4 ms·
Wrong, Americans aren't dumb enough to buy houses until prices drop to pre-bubble prices. Prices are still kinda crazy and unjustified compared to 2005. Also,
by ck2 16y ago
Wrong, Americans aren't dumb enough to buy houses until prices drop to pre-bubble prices.
Prices are still kinda crazy and unjustified compared to 2005.
Also, the average person can probably not get credit anymore and the wealthy desire only so many 2nd homes.
- _delirium 16y agoYeah, I think the credit issue is a big part of it. Whether it's a good idea or not, if it were as easy to get a mortgage today as it was in 2005, I'm pretty sure a lot of Americans would be getting huge mortgages. So it may be overstating the case a bit to claim that Americans have in aggregate made a rational decision not to buy houses--- versus simply not being able to buy houses anymore due to a change in the banking situation.
- pstack 16y agoI posted this in my own comment, but I agree that a lot of people won't buy homes until they drop even more. Unfortunately, I don't know how much more they're going to drop. There is a lot of artificially maintaining the value of homes, because politicians want to keep the voting block happy (people in debt with a family). I bought my home, because rates dropped below 5% and I had a chunk of money on hand, found a home I really liked, and was kind of sick at the thought that I'd just handed over almost $200k in just over ten years by renting apartments. I make a solid income and owning a home isn't a trivial expense to me, so I can't imagine someone making a go at it if they have a family and an income that is half or a third. Prices should drop to whatever their natural un-aided point would be, so that all those people out there who will either never own a home or only do so by getting into unfathomable debt (all over again) will actually be able to own a piece. Imagine what the long term benefit to the economy would be if prices dropped just long enough for tens of millions of people to lock in rates on their own home? It would transform the economy as well as, perhaps, society. Owning a home would be the rule, instead of exception. Being in debt to own a home would be an exception. High rent would be an exception. There would be much more discretionary income to put back into other industries. Or, better, for people to stick into their savings so that they can retire with a home to live in and finances to support themselves.
- chopsueyar 16y agoAt the end of the day, the majority of these homes being financed are obsolete in terms of energy-efficiency. Energy costs will be the main concern. We need to cool or warm our air, heat our water, refrigerate our food, and mechanically dry our clothing. If prices were to diminish as you speculate, the real cost of home ownership would be property taxes, utilities, and maintenance. How many of these homes built in the last 30 years will last another 30 years? What does it cost to cool a poorly insulated wood-frame 2000sqft house? What will it cost to cool in 10/20/30 years?
- kd0amg 16y agoEnergy costs will be the main concern. We need to cool or warm our air, heat our water, refrigerate our food, and mechanically dry our clothing. Housing around here is not particularly expensive, but the house's gas bill peaks a little over a tenth of the rent in an Upper Michigan winter, and the electric bill doesn't really get near that peak. There would have to be some pretty significant change before energy costs were that much of a concern.
- lurker19 16y agoDo you also get kind of sick when you notice that food and clothing and flowers and education and entertainment cost money also? If no, why is housing different? If yes, what do you think income should be used for?
- pstack 16y agoI don't think you understand my point. Housing should cost whatever supply and demand value it at. That means that when everything goes belly up because of stupid lending and stupid borrowing, those people should have to sell their homes at a loss and people should be able to come in and buy those now cheap (because of a new ratio of supply and demand) homes on the cheap. In other words, I want the natural value (free market) of things -- not some artificially inflated value, because government and committees felt obligated to bow to home-owners in saving their asses and maintaining the value of their assets. If I buy a car and then my financial situation changes, I may need to get rid of that car on the quick and someone can get a good deal out of it. Why should the government come in and rescue me by ensuring that I get a solid high value for my car, at the expense of another person who could have benefited from circumstances that otherwise would have made the car affordable to them? I know we don't tend to have a truly free market much of anywhere, but it seems particularly shitty to artificially maintain a high value in housing at the expense of a huge chunk of society that can't afford ridiculous (artificially so) housing prices.
- mikeryan 16y agoOne data point, we just bought our house (Berkeley CA) in January for the exact same price the previous owners purchased it on 2003. My sister closed 5 days ago on a house in a very desirable part of Mountain View CA. Through their process they had houses with up to 25 bids. I'm seeing (anecdotally, in the SF Bay Area) a lot of people buying right now. These are generally savvy folks too, they're putting 20%+ down getting awesome fixed rates, and staying well within their means . We may still see a slight dip in prices but my feeling is that we've bottomed out a bit here and on the way up. We think we'll be able to sell our house in 5-10 years and make a profit. That may be wishful thinking, but I'm fairly confident in that position, especially as the tech sector heats up. The tricky thing about the SF Bay Area however is its very resistent to outside pressures, it was one of the last places hit and will likely be on of the first to recover. Its very hard to time a bottom in the housing market here.
- chopsueyar 16y agoThrough their process they had houses with up to 25 bids. Can you please clarify what these means?
- pstack 16y agoI think he just means that there were 25 offers on the house.
- chopsueyar 16y agoBut he said houses plural.
- thwarted 16y agoThey were looking to buy a house and some of the houses they were looking at were in such high demand that up to 25 different people had put offers on them.
- 16y ago