5 ms·
Top Retractions of 2020
- person_of_color 6y agoWhat an absolute shitshow. I fear for our future if scientists can be made to look the fool like they did this year.
- roenxi 6y agoScience is not the process of figuring out a new thing in 2 months. For January-April it was possible for a smart layman to outperform the scientists on basic "what is going on" questions - because neither had any data and everyone was guessing what the terrifying signals out of China meant based on political knowledge and quality of the rumours feeding back. Science is the process of flushing all the bad opinions out much like they are doing in this article. Now in December the scientists will be comfortably ahead of the laypeople in their understanding of the Coronavirus.
- mistermann 6y agoI think there's a subtle miscommunication going on here (and my intuition is that this is an extremely common phenomenon, and not limited to only the topic of Science). Whereas you are talking about Science, as practiced by scientists, person_of_color is talking about "Science", as it is perceived by the general public. Science vs "Science". And not to be overlooked are the layers between these two as well: the communication/information ecosystem. This may seem like a subtle, unimportant difference (or not noticed at all in normal(!), realtime cognition), but that's just an impression...perception - the actual importance is the systemic consequences in the world. We can wag our fingers all day at the idiots who "don't understand/listen to The Science", but if actual science (Science vs "Science") isn't actually communicated to the public, and also done in a manner such that it both(!) lands and sticks in these people's minds, we will then enjoy the suboptimal consequences that result. We can then (choose to) proceed to assign blame (enjoying the psychological/emotional pleasure that often comes with that) as to whose "fault" this is all we want - the current systemic consequences are what they are (however: the future consequences may be influenced by this blame assignment process). So says Science (or more precisely, would say, if we could be bothered to study such things, with the same depth and rigour that we study the hard sciences [1]). > Science is the process of flushing all the bad opinions out much like they are doing in this article. Is this article Science, or "Science", or a hybrid (in general, and also from this perspective of Systemic Consequences)? I would personally classify it as being far more towards the "Science" side of the spectrum. > Now in December the scientists will be comfortably ahead of the laypeople in their understanding of the Coronavirus. In most respects surely, but all? And again: might even seemingly completely innocuous statements like this possibly have Systemic Consequences? [1] How Much Does It Cost To Find A Higgs Boson? https://www.forbes.com/sites/alexknapp/2012/07/05/how-much-does-it-cost-to-find-a-higgs-boson/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/alexknapp/2012/07/05/how-much-d... > The Large Hadron Collider took about a decade to construct, for a total cost of about $4.75 billion. There are several different experiments going on at the LHC, including the CMS and ATLAS Detectors which discovered the Higgs boson. CERN contributes about 20% of the cost of those experiments, which is a total of about $5.5 billion a year. The remainder of the funding for those experiments is provided by international collaborations. Computing power is also a significant part of the cost of running CERN - about $286 million annually. Electricity costs alone for the LHC run about $23.5 million per year. The total operating budget of the LHC runs to about $1 billion per year. > The Large Hadron Collider was first turned on in August of 2008, then stopped for repairs in September until November 2009. Taking all of those costs into consideration, the total cost of finding the Higgs boson ran about $13.25 billion. That's a large amount, but there are over 50 billionaires on the Forbes list actually worth more than that. The money itself is provided by the CERN member countries, and a little over 70% of the annual budget is provided by Germany, the U.K., Italy, France and Spain. The money for the experiments also comes from large institutions such as universities and observer governments such as the United States, India, and Russia.
- tacitusarc 6y agoThis is part of the exoteric versus esoteric communication problem.
