2 ms·
This is great (and would be nice if it did cars and worked with HID office keys, too). I would be a lot happier with a single RFID tag per user (globally; it c
by rdl 16y ago
This is great (and would be nice if it did cars and worked with HID office keys, too).
I would be a lot happier with a single RFID tag per user (globally; it could be your phone with NFC, or a $0.05 tag) which could be remotely added or removed from the ACL on doors (use zigbee or even a 3g chipset built into the door; it only updates infrequently).
That way you don't need to pull your phone out in a dark alley and hit a button to unlock the door, and if your Internet connection is down (or power is out), the door can still unlock.
You could hack this up with the Schlage locksets and new firmware.
I guess it's a question of feature prioritization: no keys at all but a clunkier UX with less features, or a single RFID tag with lots of other benefits.
- 18pfsmt 16y agoAustrian RFID (ISO 14443) company Legic has had a deal with Schlage for a while. And Swedish lock company Assa Abloy ($B conglomerate) also owns HID (and its numerous subsidiaries), which pretty much dominates RFID-based access control, and has had a solution in place for at least 3 years that I know of. Edit: Legic is Austrian, not German. Fixed. Edit 2: I was obsessed with this topic in '06-07 as the RFID startup I worked for struggled to maintain relevance as each use case for RFID proved pathetic ROIs vs existing solutions. I left when it was clear NFC/ payments was the only viable strategy and the startup was unwilling to drop the other verticals and pursue NFC (which is only now about to become viable).
- rdl 16y agoYeah, the value is in having a decent API, easy self-install lockset for homes and small businesses; HID type stuff is almost always professionally installed, requires wiring to the door, etc. The legic/schlage system has really bad software, and the service is lame, too -- bad enough that I bought one and didn't install it on an exterior door. I like the hacker aesthetic of lockitron, but want the robustness of the pro stuff too. Although if they do NFC tag reads in the lockset, it wouldn't be too hard to work as a simple internet-programmable RFID lock.
- 18pfsmt 16y agoSo, just to be clear: ISO 14443 is the RFID standard from which the NFC standard, ISO 18092, is basically derived. There are very minor differences. EDIT: The hope with NFC is that the phone can become a passive (non-power requiring) tag that can be read without internal power. As well, the hope is that it can read tags as well, though they are often referring to ISO 15693 and ISO 14443 (These are considered RFID standards) tags as far as readability (don't even get me started on ISO 14443A vs ISO14443B....Ugh).
- ccamrobertson 16y agoThanks for the idea! I wouldn't be surprised if we move in this direction. People love their fobs, but provisioning for temporary access on the big access control systems is a pain with current panels. The big issue is, of course, hardware development cost in getting active NFC into the locksets. Some of the high end hotel & commercial locksets from Assa and Schlage are adding NFC capabilities, but I suspect the software is plagued by the same, traditional problems.
- 18pfsmt 16y agoJust find a way to abstract all the nonsense. I'd be happy to help you to get test locks ( I have contacts at schlage and Assa Abloy). I don't want to bother you by email w/o permission, however.
- ccamrobertson 16y agoI'd love to hear more about your NFC experience - feel free to drop me a line at cameron@lockitron.com.
- cynix 16y agoDo Schlage or Assa Abloy have standalone battery-powered locks like the Lockitron that uses FeliCa or MIFARE cards?
- rdl 16y ago
- rdl 16y agoBtw, I'd love to talk to you too (email me at ryan@venona.com if you'd like?) about RFID stuff; I worked for an RFID payment company back in 2003 (ViVoTech, implemented paypass and some loyalty card systems), and I've got some friends who want to set up a hardware lab.