4 ms·
Respect to Timnit Gebru for having tried but I don't think it could ever work. 1. Google profits (massively) from AI. 2. Google founds a research team for eth
by throwaway927219 6y ago
Respect to Timnit Gebru for having tried but I don't think it could ever work.
1. Google profits (massively) from AI.
2. Google founds a research team for ethics in AI.
How on earth could 2. be independent research? It's like a tobacco company funding research into the health effects of tobacco. I can't see it as anything other than a PR move and maybe also trying to steer the ethics research into directions that don't hurt 1.
- blfr 6y ago1. Google profits (massively) from AI. Do they? Genuine question. They have some impressive achivements, like AlphaGo, but they seem to be making money mostly from the regular old keywords and search.
- marcinzm 6y agoTechnically Google makes money from advertising not search. And advertising has been driven by AI for the last two decades. You can't do proper ctr, conversion, bid, etc. predictions otherwise. edit: Even search uses state of the art language models right now but I assume the gains are incremental. Advertising on the other hand is based on predicting the CTR and the gains from doing that versus naive bid approaches are 40%+.
- js8 6y agoI agree. However, I disagree with this statement: "Former Googler Leslie Miley said he does not believe Google would have handled it the same way if Gebru were a white man. " James Damore was also fired from Google, also in a controversy about ethics. I think this is really about freedom of expression, and debate. It's impossible to have this within (and outside) a corporation, because employees are not protected enough. This could be solved by having stronger unions. Unfortunately, the minority card is now used to divide the employees. I suggest listening to something of what Adolph Reed says about this.
- marcinzm 6y agoUnions at best enact the will of the workers and I wonder if most Google employees would prefer all this ethical drama to just stop. In that case a union would most likely have a rule banning all debates on controversial or non-work topics (on the job using google equipment). Which would lower the amount of debate rather than increase it. Unions aren't a magical solution to all problems.
- js8 6y agoI don't understand why would unions ever support such rule. It goes exactly against union organizing.
- DharmaPolice 6y agoIf they wanted genuinely independent research they would just put x million dollars into some trust which would fund ring fenced research positions at a University for the next ten or twenty years. The idea of someone being independent while directly on payroll (and reporting to Google management or even the Alphabet board) is ridiculous.