- mistermann 6y agoVery much so, and it receives little attention, while the consequences receive a massive amount, and are often targeted as what needs addressing, rather than the underlying problem.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI think it's good to occasionally remember that, for all the marvels of medicine - and there are true marvels to behold, no doubt about that - we're still just scratching the surface, and barely even that for many domains of medicine. Biology is extremely complex, and doesn't yield very easily to the methods used in physics to alleviate complexity, since biological systems are extremely inter-connected (whether at the social level or internally) and hard or impossible to separate into clean functions.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> we're still just scratching the surface I think the same can be said of just about any field, but with medicine it's more clear to people who aren't experts in the field, compared to a field like physics. As I understand it, for all of modern medicine's many marvels, it can't do much about the common cold, or tinnitus. I suppose that's analogous to how we have software that can beat any human chess player, but text-to-speech is still a work in progress. Our systems have a harder time moving the pieces than picking world-class chess moves.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI believe (though of course it could well turn out to be wrong) that physics is much closer to understanding the universe than medicine is to understanding the human body. There are big open problems in physics, absolutely. But in the domains where our theories currently apply and that we can experiment on, we can actually use them to predict with extreme accuracy how things will behave, and we have been able to exploit this to create marvels of technology like nuclear reactors, microchips, the LHC, MRIs and many others - all with essentially 100% accuracy in everything they do. In medicine on the other hand, we barely have one drug that works or doesn't work predictably in every person; we're not sure what to measure in someone to understand what potentially impacts any particular disease; we are still discovering entire organs in the human body every year; we have only recently realized that the trillions of bacteria that naturally live in our bodies have more than minor impact on our organism, but we still have little idea of what their effects actually are; and if we start looking at psychiatry or neuro-science or nutrition, we're not even sure we're asking the right questions, nevermind giving any of the right answers. Hell, there are some signs that we may have a microbiome in our brain[0], long thought to be essentially aseptic in healthy humans. [0] https://www.colorado.edu/lab/neurodegeneration/there-brain-microbiome https://www.colorado.edu/lab/neurodegeneration/there-brain-m...
- sgfyd 6y agoIt is really irresponsible and dangerous to post this sort of thing on HN, and dang should be ashamed to leave it up so long. Junk articles like this do nothing but sow public distrust in an extremely trustworthy scientific/medical system.
- pjc50 6y agoAbsolutely the opposite: a healthy correction system is a good sign. It's true that a lot of this stuff should not have been published in the first place, but that's a much harder problem to solve. Good to have a retrospective, in the agile sense, on the HCQ fiasco too.
- lemonspat 6y ago> Any shame you want to should on the authors of that chapter. Why are you so afraid of scientists being corrected here? We have enough bad science You should redirect that shame to the authors listed on this page. Why are you so afraid of scientists being corrected here? Scientists are human and get things wrong. Just like a coding bug, bad science needs to be corrected. So I disagree. What's dangerous about pointing out fault with this example? > 6 In the category of “not retracted but should never have been published,” we’ll offer up this book chapter, which claims that the virus behind the COVID-19 pandemic hitched a ride to Earth on a meteorite.
- sgfyd 6y agoSuggesting COVID-19 science is "bad science" will lead to people dying. You are condoning murder.
- raverbashing 6y agoSurgusphere was the worse fraud of 2020 and I hope people won't forget those involved with it (Discussions of HCQ regardless, talking about effectiveness is one thing, falsifying data is another)
- throway1gjj 6y agoWhere's the WHO+ telling us that masks are dangerous? Was that not retracted?
- swebs 6y agoDo you have a link to the original statement?
- snicksnak 6y agoThere is this one from Dr Maria Van Kerkhove from the WHO [0]: > our recommendations are that in the community we don't recommend the use of masks unless you yourself are sick and as a measure to prevent onward spread from you if you are ill. The masks that we recommend are for people who are at home and who are sick and for those individuals who are caring for those people who are home that are sick. The general advice the WHO gave on masks was > If you are healthy, you only need to wear a mask if you are taking care of a person with suspected 2019-nCoV infection. [1] [0] https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/transcripts/who-audio-emergencies-coronavirus-press-conference-full-30mar2020.pdf https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/transcr... [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20200329083719/https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/advice-for-public/when-and-how-to-use-masks https://web.archive.org/web/20200329083719/https://www.who.i...
- number-sequence 6y agoPossibly a long shot, but I was wondering if you knew of any sources of the CDC also taking this stance? I have a vague memory that they also made similar statements, but I tried to find evidence of that recently and couldn’t find a source. I’d appreciate anybody that could link me to a source if they have it on hand / find one.
