3 ms·
The problem is one of medical ethics in an unequal society. The problem is that there's a sum of money for which I would have taken the risk and got a vaccine i
by renewiltord 6y ago
The problem is one of medical ethics in an unequal society. The problem is that there's a sum of money for which I would have taken the risk and got a vaccine in January and had exposure to the disease in February.
Everyone in society would have been better off if I had been permitted that. America could have paid me and 49 others a million dollars each and come out wayyy ahead (since direct exposure tests will yield results way faster). Then a 3 month safety protocol and we're off to the races.
But I can make that choice because I am comfortably above subsistence. If I do it, you know it's because it's a combination of bravado, bragging rights, and this money I could survive without.
But if you actually allow the market to price this, the real price for the tester is approximately $10 in sub-Saharan Africa, and we know he's on below subsistence and is really trading his body for another few days of life. We find that doing this is abhorrent.
An interesting effect that inequality prevents us from Pareto optimal actions and improving the human race as a whole.
- pjscott 6y agoA few workarounds spring to mind: 1. Run challenge trials, but don't pay participants in money. Talk up the danger and risk, and publicize the heroism of the people who volunteer. Make a spectacle of it. If you ask for fifty heroes, is there any doubt that you'd get them? 2. Pay participants, but impose a minimum price they need to be paid in order to assuage people's squeamishness. That hypothetical guy in sub-Saharan Africa might be exploited at $10, but if he's getting paid $1,000,000 then he has practically won the lottery. Either of these would be a big improvement over the status quo, where challenge trials aren't run at all and countless people die because of it.
- hnracer 6y agoOr 3. only recruit people who earn over X dollars. Any of these are good solutions.
- winston_smith 6y agoIt's great that you care about poor people, but it's also elitist to treat them like they're too poor to afford free will.
- renewiltord 6y agoMeant to be a summary of the current state-of-the-art in medical ethics not in my personal view of the world (which goes so far as to allow non-fatal organ sales). You can rest assured I neither care about poor people more than other people nor do I wish to infantilize them.