3 ms·
> The assumptions that pilots would be able to react to a failure correctly within 10 seconds. I think something is very wrong if safety of any system is depen
by bayindirh 6y ago
> The assumptions that pilots would be able to react to a failure correctly within 10 seconds.
I think something is very wrong if safety of any system is dependent on reacting to any failure within 10 seconds, without any error whatsoever.
I know pilots and piloting is on the extraordinary end of the spectrum but, isn't this stretching it a bit too much?
- chippiewill 6y agoI know it's mostly fiction, but it reminds me of the "Can we get serious now?" in Sully https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1fVL4AQEW8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1fVL4AQEW8
- bayindirh 6y agoThat was a riveting 3 minute video. I'll watch this tonight.
- andi999 6y agoAgree´. I think the (german version) of the starfighter had a 2 second window for retracting the landing gear during lift-off otherwise the stall protection will crash the jet into the ground. Well there was a lot wrong with this model 296 crashed (during peace time training....)
- bayindirh 6y ago2 seconds. You can't reach for the lever/switch in two seconds. That's insane.
- andi999 6y agoI remember the value from a report on TV (who knows if it is correct). But then lift-off is not a too unexpected event, so better keep your hand close to that control.
- Xylakant 6y agoThe running joke at that time was that the fastest way to acquire a starfighter was to buy a plot of land and wait. That thing was nicknamed widowmaker for a reason.
- dm319 6y agoFrom what I understand the whole reason this happened was that Boeing wanted the new efficient engines without having to call the plane a new model. So they were really asking pilots with no training on the new Max planes to react correctly to a situation that didn't exist on the old plane within 10 seconds. Surely this is basically admitting to being at fault? Also, these airlines that bought the Max on the basis they wouldn't have to re-train the pilots are presumably having to foot the bill for this?
- lisper 6y agoPrivate pilot here. You have it exactly right. The problem is not the ten-second reaction time. There are a lot of emergencies that require that kind of reaction time (engine failure, to cite the obvious example). The problem is ten-second reaction time to a new kind of emergency without special training for that emergency.
- redis_mlc 6y agoWhat you're missing is: - Boeing promised $1 million penalty per plane to Southwest if retraining was needed - none of the planes had the right cockpit indicators, whether they were ordered as an option or not. The US pilot unions are pissed about this. - the flight manuals were not accurate. This is a big deal from a regulatory standpoint, and means the planes were never airworthy. The EU could have a field day with this. - the certification paperwork was wrong. The FAA could do basically anything it wants to Boeing at this point, including asking for criminal charges. - pilot training is an on-going expense, forever. It actually would affect Southwest's business model, which depends on commonality. - Boeing is the US' biggest exporter, so this incompetence actually affected us at a national and international level financially.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- redis_mlc 6y ago> I think something is very wrong if safety of any system is dependent on reacting to any failure within 10 seconds If you said 3 seconds when airborne, except for some engine failures, I'd agree. On takeoff and landing you're looking at under 1 second response to stay on the centerline or abort. When airlines transitioned from piston to jet engines, there were a lot of accidents. The reason was that piston engines respond to throttle input immediately, but jets took 6 seconds to spool up. So being low on landing in a jet usually meant hitting the ground before the engines increased thrust.