3 ms·
Entomologist E.O Wilson said about communism, "great idea, wrong species". It's basically how I feel about 'free software'. There's a very straight forward reas
by Barrin92 6y ago
Entomologist E.O Wilson said about communism, "great idea, wrong species". It's basically how I feel about 'free software'. There's a very straight forward reason why, as the author points out, free software projects are run by lone developers and lack resources. Because free software, by its own stated mission goal, basically has no good way to reap the rewards for the benefits it brings to the public. It's a great idea in the wrong economic system.
- skavi 6y agowrong culture maybe, but their have definitely been successful communal societies. And there have definitely been successful free software projects.
- Barrin92 6y agoI spent a year in a kibbutz, I am definitely aware that there's success on the margins. But it very much has to exist in the crevasses of the system. The 'free software' movement is explicitly ethical for that reason, it is hard to justify it on economic grounds, and free software is undersupplied for that reason.
- tehjoker 6y agoFeudalism seemed like an immovable foundation of the world until it wasn't. The problem with free software is the need for private competition to restrict people to make money. In a cooperative vs a competitive economy, this idea would come to the forefront. For more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalist_Realism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalist_Realism
- jcranmer 6y ago> Feudalism seemed like an immovable foundation of the world until it wasn't. When I see a statement like this, I must immediately ask: what do you consider to be feudalism, and when do you think it existed?
- tehjoker 6y agoFeudalism was a system of land ownership and military service for nobles and peasants more-or-less tied to the land working for the nobles. Urbanization and capitalism eventually overturned this system with most of the vestiges wiped out after WW1 when many monarchies became republics. It existed mostly in the middle ages up to the 1700s/1800s and was eroded unevenly around the world (notably the USSR confronted the system directly in 1917).
- phkahler 6y agoLone developers have the option of dual licensing, and I think more people should do that. Use GPLv3 or even AGPL for the free version and offer commercial license as well.
- _jal 6y agoIdeological commitments like this are just blinding. People convince themselves of something and literally can no longer see things right in front of them. > free software projects are run by lone developers and lack resources I'm sure nonsense like this gets sage nods when presented in front of of nontechnical executives, and there are indeed projects this describes. It doesn't describe RedHat, Ubuntu, Postgres, the Linux kernel, any number of Apache Foundation projects... it is either ignorant or dishonest cherry-picking. > It's a great idea in the wrong economic system. Economics is a useful domain of study, but studying economics does bad things to a certain kind of person.
- Barrin92 6y agoThe Linux kernel does not capture the market value that it provides to its users, or Torvalds net worth would look more like Gates. Neither does Ubuntu or Postgres, and Red Hat has commercialised services rather than software. In your reflexive attack on economics you seem to have misunderstood my point. I think free software is good, it's also on an organisational level successful, but it does not capture its own value, that much is fairly obvious, which answers the question of the author 'why is free software not mainstream?'
- _jal 6y ago'Reflexive' is a bizarre term to use, but I guess you're just looking for a generic devaluing term. I heard your point loud and clear, it is hardly subtle, or novel. But in your rush to tell me how wrong I am, you missed mine, which is that you can't see what is in front of your face. Free software is mainstream. It hasn't supplanted all other development models, and it hasn't conquered every market, but it doesn't need to. The fantasists/propagandists claiming it is fringy have yet to square that view with, say, the reality that stodgy F100 insurance companies migrated their LOB workloads to it years ago. The fact that it is mainstream means that the model that lead to this conclusion needs modification.
- TulliusCicero 6y agoBut some free software is mainstream. Just look at the Linux kernel. You don't have to necessarily 'capture value' in the capitalist/market sense to be successful.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> free software projects are run by lone developers and lack resources Sometimes. The Linux kernel is developed mostly by paid professionals, as is OpenJDK, Chromium, and Firefox.