- snicksnak 6y agoFauci said in a 60 minutes interview back in March: "Right now, in the United States, people should not be walking around with masks" and "When you're in the middle of an outbreak, wearing a mask might make people feel a little bit better and it might even block a droplet, but it's not providing the perfect protection that people think that it is." [0] However that was before the CDC issued in early april its recommendation to wear masks [1] [0] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/preventing-coronavirus-facemask-60-minutes-2020-03-08/?ftag=CNM-00-10aab5j&linkId=84037176 https://www.cbsnews.com/news/preventing-coronavirus-facemask... [1] https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/04/03/826219824/president-trump-says-cdc-now-recommends-americans-wear-cloth-masks-in-public https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/0...
- nautilus12 6y agoI think maybe the HCQ should have just been one point, I got 5 points in about hcq and how President Trump is dumb, and I gave up. This comes off as yet another political piece as a result even if thats not what it is.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> think maybe the HCQ should have just been one point, I got 5 points in about hcq There were only 3 on HCQ. > and how President Trump is dumb President Trump was mentioned once, in the second HCQ piece, and not in a context which particularly suggested he was dumb. (Arguably, it could be viewed as recontextualizing something for which he was viewed as dumb by many people independently.)
- swebs 6y agoSkip to the section at the bottom titled "It wasn’t all COVID-19"
- pjc50 6y agoIt's not political to say someone's wrong if they are in fact wrong. Although speaking truth to power is unavoidably political ..
- snicksnak 6y ago> Some journals used 2020 to purge what readers perceived to be offensive articles. I hate this so much.
- lqet 6y agoThis was the controversial section in the retracted article in "Angewandte Chemie" which was given as an example: > In the last two decades many groups and/or individuals have been designated with "preferential status". This in spite of the fact that the percentage of women and minorities in academia and pharmaceutical industry has greatly increased. It follows that, in a social equilibrium, preferrential treatment of one group leads to disadvantages for another. New ideologies have appeared and influenced hiring practices, promotion, funding, and recognition of certain groups. Each candidate should have an equal opportunity to secure a position, regardless of personal identification/categorization. The rise and emphasis on hiring practices that suggest or even mandate equality in terms of absolute numbers of people in specific subgroups is counter-productive if it results in discrimination against the most meritorious candidates. Such practice affects the format of interviews and has led to the emergence of mandatory “training workshops” on gender equity, inclusion, diversity, and discrimination. I apologize for my naivety on this topic, but: Isn't this basically saying that if A and B have the same qualifications, but B is a member of a discriminated group, B should be preferred. If A has better qualifications, A should be preferred. I can see that this might be controversial, but what exactly is offensive here (or "appalling" [0])? Am I misunderstanding the section above? [0] https://twitter.com/CIC_ChemInst/status/1269003560357773312?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1269003560357773312%7Ctwgr%5E%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fretractionwatch.com%2F2020%2F06%2F05%2Ffollowing-outrage-chemistry-journal-makes-a-paper-decrying-diversity-efforts-disappear%2F https://twitter.com/CIC_ChemInst/status/1269003560357773312?...
- snicksnak 6y agoSo this guy wrote an opinion piece which some people found ot be controversial. The essay got retracted and the editors suspended. This reminds me of what happened after that Cotton oped in the NYT. Same chain of events.
- 6y ago
- tyho 6y agoI still don't understand how the author of "Can Traditional Chinese Medicine provide insights into controlling the COVID-19 pandemic..." is still employed or why the article has not been retracted.
- admiralspoo 6y agoThis list is too heavily focused on medicine. Where is phosphine on Venus?
- mellosouls 6y agoIt wasn't retracted, why should it have been? The counter analysis reported in November just wasn't as sexy so didn't make such headlines. https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2020/10/22/venus-is-dead-new-analysis-shows-phosphine-a-possible-biosignature-is-absent/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2020/10/22/venu...
- mxcrossb 6y agoOne I didn’t see listed there but is maybe if interest: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2515-2#ref-CR3 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2515-2#ref-CR3 The original paper used games played by humans to produce new optimization algorithms. But actually their implementation of standard algorithms had bugs, so they wrongly thought the new ones were better. Wikipedia article: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_Moves https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_Moves
- MauranKilom 6y agoFrom the Wikipedia sources, this one explains the bug best imo: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2003.05808.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2003.05808.pdf