3 ms·
It is not faster than light. I think what he wanted to show was a situation, in which entanglement and quantum mechanics, are superior to classical physics. i.
by Poc 6y ago
It is not faster than light.
I think what he wanted to show was a situation, in which entanglement and quantum mechanics, are superior to classical physics. i.e someone using quantum mechanics would have an advantage over someone who don't.
However, as he said, in this situation the two generals could have agreed on something else, like if it was raining or not.
In fact, something they could have done is to flip a coin, and split with a copy of the result, which they only look at when they launch the attack. It would have the same effect.
With a random variable (the coin flip), that is hidden until revealed, we achieve the same results as quantum mechanics.
Scientist call them "hidden values" and Einstein hopped we could explain the "spooky action at a distance" with such hidden variables. But we can't, Bell proposed an experiment with entangle state which measurement could not be explained by such hidden variables, and Aspect did the experiment and obtained the predicted results.
So there exist situation where we can use entanglement to achieve better results, for example in "non-local games", where players sharing entangled state can win with probability 1, when "classical player" with probability < 1
- bluesign 6y ago“ So there exist situation where we can use entanglement to achieve better results, for example in "non-local games", where players sharing entangled state can win with probability 1, when "classical player" with probability < 1” Do you have an example for this? This is really interesting
- roywiggins 6y agoIt's called "pseudo-telepathy." The wikipedia page has an example of a game: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_pseudo-telepathy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_pseudo-telepathy
- cambalache 6y ago> In fact, something they could have done is to flip a coin, and split with a copy of the result, which they only look at when they launch the attack. It would have the same effect. Yes but the difference is that in this case, the plan already exists from the moment the coin is flipped until the result is revealed to the generals. In the QM case no one (not even God) knows what the result will be until it is actually measured,but once that happens the result is known "instantly" at both places (assuming both coins arrive at the same time), so in that sense is a FTL communication (of course it is not real communication)
- Poc 6y agoAh yes, you're right, I hadn't seen it from that angle.