all the warehouse and IT and sales workers combined? No. And please don't attribute to personal worth what is mostly a product of good luck - the fact that Jeff Bezos's move from books to everything else happened to be wildly successful doesn't mean it was a guaranteed success or that no one else could have done it. And after it started snowballing, pretty much anyone could have run Amazon and it would have still become a big success - especially anyone who doesn't care about the welfare of their workers, willing to cut corners, willing to extract massive subsidies from the state more or less directly (food stamps, the Amazon HQ bidding), willing to use their position and information to destroy their competitors, and so on. If Amazon didn't exist, it would have been replaced by a thousand other smaller enterprises that would have hired more people. Centralization and concentration of wealth and power are always a net negative for everyone who isn't very near the top of that concentration.
- dennisgorelik 6y ago> reduce their outsized power on the political system Why do you want to take away decision-making power from people who know how to make [a lot of] money?
- tsimionescu 6y agoBecause they use that power to make a lot of money for themselves and their friends, at the expense of everyone and everything else. They also often have strange ideas about what's good for people, especially when they start viewing them just through the lens of money - that's how you got slavery, eugenics, debtors prison, forced sterilization, and others.
- Enginerrrd 6y agoWhile I agree with you that the idea there is fundamentally flawed, it does seem like the greatest increases in GDP and growth have occurred when the pareto distribution of wealth was the least skewed in favor of the wealthy. To an extent, this makes sense to me from a free market perspective... The less concentrated the wealth and power is, the more we can expect competition and innovation. So even though their reasoning may be flawed, its possible the result would make sense anyway.
- tsimionescu 6y agoBut that is exactly their reasoning - not some fantasy of balancing the budget by taxing the rich, but a rationally supported (in history and economic theory) belief that reducing the wealth gap increases economic productivity. Wealth taxes (if they can be enforced, which is a significant problem) are especially powerful in this area, as they reduce the incentive for rent seeking behavior - it stops people from simply sitting on their accumulated wealth, at least when it's producing less than the taxed amount for them.
- amscanne 6y agoNo billionaire is just sitting on their money. It’s certainly tied up in assets or being actively managed. I don’t see in what universe a wealth tax could be effective, given that people can simply move. Wouldn’t it just cause large-scale capital flight, as it did in France?
- tsimionescu 6y ago> No billionaire is just sitting on their money. It’s certainly tied up in assets or being actively managed. Not literally sitting on them, but they are certainly not spending anywhere near as much of their money as someone who makes ~1M$ a year. A large part of their wealth is usually tied up in long term investments such as property or bonds, where it is safe but not productive. And as I said, enforcement is a real problem, capital flight being a possible consequence. I don't know exactly what the solution is, but surely there is some better balance to be struck than today. Especially if the US government wanted to - they have enough financial and diplomatic power to enforce this type of tax almost world wide, even if California or France don't.
- bbddg 6y agoJeff Bezos is just one person. Do you really think the US can't afford to cancel everyone's student debt?
- ericd 6y agoDo you think we should? Is it fair to everyone who didn’t go to college because it was too expensive?
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoI hate the idea of cancelling student loan debt. Why should people who chose to take on massive debt to go to private colleges get debt relief? Many many people made sensible decisions to go to lower cost schools, in-state schools or community colleges to avoid debt. Then there are people who chose to avoid college altogether to avoid debt. Some people religiously are forbidden from taking on debt and they oblige that by avoiding expensive schooling. And forgiving student debt is a punch in the face to all those people. If we forgive student loan debt we HAVE TO give the same amount to people who were prudent enough to avoid that debt in the first place or else it's all a sham.
- Can_Not 6y agoThere is a runaway trolley barrelling down the railway tracks. There are people tied to tracks as far as you can see. You can pull the lever at any time to stop the trolley from killing people, but that would not be fair to everyone who has already been ran over by the trolley. Which is the right thing to do?
- ericd 6y agoThat's not an apt metaphor. I wasn't talking about it being unfair to those who paid off their debt already/got "killed by the trolley", but those who didn't go to college because it was too expensive, or lived at home, went to community college for two years, and then transferred to a state school so that they didn't have to take on debt. Now their tax dollars would go to help pay off the debts of everyone who went to expensive private colleges, many of whom come from much wealthier families. Rather than forgiveness, we should make the debt dischargeable via bankruptcy. It should've never been made non-dischargeable (though it did help reduce interest rates, and enable more people to get them, that also upped the amount schools could charge, and made it so loan officers didn't have to consider the creditworthiness of the applicant, and their plan for repayment). It should be something that passes a need bar before essentially foisting the cost on society, and bankruptcy is a mechanism for doing exactly that. Use the money toward making public universities free, and expand the public university system, as well as trade schools. That’s really how you save all those future people tied to those tracks.
