5 ms·
> I've always found the fact that such information is exposed by default and can thus make a VM obviously not look more like real hardware is puzzling. Eh, it
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
> I've always found the fact that such information is exposed by default and can thus make a VM obviously not look more like real hardware is puzzling.
Eh, it seems to me that software ought to be cooperative by default. Plenty of programs will detect whether you have AMD or nVidia graphics and optimize itself for your hardware—why not VMWare graphics?
Where I agree is that there ought to be an easy checkbox to hide it.
- zensavona 6y agoAnd most importantly, it should be checked by default IMO
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago...no, that's where I don't agree. Again, software should attempt to be truthful by default. There's a reason we allow programs to detect the hardware they're running on—it allows for all sorts of optimizations. Does the VM claim it's network driver was manufactured by Broadcom, or does it go with Cambridge Silicon Radio? Or does it decline to provide a vendor, and if it does, how long until software starts assuming that is the sign of a VM, except this time with potential false positives for users of niche hardware?
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoI think a key distinction is whether we're in an adversarial context or not. And I think loading untrusted applications over network connection from arbitrary third parties is absolutely a position to be distrustful.
- elcomet 6y agoIt could report the host's hardware.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoBut now you're leaking information about the host, which I would think is worse given the purpose of a VM.
- ruslanbogan 6y agoIt would have to emulate the host hardware to do that because the fingerprint is only going to report what's listed in Device Manager for instance.
- userbinator 6y agoDoes the VM claim it's network driver was manufactured by Broadcom, or does it go with Cambridge Silicon Radio? It would simply be whatever the virtual NIC is. Intel ones seem to be pretty common, likely due to wide availability of drivers and documentation.
- ogre_codes 6y agoI agree with this in most cases, but when it comes to Javascript and fingerprinting, I think systems should be as generic as possible. This isn't even a VM versus bare metal thing.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoRight, and so browsers need to fix this! Not because of VMs but because a web page, unlike desktop software, has no business knowing my graphics card.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> Right, and so browsers need to fix this! Makes sense to me. There are a lot of legitimate reasons software on your computer might need to know it's in a VM or what the limits of your VR engine are.
- grimli333 6y agoWell, presumably there may be valid use cases for WebGL applications or games behaving differently according to specific vendors/drivers. It feels like something that needs to be asked permission for, however, so it can’t be used for nefarious purposes.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago...I don't know. I realize this is an entirely subjective view of what a web page should be, but I just don't think any website should know the intricacies of my hardware. The web is a low-friction, low-trust environment; installing a desktop app has more friction, but it also acts as a signal of greater trust. If a website ever really needs to know my hardware, it can ask me to choose from a drop-down. A lot of users won't know what hardware they have—but, those users are also unlikely to understand the implications of a hardware-detection permission prompt.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago