4 ms·
FWIW, I hate this about the couple of apps I use that do this (with no other option, e.g. Notion added a password option). And not for privacy concerns, as a s
by OJFord 6y ago
FWIW, I hate this about the couple of apps I use that do this (with no other option, e.g. Notion added a password option).
And not for privacy concerns, as a sibling thread is discussing, but simply because I find it considerably less convenient than a password, as most things use, and as I'm set up to conveniently use and expect.
It's especially annoying when setting up a new device - oh right yes, obviously I need to set up my email app before this one...
And what if I don't have or want or can't currently for whatever reason receive email on that device? Now I'm trying to get it there by some other means, only to find it times out in the process.
(This is all happened to me, and enough that I'm ranting about it...)
- cstejerean 6y agoFor anything I use with any kind of regularity I’d hate it. I already have this problem with services that decide they really need to send me some code by email because they don’t recognize my device (because it’s been more than 30 days and Safari killed their cookies). And then every once in a while the email doesn’t show up for 45 minutes for some reason, leaving me with no recourse. But for certain things that I need to do say once a year (let’s say renew some kind of registration or insurance) I wouldn’t mind it. Because chances are I already do this because I forgot to save the password in my password manager last time and now I need to do a reset password flow anyway.
- movedx 6y ago> For anything I use with any kind of regularity I’d hate it. I already have this problem with services that decide they really need to send me some code by email because they don’t recognize my device (because it’s been more than 30 days and Safari killed their cookies). And then every once in a while the email doesn’t show up for 45 minutes for some reason, leaving me with no recourse. It's incredible to me how impatient we've become as a society. As everything is given to us faster and faster, with less and less financial cost, the more we demand this of everything going forward. Anything that comes shy of this demand by mere minutes is shunned as unacceptable.
- jhardy54 6y ago> I'm really glad I decided to meditate and learn to be a more patient person. A friendly nudge: google 'spiritual ego trap' and then read this comment again.
- movedx 6y agoI don't believe that's required. I'm not saying I'm better than anyone else, I'm simply pointing out that having now slowed down and become more patient, I don't complain when accessing information from the other side of the planet takes 3 minutes instead of 3 seconds. That is what this essentially boils down to: convenience and patience. We're losing the latter because of the former.
- Armisael16 6y agoYou may want to work on your phrasing then, because that was sure the way it came off. You say that culturally we’re a certain way and then that you feel that you’re a better person for being different.
- movedx 6y agoI'll take onboard for next time. Appreciate it.
- greggman3 6y agoI don't get this comment. I've been in plenty of situations where I need something now. Doctors office, DMV, tax office, etc... It's not about being impatient. It's about knowing that it should be instant and it not being instant. If you turned on your water faucet, shower, or flushed your toilet and water didn't run for 45 minutes most people would be shocked.
- mattowen_uk 6y ago> Flush Button Push Detected > Contacting Toilet Cloud Server... > 503 Service Unavailable > Alert User: "Water Unavailable, Please try Later."
- flemhans 6y agoI access almost all services in private tabs, i.e. cookies are not persisted, and let my password manager do the login.
- RandallBrown 6y agoI don't love this either, but it's basically the same inconvenience as having multi factor authentication turned on. There's something very appealing about not having a password that I need to store anywhere for that service too.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I don't love this either, but it's basically the same inconvenience as having multi factor authentication turned on. MFA usually uses channels that are intended to be relative low latency (or that don't require realtime out-of-band transmission, like TOTP). Email, OTOH, isn't generally reliably low-latency
- RandallBrown 6y agoIs there a technical detail of email that I don't know about that makes it less low-latency than a text message? Email or text would work the same for this auth scheme anyway.
- hunter2_ 6y agotangent: SMS doesn't have the security needed for most things. We can let it be a part of auth when combined with another factor, albeit begrudgingly.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoSMS can be delivered days late. It isn't any better than email.
- pelasaco 6y agoAnd as I discovered in my own service: If the SMS aren't being sent - or the clients aren't getting them - there are so many parts involved that's really hard to pinpoint the problem and get an ETA for the solution..
- tonoto 6y ago
- wdb 6y agoYeah, I am not a fan of magic tokens / login by email address either. It's a pain to need to message yourself with a token url and then the messenger app does previews which renders the token invalid and then you need to save a text file with the url in it, send it open it, copy paste the url into the browser. Just to login. Sure, you could say, why don't setup your email on your devices but I shouldn't need to do that. Just to use your website. These magic links are just not user friendly