- amscanne 6y agoExactly. The US has one of the most progressive tax systems in the world. It hasn’t magically solved the wealth gap. Many people just want to punish the ultra wealthy, but it also won’t help. If it’s actually about raising revenue, you will need to actually look lower, to the top 10% and broader middle class. But this isn’t nearly as compelling as a populist message to fund the various proposed unicorns...
- tangjurine 6y agoReally? The average income of someone in the top 1 percent is around 1 million, and the average income of the average person in the US is around 50k. So the top 1 percent have 20 percent of the income, so a 10 percent tax increase on the top 1 percent corresponds to a total increase of 2 percent, which isn't a small amount.
- rufus_foreman 6y agoAm I reading this right, you think that if you increase the tax rate on high income people by 10%, you will get 10% more taxes from them?
- amscanne 6y agoTaxes select for income brackets, not people. Consider your example: 1mm is an average. You need about 300k/yr to be in the top 1%. So you make it a marginal tax on income above 300k? To actually collect 10% more taxes from that group, you would need strictly more than a 10% marginal tax. In practice, your marginal rate is probably 20-30%, since you would barely collect from the first ~0.5% (too close to 300k). If you have a marginal increase of 30%, you’re going to start to see significant changes in behavior, since dollars above 300k would be taxed at ~65%. (Since we’re talking about people taking in > 1mm/yr, that probably just means more retained earnings.) The top 1% is already likely paying the full federal marginal rate on their income (or AMT at least), so even if you tried to take every last cent above 300k/yr you probably wouldn’t be able to increase revenue by more than 10%. (But this is a hypothetical only, as such a move would obviously result in less revenue than today, since no one would bother earning the dollars that are taxed at ~35% right now.) So yeah, maybe you could squeeze all those people for a few % more revenue, but there’s not a ton more juice than that, and I’m skeptical that it would even work at all. But “taxing the 1%” is certainly not a game changer the way it’s spun.
- purple_ferret 6y agoElizabeth Warren's wealth tax plan claims it will be bring in 3.75 trillion over 10 years.[1]: >That’s why we need a tax on wealth. The Ultra-Millionaire Tax taxes the wealth of the richest Americans. It applies only to households with a net worth of $50 million or more—roughly the wealthiest 75,000 households, or the top 0.1%. Households would pay an annual 2% tax on every dollar of net worth above $50 million and a 6% tax on every dollar of net worth above $1 billion. Because wealth is so concentrated, this small tax on roughly 75,000 households will bring in $3.75 trillion in revenue over a ten-year period. Are you saying this is wrong if I 'pull out my calculator' and run the numbers? The reality is it is not. Wealth is massively concentrated at the top in this country, and from a purely numbers perspective, if it were 'redistributed' it could cover a lot of basic costs that occur in this country. [1]https://elizabethwarren.com/plans/ultra-millionaire-tax https://elizabethwarren.com/plans/ultra-millionaire-tax
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoWealth is not money.
- throwaway894345 6y agoMy favorite was when MSNBC cited a Tweet claiming that Mike Bloomberg could write every American a check for $1,000,000 and still have money left over. I actually think our country can afford to tax the rich more than we have done, but there are a lot of people who reach the same conclusion by utterly farcical reasoning. Relatedly, there are a lot of people who rail against capitalism for making us slaves as though there is an alternate system that doesn’t impoverish and ultimately kill billions.
- legulere 6y agoThe US currently taxes the rich extremely low when compared to other countries or the US in the good old times. All this was rationalized with trickle down economics which have turned out to be utter nonsense. The wealth of those unfathomable rich was built on top of the society they live in and are part of. The acquired wealth is so beyond comprehension that the idea that any one person could have such a big positive impact alone to justify it is just absurd.
- door99 6y ago> For many, this is more about punishing their bad guys than generating tax revenue to accomplish something. That’s basically the point of wealth taxes, explicitly. Advocates of a stronger wealth task believe billionaires should not exist on principle, that centralization of wealth and power is wrong it itself. And they’re right.
- csomar 6y agoThis is the problem with representative democracy when the average IQ is below 80. Candidates do this because it sells, and they are running like business except they get paid in votes instead of dollars. When they are in office, they try to string along as long as they can. Like this bill will probably not pass, but some damage could be done and the next time they have to give more ridiculous promises.