3 ms·
I have always loved the way GMail protected you from dangerous actions, like deleting an email. Usually software would protect you with a confirmation pop-up:
by combatentropy 6y ago
I have always loved the way GMail protected you from dangerous actions, like deleting an email.
Usually software would protect you with a confirmation pop-up: "Are you sure you want to __________ ?" Instead, GMail just let you do it. Then it added a yellow strip at the top, "Message deleted. [Undo]". So, instead of double-confirmation, GMail implemented Undo more thoroughly.
This was better in two ways:
(1) It wasn't a pop up! I hate pop-ups. I don't think anyone likes pop-ups.
(2) A computer asking you "Are you sure?" is as annoying as a human being questioning everything you say. It is nice every now in then, when it really was an accident. But most of the time, it isn't. Another metaphor is a mechanical device that is failing. You press the button, and it doesn't work. You have to press it again.
The whole approach breaks your flow, implies contempt, and by definition is frustrating.
The approach of "just let you do it and provide an undo" isn't recent anymore, and sadly, Google seems to be drifting away from it. I see more and more pop-ups and "Are you sure?" messages.
- RMPR 6y agoWhile I get and share your point, the downside is: when you miss the yellow strip, you're basically screwed. Being tech savvy, I remember many times this pattern caught me off-guard. How do you think non tech-savvy (who account to the majority of users I guess) will react to this?
- Flimm 6y agoYou can still recover a deleted email from the bin.
- combatentropy 6y agoMaybe you are thinking of situations that I am not. I suppose like anything it can be badly implemented. But in the situations I'm thinking of, the Undo opportunity was unmissable. Besides, I already knew that I had clicked what I clicked. So if I didn't mean it, I knew to look for the Undo.