3 ms·
An idea I've always liked is a perpetually extendable copyright with rapidly escalating fees. E.g.... First 10 years are free The next 10 years cost $50 - B
by TylerE 6y ago
An idea I've always liked is a perpetually extendable copyright with rapidly escalating fees.
E.g....
First 10 years are free
The next 10 years cost $50 - Basically just enough to make it worth the time to process...basically a bozo filter for abandoned works)
Years 21-30 cost $5,000. - Starting to cost real money, but not overly onerous to anything in active commerce.
Years 31-40 cost $50,000
Years 41-50 cost $500,000 - Worth it only for highly lucrative works
Years 51-60 cost $5,000,000 - You've got to really want it
After that keep adding on zeros, I guess. I haven't really thought about the exact numbers.
I personally have no problem with Disney keeping all rights to Mickey Mouse in perpetum if they write a billion dollar check every year for the privilege.
- forrestthewoods 6y agoSomething like that would be great. That scale actually feels pretty good.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoWhat you're saying is too logical. It'd never fly, sadly. Those who want "intellectual property" to be treated like physical goods should be alright with it being taxed that way too. The social contract should be mutually beneficial, but right now copyright holders get to hold culture hostage and starve the public domain with egregiously long terms.
- dmitriid 6y agoAmazon paid 250 million dollars for the rights to Tolkien's Silmarillion. This proposed scheme will simply lock away most of IP (especially IP with any cultural significance) in the vaults of a few conglomerates.
- webmaven 6y ago> This proposed scheme will simply lock away most of IP (especially IP with any cultural significance) in the vaults of a few conglomerates. The difference being that right now, most IP (regardless of significance) is already being locked up in this way, the conglomerates don't have to pay or take any overt action to keep them locked up, and orphan works are lost when all copies degrade before the lockup period expires (early film, in particular).
- dmitriid 6y agoThe only way to fix it is to reduce copyright terms to a sane number of years. Any monetary schemes don't really work.
- webmaven 6y agoThe above proposal is compatible with this goal, since it reduces the default copyright term, and adds optional paid extensions on a sliding scale. As compromises go, it's pretty decent. I few other wrinkles I'd suggest to reduce friction: a copyright registry is being reintroduced[0] here, and this registry must be made public just like patents and trademarks. Registrations and extensions should also be filed a year before expiration (no fair to create a derivative work based on something that is scheduled for expiration only to have the rug pulled out from under you). This gives the creator plenty of time to register a work after publication, minimizing the burden on copyright owners (currently copyright is granted with no notice or registration required). [0] Okay, not really, a copyright registry still exists today, but given it is optional and only affects the amount of damages you can collect from violations and absence from the registry isn't an affirmative defense, it isn't really comparable to the kind of registry that is needed to make such a scheme work. Nor is it comparable to the functions of the registry as it existed before copyright was made automatic.