3 ms·
Thanks for posting this. Are there cases that set precedent for satire not being protected under the doctrine of Fair Use? I'm not a lawyer so I'm not sure if t
by heavyset_go 6y ago
Thanks for posting this. Are there cases that set precedent for satire not being protected under the doctrine of Fair Use? I'm not a lawyer so I'm not sure if the quoted Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc. case set that precedent, or if it was just quoted to show the difference between parody and satire in the eyes of the law.
- nkurz 6y agoIf others aren't aware, the somewhat formal sounding "Campbell v. Acuff-Rose" regards the legality of 2 Live Crew's cover of Roy Orbison's "Pretty Woman". The Supreme Court held that it was clearly a parody, and thus clearly fair use. Equally clearly, seeing as the Supreme Court was reversing the earlier decision of the Appeals Court, it wasn't actually that clear to some. In any case, it's also a delightful listen to a more innocent era in rap: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rMqnPVU207M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rMqnPVU207M. That said, I'd also be interested in an answer to heavyset_go's question. I think the answer is "no", and that it's only a case of "parody" being a positive example of transformation rather than "satire" being a negative. The decision in this case, for example, doesn't actually even mention the term "satire", and instead relies on the (not particularly well defended) opinion that setting Star Trek in the world of Go! might be transformative for Captain Kirk, but it is "not transformative" to Go!.
- zerocrates 6y agoCampbell v. Acuff-Rose is the precedent at the Supreme Court level for parody, even commercial parody, potentially qualifying as fair use. Other lower courts had held as much in earlier cases, as well as in other cases holding that works were not parody in the sense relevant for copyright (crucially, that they were not commenting on the work they copied from). Campbell not only held that "Pretty Woman" by 2 Live Crew was fair use as parody, but also discussed the distinction of parody and satire: "Parody needs to mimic an original to make its point, and so has some claim to use the creation of its victim's (or collective victims') imagination, whereas satire can stand on its own two feet and so requires justification for the very act of borrowing." To some extent it simply codified a distinction already present in lower court decisions, but as the Supreme Court precedent it set the standard nationwide. The case doesn't explicitly hold that satire is not fair use, or even that parody is fair use. Fair use is a case-by-case, multi-factor test that characteristically lacks bright lines. A "merely" satirical work that copied less of the original, or was extremely transformative, could be fair use. Parody and satire often co-exist and even "parody-ness" is a sliding scale that can affect the analysis. In practice though, Campbell is a pretty "bright-ish" line: if a commercial work obviously copies from an original, a court calling it "satire" as opposed to "parody" is almost certainly not going to find fair use.