3 ms·
> Apple allows you to buy a computer with more than 8 GB RAM, but I think it's just a trap how to satisfy and charge those who don't believe the reviews and jus
by tomcam 6y ago
> Apple allows you to buy a computer with more than 8 GB RAM, but I think it's just a trap how to satisfy and charge those who don't believe the reviews and just want more RAM whatever it takes.
Just spitballing here, but I’m guessing the OP doesn’t spend much time using DAW sample libraries or editing video.
- honzajavorek 6y agoHi, I'm the author. I don't know what DAW is and I don't spend time editing video. I made my first video in iMovie ever just a few days after I've got the M1 :)
- tomcam 6y agoDAWs or digit audio workstations are for editing sound. In music, that can mean needing to load a 100G file into RAM to get a convincing orchestra or piano sample. So I have a MacPro I bought earlier this year with 384G RAM but... Thanks to blog posts like yours I am also buying a 16G M1 MacBook Pro for general purpose uses such as web development!
- dev_tty01 6y agoYou are probably right. The problem is that it is all grey. Some people do work with large datasets that absolutely perform much better with larger RAM. Some people had bad experiences in the past with slow swap systems and now always believe they need more RAM. Some people look at monitor apps and see that programs allocated large virtual blocks (because they can) and assume they need more physical RAM. Some people had 16 GB systems in the past that they really didn't need and now run an M1 system with 8 GB and find that everything runs fine. What we need are concrete A/B tests. Two identical (other than RAM size) x86 systems running large data set memory hungry tasks that performs significantly better on a 16 GB system than a 8 GB system. Then the same tasks (running native ARM code) on 8 and 16 GB M1 systems with the identical OS version. Ideally a sequence of tests with varying memory demands. Tests like that would at least get in the ballpark of revealing if the M1 systems are somehow more capable with less memory. The rest is just anecdotal. I suspect that M1 systems might handle light swapping a bit more efficiently than the latest x86 systems, but tasks with truly large datasets will ultimately be limited by SSD access rates. Of course, that is just another useless opinion until reasonable test data is available.