4 ms·
> The study compared countries that passed tax cuts in a specific year, such as the U.S. in 1982 when President Ronald Reagan slashed taxes on the wealthy, with
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> The study compared countries that passed tax cuts in a specific year, such as the U.S. in 1982 when President Ronald Reagan slashed taxes on the wealthy, with those that didn't, and then examined their economic outcomes.
All of these studies consistently miss one thing.
Effective tax rates haven't really changed since before Reagan.
Prior to Reagan, the tax code was riddled with loopholes. Not like how it is now where corporations do this and that, but much worse. Rich individuals were just deducting everything they buy from their taxes.
The Reagan "tax cuts" did two things. One, they closed a lot of those loopholes. Two, they significantly lowered nominal rates. The two things basically canceled out. There was never any meaningful reduction in government revenue.
- gumby 6y agoThey did a third thing which was to make the tax system more regressive. That was by deliberate design: there is a specific argument for it going back to Burke at least. I strongly disagree with it but I understand the argument.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWhether or not that was their stated intent, it isn't what they actually did. Here's the effective rate table going back to before Regan: https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/historical-average-federal-tax-rates-all-households https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/historical-averag... Not exactly huge differences before and after. And compare the recent effective rates to the ones at the start of the table. About the same for the top quintile, significantly lower for all the others. So we should be seeing a reduction in wealth inequality then, right? Or at worst it should stay the same, so why are we seeing the opposite? Obviously this doesn't prove that the thing that hasn't actually been tried would actually help, but it does point to the idea that maybe the problem lies somewhere else entirely. For example, lack of effective antitrust enforcement.
- gumby 6y agoThose are the rate charts before deductions. Most deductions are meaningless at the low end of the income spectrum. Find a chart of % payment by quintile and you'll get a different picture. Apologies that I can't find one in a quick search before running to dinner but there was good work done by the NBER on this. Edit: by % payment by quintile I mean what percentage of total income is paid by each quintile, not what percentage of total taxes is paid by each one.
- WillPostForFood 6y agoYou are right, Federal receipts have been hovering between ~15-17% of GDP since WWII, regardless of whether the top tax rate was 90% or 28%. There is more variation due to changes in growth than changes in rates. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S
- jacques_chester 6y agoThe sentence immediately prior to the Reagan reference: > The new paper ... examines 18 developed countries — from Australia to the United States — over a 50-year period from 1965 to 2015. And from the original paper[0]: > Many empirical studies look at single tax policy indicators to identify tax cuts for the rich. However, there is some disagreement on measuring taxes on the rich in the literature. First, there is no consensus on which taxes to look at. Whilst some authors look at taxes on personal income (Egger et al., 2019; Rubolino and Waldenström, 2020), others focus on corporate taxation (Devereux et al., 2002) or inheritance taxation (Piketty and Saez, 2013b). Second, economists have used different tax policy indicators. Some look at top marginal income tax rates (Piketty et al., 2014), while others look at effective tax rates (Egger et al., 2019) or revenue generation (Baunsgaard and Keen, 2010). We propose an encompassing approach that utilises Bayesian latent variable analysis on a range of different taxes and indicators to overcome these problems. This allows us to detect shared variance across 7 indicators that are commonly used proxies for taxes on the rich (see Table A1 in the Appendix). In total, the data cover 18 OECD democracies over 5 decades (1965-2015). We estimate the latent variable using a Bayesian Markov-Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) approach with diffuse normal priors, three MCMC chains and 1000 burnin iterations (for more information on the estimation of the latent variable, see Hope and Limberg, 2020). It's likely that professionals have a better grasp of the nuances of empirical tax research than you or I. [0] http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/107919/1/Hope_economic_consequences_of_major_tax_cuts_published.pdf http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/107919/1/Hope_economic_consequences...
- wffurr 6y agoThe actual paper where you can read their analysis for yourself: http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/107919/1/Hope_economic_consequences_of_major_tax_cuts_published.pdf http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/107919/1/Hope_economic_consequences... That's a nice just-so story, but it's not supported by the evidence. You can read for yourself in the original paper, but the authors used a pretty sophisticated approach to measuring taxes: " We propose an encompassing approach that utilises Bayesian latent variable analysis on a range of different taxes and indicators to overcome these problems. This allows us to detect shared variance across 7 indicators that are commonly used proxies for taxes on the rich (see Table A1 in the Appendix)"
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> That's a nice just-so story, but it's not supported by the evidence. Here is the evidence: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S It is supported by the evidence. > You can read for yourself in the original paper, but the authors used a pretty sophisticated approach to measuring taxes: So sophisticated a model that it can measure the impact of a change in tax revenues that didn't meaningfully occur?
- wffurr 6y agoThat chart says absolutely nothing about tax rates on the rich.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIf the rich pay most of the taxes (because they have most of the money), and taxes on the poor and middle class didn't meaningfully increase, and the total amount of taxes being paid didn't meaningfully change, what does that tell you about the amount of taxes paid by the rich?
- 6y ago
- specialist 6y ago> All of these studies consistently miss one thing. Effective tax rates haven't really changed since before Reagan. I'm not following you. You've cited stable effective income tax rates and gross federal tax receipts. OC says supply side policies led to greater inequity. Do your cites refute their claim? Mea culpa: I don't understand this OC's measure of inequity. I'd be grateful if someone could do an ELI5 comparing it to the Gini coefficient. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"Prior to Reagan, the tax code was riddled with loopholes." A friend who used to work at DOJ many years ago told me that the greatest ever expansion of the US tax code was during the administration that came in after Reagan.
- cosmiccatnap 6y agoI can't for the life of me understand how people get the misconception that this one factoid equates to a tax rate equivalent in some magical vague way. 1. If it closed any loopholes it only did so to open more convenient ones we are currently still struggling with that go to wealthy individuals and companies far more than the middle class, which most of those loopholes you are taking about were for prior to reagan. They were less loopholes and more accurately social safety nets put in place after the great depression. 2. The "effective" tax rate is a more or less meaningless number contrived to hide the nature of what is actually occuring. It's a way of obviscating the raw revenue but you can very easily cut through it by simply counting the currency in circulation and determining how much of it is in the hands of the wealthy vs regular people. When you do that you find that raw inequality is on par with what it was on the eve of the great depression and there are plenty of papers to support that this is no coincidence. Secondly you conveniently lock the rate at regan without pointing out that immediately prior to regan there were significant changes in taxation. In the 50s for example it wasn't uncommon to tax a CEO and their company at 90%, which is widely different than the tax rates we see now even if we use the arbitrarily designed "effective" qualifier. 3. This makes assumptions that the tax rate reflects actual taxation which it doesn't. You are correct that if you look at the books quickly the effective tax rate seems on the level but look even a bit more closely and things quickly don't add up. Many companies corporations and individuals pay nothing yearly in taxes by using the location of their business to avoid having to be taxes in one country vs another or one state/province over another. They flood vast sums of money to shell companies and then report themselves as only having earned 300,000 (as bezos has done for the last 5 years) in order to present this falsehood that he doesn't take the money, but instead he gets paid in stock which can be far more flexible with taxation and isn't accounted for in your "effective tax rate"