3 ms·
I find it extremely ironic. I’m currently finishing “Countdown to Zero Day” and some people are saying that NOBUS (nobody but us) doctrine reduces the attack su
by bayindirh 6y ago
I find it extremely ironic. I’m currently finishing “Countdown to Zero Day” and some people are saying that NOBUS (nobody but us) doctrine reduces the attack surface considerably. Some other people highlight this mentality as extremely dangerous from a defense standpoint.
Ten years after Stuxnet/Flame saga, USA is experiencing a same kind of attack and their stated preparedness has not improved from the levels stated in that book.
It’s fascinating.
Edit: No. I’m not enjoying this. There’s no schadenfreude.
- Threeve303 6y ago> Some other people highlight this mentality as extremely dangerous from a defense standpoint. Often the answer this group offers is yet another third party solution that is popular at the time. Then they give these tools the high level of permissions they need to function. Cycle repeats.
- bayindirh 6y agoNope. They advocate immediate disclosure of zero day exploits found by government and mandatory policies against stocking of these vulnerabilities for using them as/in cyber weapons. That book contains no corporate backing/advertising.
- Threeve303 6y agoSorry, I wasn't referring to the book specifically. Just talking about my experience during these kinds of conversations in government and the corporate world.
- XMPPwocky 6y ago> They advocate immediate disclosure of zero day exploits found by government How do you think governments find these vulnerabilities? Accidentally, under the couch cushions? What you actually seem to be proposing- in practice- is a ban on government-funded vulnerability research.
- bayindirh 6y ago> What you actually seem to be proposing- in practice- is a ban on government-funded vulnerability research. To be completely honest, I don't have a concrete answer to this question yet because I haven't finished the book and didn't give the hard think it requires. However, I can see and both parties' perspective and reasoning. I just need to give these perspectives a good rub with my own views.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoIf the current state of affairs is better than governments not doing any such research, yet responsible disclosure of any vulnerabilities is, in turn, better than keeping them private, then any government that believes in the transitory principle should continue their research and start disclosing their findings.
- mehrdadn 6y agoConfused, how is NOBUS supposed to reduce any attack surface? NOBUS means you don't patch vulnerabilities that you believe only you have access to. Wouldn't that expand an attack surface (or leave it as-is)? How would a refusal to patch decrease attack surface?
- bayindirh 6y agoYou’re right to be confused. NOBUS assumes that other parties do not have the means to find the same vulnerabilities and/or weaponize them with same effectiveness. It also layers this assumption with “we can prevent it at the firewall level so we can actually patch it while they can’t” idea. As we all know, it’s an absolutely brilliant(!) idea.
- vsareto 6y agoI don't see the irony? Was there a zero day that allowed them to trojan the Orion binary? I thought they just had ordinary access to change it. If there wasn't one, NOBUS doesn't really apply here? I haven't seen anything on how they got the initial access to it yet so maybe I've missed it.
- bayindirh 6y agoNOBUS doctrine has implicit, philosophical problems. It may work with kinetic weapons because research is more expensive, obscure, dangerous and accumulation of knowledge has a greater effect. On the cybersecurity side, its effectiveness inherently reduced because any person with a laptop can conduct the same research in principle. So, other parties can find breakthroughs or leapfrog each other with relatively minimal effort. On the other hand, NOBUS has an inherent ego attached. It considers other parties to be inferior permanently. It considers other parties are unable and will be unable forever unless we leak something. This is a flawed thinking in computer science / programming research. The core of the irony has two layers. First the personal one: The timing of reading the book and how the events unfold. Second irony is in the US government. They were aware that they're not ready to defend if someone uses the same weapon against them, however they were so focused to improve their offensive capabilities and failed to secure themselves. Moreover, the attack came via a national software company. They've hit from inside. It's like adding insult to injury.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]