2 ms·
Even if RFC 4180 was a standard, which isn’t, and everyone in the world strictly adhered to it, it would still be a poor choice for archival purposes.
by mulmen 6y ago
Even if RFC 4180 was a standard, which isn’t, and everyone in the world strictly adhered to it, it would still be a poor choice for archival purposes.
- foolmeonce 6y ago> it would still be a poor choice for archival purposes. It isn't being compared to all formats, it is being compared to sqlite. Some random version of one implementation written in C, stored in "fossil" may be good enough for the library of Congress, but that kind of nonsense went too far for even browser makers to take seriously. Meanwhile it is trivial to read and infer data from formats like CSV to either use directly or automate a reading process with any tools that exist now or in the future.
- foolmeonce 6y agoPerhaps I should have cited the official reference which makes it clear that the viewpoint in this article was at best too optimistic: https://www.w3.org/TR/webdatabase/ https://www.w3.org/TR/webdatabase/
- laumars 6y ago> Even if RFC 4180 was a standard, which isn’t It is an informal. RFC just says it's not defining the Internet standard. The reason being, and as I'd already pointed out, CSV predates RFC 4180 by 3 decades so what the RFC is really setting out is to describe what those established conventions are and what the MIME type should be. That doesn't mean that what the RFC describes isn't already a convention (it's the same specifications as published by IBM, W3C and many other big hitters). > it would still be a poor choice for archival purposes. I hadn't suggested it was a good choice for archival purposes. You're building a straw man argument there. My point was that there is a conventional standard to CSV and that is very well documented. The issue with CSV is that it's so easy to write a parser that some developers do so without bothering to read any documentation on how CSV should be parsed. That's not the fault of CSV, that's the fault of lazy developers. But I do completely agree that CSV has other faults (which I had also discussed too).